Originally posted on The Majors National  |  Last updated 11/15/12

MIAMI - OCTOBER 22: Right fielder Miguel Cabrera #20 of the Florida Marlins hits the ball during game four of the Major League Baseball World Series against the New York Yankees on October 22, 2003 at Pro Player Stadium in Miami, Florida. The Marlins won 4-3 in 12 innings. (Photo by Elsa/Getty Images)

Getty Images

Tonight, we will finally learn the MVP of the American League, a contest that really comes down to two candidates in Miguel Cabrera of the Detroit Tigers and Mike Trout of the Los Angeles Angels. For the majority of the 2012 season the debate raged on who should ultimately take home the prize with traditionalist seemingly siding with Cabrera while the sabermetric junkies simply fell in love with Trout’s eye popping stats… and for good reason. But what most people tend to forget in this debate, including those in the Baseball Writer’s Association of America (BBWAA) who get the final say is the actual premise of the Award which is the most valuable player. Last season I was a huge proponent that Justin Verlander deserved the AL MVP because he truly was thee most valuable player to the Tigers’ organization. Sure his stat line was different than that of Jacoby Ellsbury but if you took Verlander out of the Tigers’ rotation you could make a good case that the Tigers don’t make the playoffs last season, despite their late season run. And in the end the writers got it right awarding Verlander the honors instead of not necessarily the most exceptional player (which you could argue Verlander was as well). Fast forward to this season though and the debate get’s a little murky. Both Cabrera and Trout were hugely valuable to their respective teams and very much dictated what success the teams did have. Something that can’t be taken into account though was what happened before this season or what will happen in years to come. The 2012 AL MVP should be based on just that, what happened in 2012 between these two very impressive players. MIKE TROUT Stats, stats, stats:The traditionalist seem to hate this category but baseball is very much a stats driven game so it would only seem appropriate that Trout’s stats should without a doubt present a very good case for his AL MVP argument. In only 139 games played the 21-year-old hit an astounding .326 (second behind Cabrera) with 30 home runs and led the majors with 49 steals and 129 runs scored. It makes you wonder what those stats would look like if he played in all 161 games during the season, again something you really can’t penalize him on. Defense: Sure Cabrera was serviceable at third base in 2012, Trout on the other hand was phenomenal in center for the Angels. He possessed a .988 fielding percentage and a UZR of 1 which helped the Angels become one of the best defensive outfields in the American League. Trout’s run in 2012 also made the WAR stat a household term… which most people don’t understand the idea of despite it still being important. Where would the Angels’ of ended up with out him in 2012? Mike Trout’s presence in 2012 enabled the Angels to be relevant at the end of the season. Given the struggles of the rest of the team, especially Albert Pujols, Trout carried the organization on his back giving the Angels the opportunity to remain in the hunt in September. And in a tough AL West nonetheless. MIGUEL CABRERA Triple Crown: Even though not every Triple Crown winner has ended up winning the MVP, there has to be some sentiment to Miguel Cabrera being the first player since Carl Yastrzemski in 1967 to win the Triple Crown. Cabrera finished the season with American League leading number in home runs (44), RBIs (139) and batting average (.330). Mike Trout certainly has his impressive numbers but Cabrera has his as well. Switching positions: Not a whole lot is put into this but it should. Miguel Cabrera, who is baseball’s BEST hitter (yes better than Albert Pujols) offered to switch positions during last offseason so the team could pursue Prince Fielder and put him at first. Prior to his move, Cabrera had worked himself into a good defensive first baseman and yes he wasn’t nearly as good as Trout was defensively but worked equally as hard to put his third base critics to bed in 2012. The Tigers were a better team this past season because of Fielder and Cabrera going back-to-back in the lineup, something that may of never of come to fruition if Cabrera didn’t make the move. The Tigers got to the playoffs: What should be important in voting for this award, but probably still isn’t is whether or not the players respective team made it to the postseason. Simply put, Cabrera and the Tigers made it to the postseason (and eventually the World Series) while Mike Trout and the Angels were golfing. And it was Cabrera’s monster numbers in the month of September that helped propel the Tigers past the White Sox and into October baseball. Like Mike Trout, where would the Tigers be without Cabrera?  
Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45

Report: Ray Lewis gave Bills pregame pep talk

Report: Marshawn Lynch out a few weeks to recover

Peyton Manning to miss at least two more weeks

Notre Dame DT: Committee 'spit in our faces' with ranking

LaRon Landry suspended indefinitely by NFL

Don’t blame Mike Pettine for benching Johnny Manziel. Blame Johnny.


Danny Ainge: Celtics’ Marcus Smart has shown ‘propensity to get injured’

Ravens claim Jimmy Clausen off waivers, send Joe Flacco to IR

Report: Signs point to Chip Kelly, Eagles parting ways after season

Johnny Bench(ed): Manziel demoted to third string

ACC schools find themselves in major financial trouble


Michigan State lists two starting QBs on depth chart

10 storylines for Week 13 of the college football season

LISTEN: Browns fan cries on radio while ripping Johnny Manziel

Texas A&M QB Kyle Allen says he was injured vs. Alabama

Report: Maple Leafs are no longer the NHL’s most valuable franchise

Ranking the 10 best games of 2015 college football rivalry week

Did a Chipotle employee convince Danny Ainge to trade for Isaiah Thomas?

Bud Black joins Angels organization as special assistant to GM

Ben Simmons, Henry Ellenson excelled in freshman vs. freshman battle

Maximizing the Bucks

Holly Holm asked Beyonce who she was

Florida, Florida State kick off college football rivalry week

Which goalies are pulling ahead for the Vezina Trophy?

MLB News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

By clicking "Sign Me Up", you have read and agreed to the Fox Sports Digital Privacy Policy and Terms of Use. You can opt out at any time. For more information, please see our Privacy Policy.
Get it now!
Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45

10 storylines for Week 13 of the college football season

Ranking the 10 best games of 2015 college football rivalry week

Examining the Mavericks' hot start

Johnny Bench(ed): Manziel demoted to third string

Mike Trout, four years in

Tom Brady on ‘Rex Ryan!’ line call: It’s ‘in the playbook’

Five NFL teams trending downward

Not so fast, USC: Eagles Chip Kelly buys Philly-area home

The five best hockey fights from Week 7

Bart Starr doesn’t remember Green Bay Packers career

Today's Best Stuff
For Publishers
Company Info
Follow Yardbarker