Originally posted on The Queensbury Rules  |  Last updated 5/7/12

What if I told you I had Miguel Cotto beating Floyd Mayweather 117-111 (nine-three in rounds)? Well, you can relax, I didn’t. Don’t puke all over your Pernell Whitaker t-shirt and rush to defecate on my Twitter just yet. I scored the fight 116-112 Mayweather, giving Cotto rounds 2, 5, 6 and 8. But if I had shared the opinion of some respected boxing scribes on certain individual rounds, perhaps I could’ve registered that seemingly ludicrous number.

ROUND 2

Scored for Cotto by Tim Dahlberg (AP), Kevin Iole (Yahoo), and Dan Rafael (ESPN).

ROUND 3

Scored for Cotto by Lance Pugmire (LA Times), Doug Fischer (Ring Magazine), and Tim Starks (Queensberry Rules).

ROUND 5

Scored for Cotto by Harold Lederman (HBO), Ron Borges (Boston Herald), and Iole.

ROUND 6

Scored for Cotto by David Greisman (Boxing Scene), Lederman, and Fischer.

ROUND 7

Scored for Cotto by Scott Christ (Bad Left Hook) and Pugmire.

ROUND 8

Scored for Cotto by Greisman, Dahlberg, and Fischer.

ROUND 9

Scored for Cotto by Rafael.

ROUND 10

Scored for Cotto by Christ, Starks, and Fischer.

ROUND 11

Scored for Cotto by Starks and Pugmire.

If you agreed with those guys on all of those rounds, you would have tallied the improbable card of 117-111 for Cotto (gasp!). Of the ten gents I cited, only two came up with a final verdict other than Mayweather winning the fight. Starks scored a 114-114 draw. Pugmire saw it 115-113 for Cotto. Of the rest, Iole and Borges had it tightest at 115-113 Mayweather. Dahlberg, Rafael, Fischer, and Christ all rendered 116-112 Mayweather. Lederman had it 117-111 and the esteemed Greisman, one of the brightest and funniest boxing writers around, came in at 118-110, a resounding Mayweather victory, at least in a scoring sense.

The majority consensus was that Mayweather was an obvious winner, whether it was narrow or wide. Any difference of opinion will likely be met with righteous indignation and mocking derision. I thought Mayweather clearly won the fight. That is my opinion. The problem with boxing scoring is that most fights contain rounds that are hardly definitive or conclusive. This fight had several quiet, close, debatable rounds, and you can see from the differences in scoring that opinions can vary widely. The aforementioned Scott Christ echoed my score of 116-112 for Mayweather but we scored two rounds differently. Same situation with Doug Fischer. If I agreed with Scott that Cotto won the 7th and 10th rounds, I would’ve had it a draw. If I then agreed with Fischer on the 3d round, I’d have Cotto winning 115-113. If Scott concurred with me on the 7th and 10th rounds, he’d join Greisman with a 118-110 in favor of Mayweather.

Point being, there’s no right answer, no undisputed truth, when it comes to scoring close rounds in a fight. Looking at it as a whole, I couldn’t possibly come up with a way to claim Cotto won. But you don’t score fights as a whole, you score round-by-round. And if you shared the opinions of the people mentioned above on the rounds cited, even seven out of the nine, you wound up with Cotto ahead on your card. You’ll surely be scoffed at by all the boxing “geniuses,” dubbed an imbecile, incapable of grasping the finer points of the sweet science. They’ll spout out old clichés: “boxing is like jazz, the better it is, the harder it is to understand, and you just don’t get it.” They’ll rattle off some impressive-sounding technical mumbo-jumbo (amazing how many guys on Twitter speak with the pedigree of a twenty-year veteran world-class boxing trainer, isn’t it?) and deride you and your ghastly scorecard. My opinion: It was a competitive fight. Mayweather took over late and clearly deserved to win. But if you scored some tight rounds differently and saw it otherwise, that doesn’t make you an idiot. It means you have an opinion different than mine. And as they say, opinions are like assholes: Everyone has one, and there are a lot of them in boxing.

This article first appeared on The Queensbury Rules and was syndicated with permission.

PLAYERS: Miguel Cotto
MORE FROM YARDBARKER

Report: Broncos tried to trade Demaryius Thomas

Baker Mayfield stripped of captaincy, won't start vs. WVU

Metta World Peace to join BIG3, play under name Ron Artest

Travis Kelce after loss to Giants: ‘Guys have to get called out’

Broncos reportedly fire offensive coordinator Mike McCoy

LIKE WHAT YOU SEE?
GET THE DAILY NEWSLETTER:

Hue Jackson says DeShone Kizer will start for rest of 2017

Jones has no problem telling other NFL owners to ‘pipe down’

Donald Trump want the NFL to suspend Marshawn Lynch

Ex-NFLers react to news of Terry Glenn dying in car accident

Saints lose breakout pass rusher Alex Okafor for season

Jay Cutler’s wife seems fed up with this ‘football s—‘

The 'Wheelin' and Thielen in Minnesota' quiz

What each NFL team should be grateful for this Thanksgiving

Sports & Politics Intersect: Is Jerry out of his league?

Should the Broncos make Tyrod Taylor their next quarterback?

15 mid-majors you need to know before you hear about them in March

Follow Ben Simmons as he leads us to the NBA's unknown future

The Saints flipped the script to revive their season

The 15 best and 15 worst MLB signings of the last decade

Winners and losers from NBA's first month

14 things we hated about 2017 college football season

MLS conference finals predictions: Who will advance to play for Cup trophy?

Vikings' unnecessary quarterback conundrum is Mike Zimmer's doing

Boxing News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

By clicking "Sign Me Up", you have read and agreed to the Yardbarker Privacy Policy and Terms of Service. You can opt out at any time. For more information, please see our Privacy Policy.

The 'Wheelin' and Thielen in Minnesota' quiz

What each NFL team should be grateful for this Thanksgiving

NFL Week 11 injury report

Sports & Politics Intersect: Is Jerry out of his league?

15 mid-majors you need to know before you hear about them in March

The 'An I, Tonya for an eye (or knee)' quiz

Should the Broncos make Tyrod Taylor their next quarterback?

The 15 best and 15 worst MLB signings of the last decade

The 'It's a major award!' quiz

Follow Ben Simmons as he leads us to the NBA's unknown future

Today's Best Stuff
For Publishers
Company Info
Help
Follow Yardbarker