Originally written on Rumors and Rants  |  Last updated 11/22/12
Former USC running backs coach Todd McNair essentially had his career ended by the NCAA’s punishment of the school’s football program. The NCAA ruled that McNair “knew or should have known” about payments from a wannabe sports agent to running back Reggie Bush, despite a serious lack of evidence. Now McNair is suing the NCAA, claiming the organization’s investigation was one-sided and his career was hurt by it’s report on the scandal. On Wednesday a judge in a Los Angeles court agreed, and ruled that the NCAA was “malicious” in it’s investigation of McNair and USC. Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Frederick Shaller denied the NCAA’s appeal to throw out McNair’s lawsuit, and his 10-page ruling was scathing. He claimed – among other things – that emails between an NCAA worker and a person who works in the agency’s appeals decision “tend to show ill will or hatred” toward McNair. Shaller also said he was convinced that the actions of NCAA investigators were “over the top” in this case. McNair’s attorney Bruce Broillet claimed during the hearing that the records showed the agency knew it was relying on false statements about McNair’s conduct in an attempt to “nail” him. Broillet continued: “The emails proved they wanted to get McNair in order to impose the heavier penalties they wanted on USC. So they wrote the evidence the way they wanted it to be – and that’s malice. They got it all wrong on purpose.” Essentially, Shaller agreed saying, “I think it was directed to an outcome.” The NCAA’s attorney, Laura Wytsma, denied that claim, saying evidence showed that the committee investigating McNair (and USC) was trying to get it’s report right. That said, her quote about the process is telling: “They were struggling to get the right result.” Well I guess it depends on what your opinion of the “right result” is. Shaller also claimed he saw no reason for the records in the case to be sealed, because the public has a right to know what went on behind the scenes. The NCAA obviously will appeal that decision because it doesn’t want the files from this case to become public. At one point during the hearing on Wednesday Wytsma even admitted that chief NCAA investigator Richard Johanningmeier actually got certain facts of the case wrong. For a long time it has been obvious that the evidence didn’t add up to the penalties in the USC case. It seemed like the NCAA came to its conclusion before it had actually investigated the matter. While no one associated with USC has claimed that Bush didn’t receive benefits, they have argued how much the school really could have done to prevent it if its employees truly didn’t know what was going on. Basically the case comes down to the NCAA’s finding of unethical conduct against McNair. The organization concluded that he lied in answers to investigators, but the actual evidence may not support those claims. The NCAA contends it simply found Lloyd Lake (the multiple-felon who provided benefits to Bush) more credible than McNair. They believed one and not the other. For those unaware, Bush received benefits from a Lake, who had no connection to USC. The school claimed the team’s coaches had no idea what had transpired in San Diego – more than 100 miles from the campus – between Lake, Bush and his parents. This ruling is a gigantic black eye for the NCAA and vindicates what USC has claimed for years: that the organization was trying to make an example of the school before the evidence was even collected.
GET THE YARDBARKER APP:
Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45
MORE FROM YARDBARKER

Seguin called out by former Maple Leafs CEO for partying

No suspension for Sarkisian was made in best interest of USC

Jim Tomsula disputes report Jarryd Hayne has made 49ers

Report: Brady case judge once vacated CBA violation ruling

Why no. 4 Baylor will and won't win the National Championship

Is D'Angelo Russell in over his head?

LIKE WHAT YOU SEE?
GET THE DAILY NEWSLETTER:

Percy Harvin voices support for Tyrod Taylor

Richardson pleads not guilty to traffic, resisting arrest charges

Andrew Luck tried not to watch Super Bowl, was still ‘salty’

RG3 blames intern for liking Instagram post trashing owner

Former USC linebacker suing school over insurance policy

Report: Fred Jackson expected to sign with Seahawks

All Sports News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

By clicking "Sign Me Up", you have read and agreed to the Fox Sports Digital Privacy Policy and Terms of Use. You can opt out at any time. For more information, please see our Privacy Policy.
the YARDBARKER app
Get it now!
Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45

The Opening Drive: Jamal Anderson warns UM fans before heading to Salt Lake City

Best and worst MLB players in August

RG3 blames intern for liking Instagram post trashing owner

Four most surprising roster cuts from NFL teams

Raiders cut Trent Richardson

Caroline Wozniacki smoking cover of ‘Rhapsody’

Everett Golson named FSU's starting QB

Urban Meyer won't announce QB before season

Teammates relieved RG3 was benched?

Five NFL teams that should trade for Robert Griffin III

Today's Best Stuff
For Publishers
Company Info
Help
Follow Yardbarker