Best OPS+ Seasons by a Catcher aged 35 or older, minimum of 375 PA, 1901-2009

Minimum of 75% of games played at catcher. Player Year Age Tm Lg PA AVG OBP SLG OPS OPS+ Gabby Hartnett 1937 36 CHC NL 405 .354 .424 .548 .972 158 Jorge Posada 2007 35 NYY AL 589 .338 .426 .543 .969 154 Ernie Lombardi 1945 37 NYG NL 417 .307 .387 .486 .873 141 Carlton Fisk 1989 41 CHW AL 419 .293 .356 .475 .831 136 Carlton Fisk 1990 42 CHW AL 521 .285 .378 .451 .829 134 Carlton Fisk 1983 35 CHW AL 545 .289 .355 .518 .873 134 Jorge Posada 2009 37 NYY AL 388 .285 .361 .538 .969 133 Smoky Burgess 1962 35 PIT NL 399 .328 .375 .500 .875 132 Walker Cooper 1950 35 TOT NL 420 .313 .367 .495 .862 129 Elston Howard 1964 35 NYY AL 607 .313 .371 .455 .826 128 Mike Piazza 2006 37 SDP NL 439 .283 .342 .501 .843 122 Ernie Whitt 1989 37 TOR AL 440 .262 .349 .416 .765 121