Found July 06, 2009 on
The Hardball Times:
I've been beating the Eric Wedge and Mark Shapiro drum quite a bit lately, including this morning, when I wondered why in the heck one or both of them haven't been fired yet.
Cleveland Frowns, however, says that the problems lie elsewhere:
But before becoming too shaken up by the prospect of either of these men hanging on to their jobs here in Cleveland, we recommend considering just how much we should expect from them and our baseball team that plays on the low end of what is unquestionably an uneven playing field . . .
. . . in the seventeen baseball seasons since the Cincinnati Reds’ 1990 World Series title, only ONE team that plays in a media market smaller than Cleveland has won baseball’s big one, the 2006 St. Louis Cardinals . . . So the next time we get that sick feeling in our stomach when the next Tribe star leaves, we might comfort ourselves with the knowledge that there are real world stats that correspond with our sickness.
There's more to it than that -- some numbers talking about market size, mostly -- but the gist is that it is, in fact, market size rather than Wedge and Shapiro that are at the root of the Indians' losing ways.
I guess I'd be more willing to buy that if (a) the Indians' biggest problem was losing its superstars as opposed to not even having their less-than-star-studded club play up to its potential; and (b) if the Indians' didn't field multiple enormously successful clubs since 1994 or so, with all of those teams playing under the same basic business dynamic as today's club.
More generally, the Frowns' article makes a big effort to explain away much of the success of smaller market teams in the past couple of decades, discounting the Rays because they had so many high picks, discounting the Cardinals because they play in "the best baseball town in America" (never mind that it's a smaller town than Cleveland), both the Cardinals and Blue Jays because of new stadiums just prior to winning their titles and removing the Marlins and their two titles from consideration altogether because they were "unquestionably weird." Frowns doesn't explain how those titles were "weird" apart from the fact that their example cuts against their argument.
I think the final nail in the coffin of that argument is the resort to football and basketball:
Or, you might also protect yourself from such bad feelings the way we do here at Frowns, that is with a growing sense of apathy toward Major League Baseball as a whole, and especially in comparison to the NFL and NBA, leagues that understand that meaningful competition requires a level playing field.
Number of teams who have won the World Series since 1990: 12
Number of teams who have won the Super Bowl since 1990: 12
Number of teams who have won the NBA Finals since 1990: 7
Level playing field, indeed.Click here to learn about THT's download subscriptions.
Original Story:
http://www.hardballtimes.com/main/shy...
-
TopicRepliesLast Activity
-
What to do with the Mets?
dublej342 started this New York Mets thread63 hours ago -
Sox Hot Stove: The Jason Bay Decision | Boston Sports Then and Now
joemgill88 started this Boston Red Sox thread153 hours ago -
Is the Chicago White Sox Signing Of Andruw Jones The Correct Move?
GMsPerspective started this MLB thread610 hours ago -
The Next Ted Williams is Not in a Test Tube - Bring Back the Days of Baseball Mysticism
mlnsports started this MLB thread11 day ago -
dodgers-small market team
wellsfargo11 started this MLB thread31 day ago
Featured Yardbarker Articles
- Deja Vu For Young And Leinart - Video
- Tim Tebow Makes it Cool to Love Jesus
- Eagles benefit from non-call, Redskins’ conservative approach in victory
- Listen to the Tiger Woods Accident 911 Call
- Tiger Woods Accident - Possible Explanations
- Hey Nets... you better hope Karma ain't lookin' tomorrow
- Report: Weis Has Already 'Cleaned Out His Office'
- NBA: Golden age of the NBA point guard
- Haslett says he has been contacted by NFL team
- The 10 biggest NHL stories of the last decade
Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers
Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?
Join the Yardbarker Network (YBN) for more promotion, traffic, and money.

















Add Comment