Just how inconsistent are the Umps?

In the past, I've attempted to evaluate umpires based on the statistics that the pitchers on the mound are putting up. I made some tables, saw a few trends, and that was that.

Given my proclivity for putting things into graphs, I don't know why I haven't tried this before.

What I did was simply take the umpire data I pulled from Baseball Prospectus's statistics, set up a few parameters, and graph the heck out of it.

You might be surprised at how varied the umpires actually are.

3 Comments On: "Just how inconsistent are the Umps?"

 
Wow, good work, I think. Kind of confusing, but it seems to make sense. But when you said that it umpire calls depend on the pictures is exactly correct. Montegue may strike out 9 in one game and call 15 BBs the next. I think something to look at would be Ks looking, as compared to Ks swinging. That may change some results.

Good point. I'll see if I can get that data...

nice work pastime, we cant let the umps get away with being shitty.

Your comment:



Featured Stories Today
YouTube's greatest NBA mixes??
The following videos are actual YouTube mixes of real life NBA "stars." Keep in mind, someone...
 
Catching Up from Albuquerque
First I want to thank everybody for their get well wishes -- I feel way better right now than I...
Name Every Winner of the WWE/WWF Royal Rumble
There have been 21 total Royal Rumbles in the history of the World Wrestling Federation or WWE as...
Female Reporter Gets Hit With Baseball
Dawn Timmeney, a reporter for NBC10 in Philly, gets hit with a baseball while conducting an...
 
My New Contest
Im sorry its been a while. I know everyone wants to know whats goin on with me. We got into Kansas...
Most Comments Today
Most Comments This Week

Top 5 Related Stories
Top MLB Quizzes
Recent MLB Fans
Most Popular MLB Articles

 
 
© Copyright 2008 Yardbarker, Inc. All Rights Reserved