Originally written on Crystal Ball Run  |  Last updated 11/10/14

Whenever news comes down like today's announcement by the NCAA of sanctions against Ohio State stemming from Tatgate, a reasonable and well-intentioned segment of college sports fans and pundits inevitably raise the idea of using monetary fines to punish scofflaws.

The suggestion makes sense on its face. What better deterrent against cheating than hitting schools in the pocketbook? Plus, a fine doesn't directly harm the current athletes, who didn't break the rules, in the same ways that losing scholarships and bowl bans do.

It sounds good in theory, but such a system of enforcement would be a nightmare in practice.

First, there's the matter of figuring how much violations should cost the penalized parties. Let's say, for instance, that the NCAA set standard fines for violations – lack of institutional control costs $100,000, academic fraud costs $75,000 and so on. How do you set the right price on a violation so that it equitably penalizes schools with different resources? Given the size of their war chests, a dollar at Florida means less to the athletic department than a dollar at Nevada.

An effective fine for a wealthy school could cripple a small institution. Conversely, what amounts to a decent chunk of change at a WAC school might not even make a dent in the petty cash box at a Big Ten powerhouse.

Alternatively, the NCAA could base its fines on the schools' individual ability to pay. That doesn't address the issue of determining what a school could reasonably be expected to pay. Is the NCAA going to hire forensic accountants to pour over schools' books in hopes of figuring out how much they should owe?

Second, much like businesses spend additional resources to mitigate mounting risks, fines would have an artificial inflationary effect on spending for compliance in areas where more resources probably aren't necessary. In the case of non-revenue programs, the increased compliance costs coupled with the risk of fines for violations could make sports like field hockey cost-prohibitive. (Imagine how much Boise State's women's tennis team would have cost the school recently.)

Although you could argue that the number of violations in sports such as badminton and cross-country pale in comparison to those of moneymakers, all it would take is one costly scandal to convince administrators around the country to begin shuttering non-revenue programs.

Finally, from a practical standpoint, fines are a much tougher sell to a key group of stakeholders: politicians. Good luck convincing them to allow state institutions to take on that kind of financial exposure, especially when schools have little ability to police the actions of boosters and agents .

Yes, it sucks when players have to pay for the sins of predecessors who ran afoul of the NCAA. Unfortunately, scholarships and postseason bans are the only universal currency when it comes to the NCAA enforcing its rules.


Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45

U.S. Soccer: Hope Solo needs to do 'number of things' to return

K.J. Wright: Targeting injured players 'unacceptable'

Five reasons the Patriots will win the Super Bowl

Five reasons the Seahawks will win the Super Bowl

Bill Simmons fires a shot at ESPN colleague Ray Lewis


Which teams are most squarely on the bubble?

Tiger Woods: 'There was blood everywhere' after tooth incident

Jerry Rice: Asterisk needed if Patriots win Super Bowl

Pete Carroll ok with Robert Kraft despite Patriots firing

Winners and losers of the Senior Bowl

Report: NFL approved under-inflated balls from Patriots

Michael Bennett talks about sex superstition, calls reporter gay

As Patriots prepare, it's easy to forget about Hernandez

Marcus Mariota's younger brother will play at Oregon

Marshawn Lynch on Media Day: 'I'm here so I won't get fined'

Ranking all 48 Super Bowls

'Goodell Must Go' mobile banners heading to Phoenix

NFL pushing College Football Playoff to change its schedule

Can the Yankees avoid paying A-Rod's milestone bonuses?

Tom Brady once got locked in a high school locker

Fire alarm at Patriots' hotel goes off early Tuesday morning

Petition to remove Pats from Super Bowl has 40K+ signatures

Richard Sherman is not pleased with Roger Goodell

All Sports News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

By clicking "Sign Me Up", you have read and agreed to the Fox Sports Digital Privacy Policy and Terms of Use. You can opt out at any time. For more information, please see our Privacy Policy.
Get it now!
Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45

Super Bowl XLIX: Players to watch

Ranking all 48 Super Bowls

Bill Simmons fires a shot at Ray Lewis

NFL pushing CFP to change schedule

Can Yanks not pay A-Rod his bonuses?

Petition started to remove Pats from SB

On John Wall's adidas J Wall 1 NYC All-Star Edition

NFL approved Pats' under-inflated balls?

Six best Super Bowl coaches of all-time

Five key matchups for Super Bowl XLIX

Early Big Ten predictions for 2015

Remembering Ernie Banks

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.