Brennan or Tebow?

it's gonna be tebow

Brennan

i'm a noles fan, but i am a fan of tebow too b/c he went to my HS (Nease) so i always liked him. i'm a little biased.

McFadden..

Man, I can't imagine the kind of stats Tebow would put up against Brennan's competition. You could be looking at 70 total TD's rather than 50. And Brennan would be an average SEC QB.

Tebow put most of his big stats up against Western Kentucky, Troy, Florida Atlantic.

5,. well said, but nonetheless a huge season by Tebow. Brennan could play anywhere, but he would not have got a chance to play anywhere but Hawaii due to his run-ins with the law. How about Brennan rides pine in the NFL for a couple years, and Tebow becommes one of the best running backs in the game ever?

I take Brennan over Tebow 4 da heisman if i had a choice of jus them 2. I think McFadden should win it

Brennan is the better player than Tim Tebow.

I'm not sold as Tebow as an future NFL great QB, but I think he wins the Heisman. Tebow is a beast, but not a great passer. Tom Brady isn't much of a physical specimen, so being a beast is not a requirement for NFL super stardom. Haven't watched Brennan, but he is much more refined per his coach June Jones.

Now being a beast with lightning speed will make D-MAC a NFL superstar... Here's to Jerry Jones giving up his entire draft for D-MAC next year!

Well there is an unwritten rule that a sophomore will never win the heisman. DMC had great stats last year and should have won it over Troy Smith. This year DMC has better stats and will win it.

Brennan throws every down. Tebow scored 20 passing and 20 running. He won. He may win it again before he gets done at FL.

tebow won so deal with it!!!!!!!!