Found August 19, 2009 on
This Purist Bleeds Pinstripes:
PLAYERS:
Joe Mauer,
Derek Jeter,
Mark Teixeira,
Alex Rodriguez
TEAMS: Minnesota Twins, New York Yankees, Texas Rangers
TEAMS: Minnesota Twins, New York Yankees, Texas Rangers
A few weeks ago, some of you will no doubt be aware that I did a guest post on River Ave Blues arguing that Derek Jeter should walk away with the MVP.
No disrespect to Jeter, who is still having an amazing season and an even more amazing road trip, but I need to change my vote.
I have seen the light, and the light is Joe Mauer.
How have I seen the light?
Mauer's average, .383, is higher than Mark Teixeira's on-base-percentage. That means that Joe Mauer is getting a greater percentage of hits than Mark Teixeira--one of the league leaders in OBP--is getting on base.
Mauer has 139 hits and 25 home runs to go along with it--and let's not forget, he missed the entire first month of the season.
As one might now expect, his walks and strike outs are almost exactly identical (46 and 47), and this is already mid-late August.
The only, and I mean only, knock on Mauer here is that the team he's playing for is, well, not very good, and the award is most valuable and not most outstanding player.
Still, it can't be much of a complaint. Alex Rodriguez, after all, won on the last place Texas Rangers, right?
Take heart, supporters of Jeter and Teixeira, however: those two could very well pick up some other hardware that might skip Mauer by (this season, at least)--and that hardware is plenty valuable on its own.
Original Story:
http://www.puristbleedspinstripes.com...
No disrespect to Jeter, who is still having an amazing season and an even more amazing road trip, but I need to change my vote.
I have seen the light, and the light is Joe Mauer.
How have I seen the light?
Mauer's average, .383, is higher than Mark Teixeira's on-base-percentage. That means that Joe Mauer is getting a greater percentage of hits than Mark Teixeira--one of the league leaders in OBP--is getting on base.
Mauer has 139 hits and 25 home runs to go along with it--and let's not forget, he missed the entire first month of the season.
As one might now expect, his walks and strike outs are almost exactly identical (46 and 47), and this is already mid-late August.
The only, and I mean only, knock on Mauer here is that the team he's playing for is, well, not very good, and the award is most valuable and not most outstanding player.
Still, it can't be much of a complaint. Alex Rodriguez, after all, won on the last place Texas Rangers, right?
Take heart, supporters of Jeter and Teixeira, however: those two could very well pick up some other hardware that might skip Mauer by (this season, at least)--and that hardware is plenty valuable on its own.
THE BACKYARD
AROUND THE WEB
RELATED ARTICLES
Joe Mauer Is the MVP, End of Story.
I was enjoying what was truly a lovely evening (yes, that included a trip to the Olive Garden and some odds-on cotton panties), up until I came across a headline that just fouled up my entire mood. From Jeff Fletcher at FanHouse, who should fly to Minnesota next time he wants to get quotes [...]
Man Muscles For MVP
Clearly, you all saw this post coming from a mile away, but it's high time BLB weighs in on the controversial "Joe Mauer For MVP" debate. No homerism here, we're just gonna lay out the facts. The cold, hard truth. Yes, we love his sideburns and humble MinnesotaNice with all of our hearts, but sideburns don't earn most valuable player awards. Neither do P'...
Mauer gets nod in AL MVP voting ... for now
Mark Teixeira and Joe Mauer can make strong cases for AL MVP. But once you break it down, one stands alone, Dayn Perry says.
Jeter Wants to Keep Playing
Derek Jeter talks about his future:
But there was an interesting exchange near the end of the interview. Jeter was asked how long he intended to keep playing and he claimed it wasn’t something that he has thought about. But he did admit to joking with Joe Girardi that he could DH for five years once [...]
Jeter gives Yanks, Sabathia rare win in Oakland
OAKLAND, Calif.(AP) Derek Jeter had his third straight three-hit game and also knocked in the go-ahead run to help CC Sabathia win for the first time in six years in Oakland in the New York Yankees ' 7-2 victory over the Athletics on Tuesday night.
Is Jeter the best hitting shortstop of all time?
Derek Jeter became the all-time leader for hits by a shortstop on Sunday in Seattle, passing Hall of Famer Luis Aparicio. But does that mean he's the best hitting shortstop of all time? At the very least, he's in the conversation.
Derek Jeter is hot, hot, hot!
One week after Robinson Cano was hot, hot, hot, Derek Jeter has somehow achieved the same degree of hotness or more. In the last seven days, Jeter even has more hits than king Joe Mauer (16 compared to 15). Jeter is hitless in just two games in August, while he has 10 multi-hit games in 18 total. So, is Jeter the best hitting shortstop of all time? Is he the MVP of the league, let...
Hot Old Man
With Hanley Ramirez and Joe Mauer streaking toward batting titles, another great hitter is very hot as well. Derek Jeter knocked out three hits Tuesday night, his third straight three hit game. Since July 24, he’s hitting .375 with seven three hit games and 13 multi-hit games. At .330/.394/..471, is this one [...]
Clear Anti New York Bias in Award Voting
The MVP debate just can’t die. The scribes in Minnesota heard yesterday about the controversy, first started by the NY Times Tyler Kepner on Friday, via their carrier pigeon. I am being facetious of course, but it’s ironic that it took so long to hear from one of the scribes in Joe Mauer’s hometown.
Charley Walters [...]
NY Yankees notes: Hideki Matsui, Derek Jeter and a check-up for Brett Gardner
Otto Greule Jr./Getty ImagesYankees shortstop Derek Jeter will get the day at designated hitter. Ramiro Pena will start in his place. OAKLAND -- A few quick notes from the once again renamed Oakland-Alameda County Coliseum... - Hideki Matsui will continue...
Odds And Ends: Jeter, Uggla, Cubs, Hall
Links for Thursday morning...
Derek Jeter, whose contract expires after next season, says he isn't thinking about his next deal or how long he'll keep playing, according to Mark Feinsand of the New York Daily News.
Juan C. Rodriguez of the South Florida Sun-Sentinel asks: Are the Marlins better off holding onto Dan Uggla after the season and paying him about...
Hot Stove Player of the Week: Derek Jeter
I turned on the New York Mets game on Friday night, and they were playing in Ebbets Field and wearing NewYork Giants uniforms. The Mets can’t even get any respect from their own organization.
What’s next? Donning tribute uniforms to the 1996 Yankees?
Those circa-1905 unis did grow on me, though. Maybe they should play a throwback game instead of just sporting the...
MLB Forum Discussions










|
August 20, 2009














Jeter should have won it in 2006, when the award ironically went to Justin Morneau, Mauer's teammate.