Originally written on The Detroit Sports Site  |  Last updated 11/9/14
lakelandlocal, Flickr Jose Valverde cost the Detroit Tigers another win on Wednesday, coughing up a two-run lead in the ninth inning en route to a 3-2, 10-inning loss to Kansas City. Even though Jim Leyland continues to stand his ground on Valverde as the closer, it’s apparent that the Tigers cannot get by like this for much longer. So, what’s Plan B? (Or Plan C, if Bruce Rondon was Plan A?) ESPN.com pitched — pun intended — a couple of ideas: Buster Olney cited a Tigers’ “rival evaluator” as saying that Jonathan Papelbon’s the man for the job; David Schoenfield wrote that Drew Smyly should get a crack, while the Tigers try to pry Jesse Crain from the White Sox. Which way should Detroit go? The Detroit Sports Site staff airs its opinions in our latest Roundtable … Chris Burke: I can’t believe we have to have this conversation in mid-June. Scratch that, I can believe it, but I’m annoyed that we have to, because everyone outside of Dave Dombrowksi knew this is the point the Tigers would reach without addressing the closer spot in the offseason. Personally, I’d move Benoit into the closer role and try some combination of Smyly and, oh, Luke Putkonen in the setup spot. Maybe Benoit tanks … but then they’re right back where they are now. Plus, a setup guy would be easier to come by than a closer. And if the Tigers are willing to take on Papelbon’s $13 million-a-year average for the next two or three seasons, why didn’t they just sign Rafael Soriano at $14 million? Max DeMara: As I’ve written, I believe Papelbon to be the best option for the Tigers. Smyly and Benoit can be toyed with in the joint closer role for the rest of June and July to buy time if Jose Valverde is disposed of, but that combo would be far too uncertain and awkward to head into the playoffs with. Besides, each is needed more in their usual roles. Detroit’s probably not getting Crain from a division rival like Chicago, so Papelbon, if the Phillies decide to sell, is the best option. Owed $13 million, he’s expensive contractually and might cost a few prospects, but he’s also closed a World Series win and maintains an excellent playoff ERA (1.00) along with seven saves. Moreover, with a mix of confidence and arrogance, he’s got the right attitude for the job. That’s precisely the kind of closer the Tigers need to go anywhere down the stretch and in the playoffs this year. If a World Series title is truly the objective in Detroit, Dave Dombrowski needs to get serious and add a championship level closer sooner rather than later no matter the cost. Papelbon would be the perfect fit. Andrew Tomlinson: I am a big fan of using Benoit or Smyly as the closer as it gives the team versatility while also capitalizing on resources inside of the organization, instead of having to mortgage huge assets to pull in a closer. Smyly and Benoit have been stellar together and with Smyly not having a place in the rotation for the foreseeable future, moving him to closer is a way for the Tigers to get the most value out of their asset. Additionally, Papelbon is also, well, not that great. Many forget his closing seasons with the Boston Red Sox when he was one of the most unreliable closers in the league. On top of that, what are the Tigers going to give up to get Papelbon? Is Smyly a trade piece; or Rick Porcello, who has suddenly turned it around? Is anyone really willing to part with Avisail Garcia, Nick Castellanos or Bruce Rondon for a guy who may be good but is not guaranteed to succeed? I’d imagine many would say no. A Smyly-Benoit combo fixes a hole in the team while not really creating another need. This team always needed another setup arm in the bullpen and moving Smyly or Benoit does not change that, but it does shore up one of the team’s biggest question marks.
Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45

Jon Gruden: Bears need to move on from Jay Cutler

Blue Jays OF tears meniscus in freak sprinkler accident

Death threats show why some fans take sports too seriously

Five bubble teams playing well heading into March

Falcons release Steven Jackson


Bill Walton has some words of advice for Derrick Rose

Five under-the-radar National Player of the Year candidates

Judge overturns Peterson suspension; NFL to appeal

Dez Bryant's mother in 2012: Dez threatened to knock me out

Full offseason breakdown for all 32 NFL teams

Brandon Bostick received death threats after botched play

Rex Ryan has truck with Buffalo Bills paint scheme

WATCH: Sidney Crosby catches teammate's stick in mid-air

WATCH: Vanderbilt coach tells own player 'I'll f-ing kill you'

Are the Kings willing to trade DeMarcus Cousins?

Johan Santana signed by Blue Jays to minor league deal

Leafs trade David Clarkson to Blue Jackets For Nathan Horton

Panthers acquire Jaromir Jagr from Devils

Russell Westbrook is surging into the MVP conversation

HBO picks up The Rock’s football series, ‘Ballers’

The key offseason moves for every MLB team

Giancarlo Stanton gets first-ever customized facemask

Ronda Rousey, Arianny Celeste have verbal sparring match

All Sports News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

By clicking "Sign Me Up", you have read and agreed to the Fox Sports Digital Privacy Policy and Terms of Use. You can opt out at any time. For more information, please see our Privacy Policy.
Get it now!
Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45

Bostick death threats show why some fans take sports too seriously

Russell Westbrook is surging into the MVP conversation

Five-round NFL Mock Draft

Key offseason moves for every MLB team

Rousey, Arianny Celeste get into it

Dallas sportscaster back with another powerful essay

The parallels of Rose and Hardaway

Offseason breakdown for all 32 NFL teams

On Josh Hamilton's addiction and feeling alone

Judge rules against AP's suspension

Why the Lions should let Suh walk

Chris Jones charged with rape, sodomy

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.