Found July 30, 2012 on CJ Sports NFL Talk:
[caption id="" align="alignleft" width="300"]English: Deng Linlin English: Deng Linlin (Photo credit: Wikipedia)[/caption] After watching the Olympic Games over the weekend, I became very upset and disappointed in hearing about a certain rule during the Women’s Gymnastics competition.  There are some stipulations to the rules/competition format that need to be addressed, because it makes no sense overall.  The rules state “The best 24 individual gymnasts (maximum two from each country) go through to the Individual All-Around final, where gymnasts compete on all apparatus.”  This is where the problem lies. The rule states that the best 24 individual gymnast qualify to compete in the All-Around finals, but the words in the parentheses completely contradicts the fact that the top 24 will not move on, unless it was actually the top 2 from each country in that order.  I understand the committee wanting each country to be represented, but it doesn’t make it fair to the top athletes in the competition. Here is the order of the top 24 competitors: 1 Russian Federation KOMOVA Victoria 60.632 Q + 2 United States of America RAISMAN Alexandra 60.391 Q + 3 United States of America DOUGLAS Gabrielle 60.265 Q + 4 United States of America WIEBER Jordyn 60.032 + 5 Russian Federation MUSTAFINA Aliya 59.966 Q + 6 People's Republic of China DENG Linlin 57.998 Q + 7 Italy FERRARI Vanessa 57.932 Q + 8 Japan TERAMOTO Asuka 57.865 Q + 9 Romania IORDACHE Larisa Andreea 57.800 Q + 10 People's Republic of China HUANG Qiushuang 57.707 Q + 11 Romania IZBASA Sandra Raluca 57.532 Q + 12 Russian Federation GRISHINA Anastasia 57.332 + 13 Venezuela LOPEZ Jessica 56.665 Q + 14 Germany SEITZ Elisabeth 56.466 Q + 15 Great Britain TUNNEY Rebecca 56.391 Q + 16 Guatemala GOMEZ PORRAS Ana Sofia 56.132 Q + 17 Great Britain WHELAN Hannah 55.699 Q + 18 Canada PEGG Dominique 55.657 Q + 19 Netherlands van GERNER Celine 55.632 Q + 20 Italy FERLITO Carlotta 55.500 Q + 21 Great Britain PINCHES Jennifer 55.266 + 22 People's Republic of China YAO Jinnan 54.798 + 23 Switzerland STEINGRUBER Giulia 54.715 Q + 24 Australia LITTLE Emily 54.498 Q Looking at the results, 4 of the top 24 did not qualify and 2 of the top 12 did not qualify.  It shows that those athletes were better in the events, at least for that day.  It also shows that not every country is represented, so in my opinion the top 24 in that order should be able to compete for the Gold medal.

Jordyn Wieber, the reigning world champion, needs to be consoled by coach Jenny Zhang following qualifier. (AP/Gregory Bull)

The most disappointing part of the rules and process is that the individual all-around world champion Jordyn Wieber, who placed 4th in the qualifying round was disqualified from competing the finals due to the rules.  It is safe to say that Wieber made mistakes during her routines, but at the end of the day she should be able to compete, because she earned a chance to be there and because she is the world champion. The top 3 teams in the competition each had 3 athletes to place in the top 24 and they all should be allowed to compete for a Gold medal.  If they Olympic Committee wanted all of the countries to be apart of it, that is one thing, but not allowing the top athletes to compete under these circumstances is bad for business. Related articles Enhanced by Zemanta



Wieber still has chance to be champion

There is no joy in saying this to a 17-year-old whose entire world has just come crashing down around her, but it must be said because too much rests on her hearing it: Jordyn Wieber, US-gymnastics anointed star who failed Sunday to qualify for the all-around finals, needs to get over it. Right now. Perhaps her coach, John Geddert, has already impressed upon Wieber that her country...

Wieber bounces back to anchor US gold-medal push

All Jordyn Wieber needed to bounce back from the biggest disappointment of her career was a little pep talk. Teammate McKayla Maroney was only too happy to provide one. Thanks to a few kind words from her best friend, Wieber returned to her world championship form in the women's gymnastics team finals on Tuesday, helping the U.S. to its first gold medal since Atlanta in 1996...

Wieber's Olympic dreams come to end

Shortly after failing to qualify for the individual all-around finals, the face of USA Gymnastics walked unsteadily past the media. Jordyn Wieber walked with wide eyes, steered by a handler, past her teammates, including the two who had replaced her in an event she was expected to dominate. Even then the tears would not stop. Aly Raisman, who came from nowhere to vault ahead of...

World Champion Jordyn Wieber Will Miss All-Around Final

Defending world champion in gymnastics all-around, Jordyn Wieber, has failed to qualify for the finals and will not medal. Wieber only finished third out of the US team and, per Olympic rules, a country can only carry two members for the individual all-around finals. Aly Raisman and Gabby Douglas will represent the Americans in the event. Raisman was surprised that she learned...

US team's medal hopes hinge on Wieber

The U.S. women's gymnastics team, on the cusp of claiming only the second team gold in American history, enters Tuesday's team finals with one person on whom everything could turn: Jordyn Wieber. This is the best women's squad America has produced since the Magnificent Seven won the country's only team gold medal at the 1996 Games in Atlanta. But its most talented...

Team USA Day Two Medal Count, And Some Olympic Thoughts

Day two of the London Olympics is in the books. Sure many of our watching our Female Gymnasts on Qualification day on the TV (paying special attention to Michigan Native Jordyn Wieber of course), but for the most part the day has come to an end. We still have yet to see the men’s relay team on TV, but for those of us who have been following the games full time over the past few...

US, Russian women set for gymnastics showdown

The Americans need Jordyn Wieber to regain her swagger in a hurry if they're going to hold off Russia for Olympic gold. The two gymnastic powers have been trading places in team competition for two years and will face off again on the biggest stage for an Olympic title Tuesday night. The Russians won the world championship in 2010, then finished second to the U.S. last year...

US, Russia set for showdown

The Americans need Jordyn Wieber to regain her swagger in a hurry if they're going to hold off Russia for Olympic gold. The two gymnastic powers have been trading places in team competition for two years and will face off again on the biggest stage for an Olympic title Tuesday night. The Russians won the world championship in 2010, then finished second to the U.S. last year...

US makes quest for gold look easy

This was the moment they had waited for their entire lives, the moment America had waited for since 1996, the moment the rest of the gymnastics world had feared as London approached: Each member of the U.S. women's gymnastics team walking slowly toward the podium, the gold medals being carried onto the floor theirs and theirs alone, American dominance in the sport now absolute...

U.S. Women Gymnasts take Olympic gold in London

Ballertainment The Women’s USA Gymnastics team earned the gold medal for team competition Tuesday in London. Gabby Douglas, Aly Raisman, Jordyn Wieber, McKayla Maroney, and Kyla Ross, along with their coaches, excitedly await the overall scores … Team USA stands proudly as the United States National Anthem is played and the flag is raised… The ladies contributed strong performances...
All Sports News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.