A Matter of Leadership
As much as Roberto Di Matteo, Frank Lampard, Roman Abramovich, and other major figures for Chelsea FC have partied with the big trophy with the big ears, the end of the 2011–2012 season means that changes will come to the club; And a prestigious and proven leader must be decided on to secure the future stars and success for the West London team for next season and beyond.
Roberto Di Matteo’s magical run as Chelsea’s interim manager has been quite incredible. After being in free fall and on the brink of elimination in both the FA Cup and UEFA Champions League under Andres Villas-Boas, Chelsea lost only three matches in all competitions under Di Matteo (none of them in the UCL or FA Cup) against 14 victories. They didn’t manage to stay afloat domestically, as they finished in sixth place, their worst finish in the Barclays Premier League since the 2001–2002 season, but they won everything else. Their defense was stellar under Di Matteo, as Chelsea allowed 1.1 goals a game in all competitions, allowing more than two goals in only a single match. They came back from a two goal deficit against SSC Napoli in the UCL Round of 16; they crushed Tottenham Hotspur FC, 5–1, in the FA Cup Semi-finals; they blanked FC Barcelona at Stamford Bridge in the Champions League, and then scored two at Camp Nou, winning the Semi-final on aggregate; they beat Liverpool FC 2–1 at Wembley to win the FA Cup; and then it all cumulated in their penalty shootout victory over FC Bayern Munich, in Munich, to win their first ever UEFA Champions League.
However, it is now uncertain if RDM will be Chelsea’s manager next season. While it can be argued that he’s the right guy for the job because he understands the players so well, it’s debatable if he has the heart to make the radical changes and complete the transition to the new generation of Chelsea players. It’s been partially done, as Chelsea has some future cornerstones for their club, such as Juan Mata and David Luiz who both are with the West London club for four more years. But more must be done to change the culture of this team. Andres Villas-Boas tried his best, but he was young and inexperienced and lacked the players’ trust to listen to him to the tee. Perhaps RDM could be the one to convince John Terry, Lampard, and other veterans to step aside and take limited time on the pitch, letting the young stars take over. He’s deeply entrenched in the culture of the clubhouse and they love him there, unlike AVB. He’s earned their respect because he won Chelsea two trophies this season when all looked lost and the Blues seemed like they would become irrelevant.
But even if he can make the transition to the new generation of Chelsea players, Di Matteo’s prestige is an issue. Some see his run as lucky and that over the course of an entire year, he might not be able to get this Chelsea team to play at the level they were at the end of this past season – especially in the long stretch of the Premiership. A few weeks of must-win football success is good, but a successful manager must also be able to get his or her team to perform on a high level in a league stage where the overall record over many months is key. Di Matteo has proven himself worthy of mention, but to some, he’s not yet verified that he can make Chelsea one of the three or four most dominant teams in Europe for a good stretch of years. Some doubt whether or not he can make Chelsea stay as consistent and as much of a contender in the BPL as Manchester United FC. Some question whether he can do the same in the UEFA Champions League, competing with Real Madrid CF and Barcelona.
These uncertainties are part of what is stopping some new, young stars from running toward Chelsea already. A prime example is Eden Hazard. While he said that Chelsea is one of his top choices of clubs to join next year, he also put Manchester City FC and Man U on that list. Why? Simple: Both Man U and Man City are prime contenders domestically and in Europe. Both clubs may have been given an early exit in the UCL this season, but they both still have impressive rosters that can win in the future. Sergio Aguero, Mario Balotelli, David Silva, and more for City; Wayne Rooney, Nani, Ashley Young, and more for Man U. Oh, and did I forget to mention that money is another reason why the two Manchester teams are on his list? Young stars always like to join clubs that have big wallets.
Yet, doubt remains in Chelsea’s case. Hazard hasn’t decided on Chelsea yet likely because of the manager situation. Perhaps he sees that RDM might be the manager next year and is worried that he won’t be on a true contending team throughout all competitions – the kind of club like Real Madrid, Man U, and Barcelona that defeat all but a few teams in all contests and is essentially guaranteed to win at least one trophy every year. The prestige of Di Matteo – the brief prestige that hasn’t been tested with Chelsea over a long period of time – might turn away some of the young, well sought-after stars. Money Chelsea has; they can afford any young player. They also will guarantee that Hazard will be more integral and have more playing time on their team than on Man U or City, where, he might be put into a backup role since they have so many solid strikers. Chelsea already misses their legendary striker, Didier Drogba, and Fernando Torres can’t be relied on to be the main source of goals for them since he no longer can score as well as used to – even with Mata feeding him good passes. Chelsea would fawn over Hazard because he would help their offense quite a bit. But success for Hazard at Chelsea is a different thing. It remains to be seen how well Chelsea will do next season and beyond because their manager situation still isn’t set. Winning the Champions League once isn’t enough security for the brightest stars on the planet.
A manager means a lot to football clubs. They can be like the Alex Fergusons and build enduring, consistent dynasties. Good leadership and unquestioned prestige makes almost any player abide by that leader’s rules and maintains a long period of success for the club. Managers, however, can also be like the AVBs and sweep through a club quickly, causing turmoil because players don’t trust the leader’s track record of success. Players will respect a manager if they see he or she has great credentials. Roberto Di Matteo has the respect of Chelsea and will always be loved for bringing them their first ever UCL trophy. However, he has yet to prove that he can bring home trophies for years and years. Was it the start of a new era of success and another Special One for Chelsea, or was it just a lucky, hot, one-time run? That’s the question that eats at Roman Abramovich. He has yet to see a manager like the former whom he can put all his faith in and whom will produce the desired results. Until Abramovich finds the leader who can do this, the young stars will always be somewhat wary of Chelsea, wondering if the Blues can be consistent, serious competitors for the big trophy with the big ears.
