Sporting News - NFL Football
Hi, [sign out]   My Fantasy Teams |
 | free membership

Mike Florio
Profile | Archive | E-mail Florio

Davis' tenure with Raiders has outlived expiration date
Posted: March 7, 2008

As America's population ages, there are plenty of people who should think carefully about whether they should still be driving their cars.

Good luck telling them.

None of us will ever want to admit that our best days are deep in the rear-view mirror, even at a time when it's getting increasingly difficult to see the windshield. Still, there's a point at which the keys need to be taken away.

The same theory applies in the workplace. Sometimes, it's simply time to go.

But, sometimes, the guy who needs to go is the one who's running the show.

And that pretty much sums up the current state of the Oakland Raiders franchise.

I mean no disrespect to Al Davis. He is a great man. He has had as much of an impact as anyone on the game of professional football. His franchise had one of the most stellar stretches of excellence that the NFL has known, with three Super Bowl titles in eight years. He has been at the forefront of diversity, hiring an African-American coach years before the term "Rooney Rule" was coined and placing a woman in the position of team president.

If, however, Mr. Davis is actively managing the football operations, as we assume, the time has come for it to end.

While the organization has made several questionable moves over the past few seasons, some of the most compelling pieces of evidence of a franchise in disarray have come during recent free-agent signings. The first big problem was the decision to sign defensive tackle Tommy Kelly, who is recovering from a torn ACL, wasn't drafted in 2004, and had generated no buzz as he was preparing to hit the open market. Still, he received $18 million in guaranteed money from the Raiders.

Then came the inexplicable decision to sign former Broncos receiver Javon Walker to a deal that could be worth $55 million over six years, including $16 million in guaranteed money. Walker, whose 2007 season was shortened by lingering knee problems, will likely get a whopping $21 million over the first two years.

Amazingly, the Raiders promptly dispatched an in-house mouthpiece to explain to multiple reporters that the deal doesn't really pay Walker $16 million in guaranteed money, and that his agents came up with that number based on a $6 million signing bonus, a non-guaranteed $5 million base salary in 2008 that will almost certainly be paid, and a $5 million base salary in 2009 that is almost as likely to be paid.

The only problem? The information disseminated by Da Raidahs was, well, dead wrong. Walker actually received an $11 million signing bonus, and he'll get a $5 million roster bonus in early 2009. The roster bonus is fully guaranteed against injury.

It's rare for a team to throw cold water on contract numbers being trumpeted by the agent for a newly-signed player. It's unprecedented for a team to set the record straight by giving out blatantly incorrect information. The Raiders admitted they were wrong, but the mere fact that they got it so wrong reveals a shocking level of incompetence -- and that has to point to the man in charge.

And it makes even more curious the stream of denials flowing from the organization regarding the status of coach Lane Kiffin. The team claims that no rift arose in the wake of the 2007 season regarding the status of defensive coordinator Rob Ryan, that Davis didn't ask Kiffin to quit, and that Kiffin wasn't frozen out of the decision to hire receivers coach (and possible future head coach) James Lofton. But how can anyone put any stock in anything that the team says in light of the Walker fiasco?

Meanwhile, Raider Nation finds itself unwittingly trapped in a Black Hole of denial. Check the comments that will be posted at the bottom of this item. Plenty will again chastise the "media" for having an agenda against the Silver and Black.

The truth is that, if the media wanted to see the Raiders fail, the media wouldn't say a thing. Instead, the media would sit back and watch it all continue to crumble.

And crumble it will continue to do for as long as the current ownership is in place. As retired Packers quarterback Brett Favre said on Thursday, "All good things must come to an end." For Al Davis, it's time for his very, very good run to come to an end. Without doubt, without question, without debate.

The Raiders' Super Bowl appearance in 2003 was, in hindsight, an aberration of the salary-cap era, and now by all appearances the team recognizes that it has to overpay players to get them to put up with the drama. This strategy will only attract players who love money more than they love football, and even the few who love football will have their passion snuffed out as the losses continue to outnumber the wins.

Mike Florio writes and edits ProFootballTalk.com and is a regular contributor to Sporting News.

Sporting news - YourTurn   SPEAK OUT ON THIS ARTICLE

Comments
Amen to that!
GB Fan In NEBlog on Fri Mar 07, 2008 04:04 pm
In the last five seasons, the Raiders have failed to win more than five games, and they only did that once. In any other organization (except Detroit's) the GM would be long gone.

However, since that GM is Al Davis, expect the Raiders' (and Detroit's) woes to continue, and the revolving head coaching door continue to turn.

BTW, a quick check of Google shows that the URL http://aldavismustgo.com is available. Have at it Raider Nation.
aajoe7Blog on Fri Mar 07, 2008 04:05 pm
Al Davis is what James Dolan will be in 30 years.
Terry H on Fri Mar 07, 2008 04:11 pm
From your lips, to Al's ears. It's "time to go..."
Wow. Watch out Florio.....
Colorado Dave on Fri Mar 07, 2008 04:14 pm
The Silver & Black will come out to attack.
If only the Raiders could get football players as passionate about football as their fan base.
A long list of underachieving players signifies bad decisions at the highest level of the organization. And for years that has been (pun intended) one & only one person...Al Davis.
I respect Al for what he's done for the NFL (& begrudgingly for the Raiders organization)but enough is enough.
Last championship...1984. (okay I fixed it!)
Raider fans - you can only live off a legacy for so long.
Put him out to pasture
JayFromReno on Fri Mar 07, 2008 04:27 pm
Well said Mike.

I have been a Raider fan for roughly 32 years now and its just pure embarrassment to be a Raider fan these days. For me, it is so bad, I'm starting to think that Ron Wolf had a lot more to do with the Raiders vast success in the 70's and 80's than Al. Results do not lie and just check the players that Wolf was responsible for acquiring. It makes me throw up in my mouth when I think about what the team was compared to what the team is now. The only constant through it all has been Al, he simply must go.
Davis, the new signings, Kiffin, and the Raiders
Rogue RaiderBlog on Fri Mar 07, 2008 04:27 pm
You're right, they shouldn't overpay for the sub-par receiver w/a doubtful knee; Kelly and Wilson I will accept...but this receiver we could have done w/out and instead utilizing some hungry young kid w/potential like crass-test-dummy turned out to be. Kelly was vouched for by Sapp and Wilson proved himself by being a starter in that position for the Super Bowl champs who beat the Patriots Tom Brady.
And the way they handled this in PR terms is also bad, I agree w/you. Through bungling this in the press they have lost all credibility and need an empowered voice there to handle such things w/the media. Someone who when asked what the contract was can get access to it and provide the information to the media in an ethical manner. This is not so much a sign of Al needs to go as those who were part of the 'old Raiders' who sit up there w/him in that box on game day need to go...too many people doing other peoples jobs; people calling media who shouldn't be the ones calling the media.
You ask anyone who joins the Raiders and speaks w/Al they will tell you Al knows of them and saw them athletically in their youth; so, he still knows talent and remembers it in the same fashion he always has.
It's the possibility of Kiffin leaving that has brought the on slot of calls for Al to leave instead of Kiffin because what is obvious to the fans is not so obvious to Al; that he has failed to adapt to the offenses and defenses of this current day and age...a concept hard to realize when you are surrounded by a certain 'group think'; for example the blocking scheme that Kiffin runs (and Mike Shannahan) and the blitzing bizarre the Giants and Pittsburg can run but Al won't let Ryan run.
j.nice on Fri Mar 07, 2008 05:20 pm
'outived expiration date' is a garbled cliche. sort of like this article.
Give it up!!!! The Raider's
TeamDomination on Fri Mar 07, 2008 05:30 pm
You are so right. The NFL (and its fans) have long been known for worshiping the good and firing the bad. The bad thing here is the GM is Al Davis. Raider fans across the nation are tired of hoping for a great season, being promised change, and still only winning a handful of games (kinda sounds like our Presidential election). This is truly the wrong way to lead a team much less, run it. The guy has to look at himself in the mirror and decide what is best, not for himself, but for the team as a whole not to mention the millions of fans. The team that once was, is just that….Once was. They need new leadership, ownership, and a renewed commitment to the game. There comes a time in every great company that the CEO’s picture is hung with a huge “Thank you” under it stating how great that man was. I believe that Al Davis needs to be photographed, worshiped, and then give him the proper retirement with a huge “Thank you” sign. Someone needs to scream “Give it up”.
DetroitTigerMarkBlog on Fri Mar 07, 2008 05:46 pm
aajoe7 wrote:
Al Davis is what James Dolan will be in 30 years.


Not quite....Al Davis has had success. He has been very successful over four + decades....with his own money, unlike Dolan (daddy's cash and never has been really successful). That being said, I wholeheartedly agree with the poster above that it is time to throw Al his retirement party. I have always had a soft spot for the Raiders, and the recent moves by the Raiders have been foolish, if not anything short of bizarre.
"I respect Al Davis" comments -
thatabby on Fri Mar 07, 2008 05:48 pm
If you ever, or as you claim; do - respect Al Davis for what he has done. Respect him for the accomplishments and whatever else you have read about him.... If you really "respected" him, then you wouldn't be so quick to clown him, bury him, get rid of him, blame him, mock him, etc.....

The man simply created THIS. and deserves to go out how ever HE chooses, and or closest ones feel. HE deserves to be applauded for the things YOU SAY YOU RESPECT HIM FOR and that's it...

All of this "I respect him BUT" ..... BUT? But WHAT?

Read over all of his accomplishments and what he has provided for players, teams, the NFL --- and just stick to respecting him like you say you do. You want to say I respect him then add the negative things, go ahead - but take out the respect him stuff.
All times are EST
Goto page 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10  Next Page 1 of 10
Click Here