Originally written on Pirates Prospects  |  Last updated 2/13/13
Mlb-astros-pirates
My initial approach with the Brandon Inge news tonight was the same as any minor league signing: acknowledge that it happened and move on. Danny Knobler reported that the Pirates are close to a minor league deal with Inge, who turns 36 this season. Like 99% of minor league deals, this one comes with no risk, and a small chance to provide some sort of reward. For that reason, there’s not much point in analyzing what Inge could do for the Pirates in 2013. Chances are he’ll spend time in Triple-A, and if he does make the majors, he’s not going to make much of an impact. In looking over his stats, I noticed that Inge has a platoon split. He crushes left-handers, but struggles against right-handers. I thought about how the Pirates have a few left-handed platoon options, but really only have one right-handed platoon option. That option is Gaby Sanchez, who will be platooning at first base this year with Garrett Jones. Then I thought about a potential platoon on the other side of the diamond. Last year at this time there was a debate on where Pedro Alvarez should have started the season: Triple-A or the majors. You don’t hear much of that debate following Alvarez’s 30 home run season in 2012. Now the conversation is on whether Alvarez can improve on his 2012 numbers. He had the power, with 30 homers and a .467 slugging percentage in 525 at-bats. What he didn’t have was the average. Alvarez hit for a .244 average with a .317 OBP. He also struck out way too much, sitting at 30% for the third year in a row. Charlie wrote about the strikeouts a few days ago, and looked at some comparable players who have had similar strikeout numbers to what Alvarez saw in 2012 (180 strikeouts). The results weren’t encouraging, and don’t give much hope that Alvarez can improve his ratios and see an increase to his average in the future. Is Pedro Alvarez a platoon player? Aside from the strikeout problems, it’s pretty well documented that Alvarez struggles against left-handers. Last year he had a .207/.270/.379 line in 140 at-bats against left-handers. That’s compared to a .257/.334/.499 line in 385 at-bats against right-handers. In his career, Alvarez has a .247/.321/.454 line against right-handers and a .209/.281/.353 line against right-handers. The overall numbers against right-handers are low, mostly because Alvarez couldn’t hit anyone in 2011. The addition of Inge, his platoon splits, his ability to play third base (career 6.8 UZR/150), and Alvarez’s struggles against left-handers got me thinking about the idea of platooning Alvarez. I’m not necessarily saying Brandon Inge should be the guy for the job. I’m looking at this more in a general “Should Pedro Alvarez be in a Platoon” way. To start the debate, let’s look at the career platoon splits of Alvarez next to an established platoon player. Pedro Alvarez: .209/.281/.353 in 292 AB vs LHP Player A: .210/.249/.381 in 328 AB vs LHP The stat lines are almost identical. Alvarez has a higher on-base percentage, the mystery player hit for more power, and the end result is that they both had an OPS around .630 against left-handers. Player A is Garrett Jones through the 2010 season. That’s how long the Pirates gave Jones before they determined he was a platoon player. They brought in Matt Diaz for the 2011 season, Casey McGehee in 2012, and Gaby Sanchez for 2013. So far Jones has done his part in the platoon by hitting right-handers, and every time he’s seen an increased role against left-handers he has struggled. It’s pretty much accepted that Jones is a platoon player. So why haven’t we accepted the same thing from Alvarez after the same overall results in the same amount of playing time? I think Alvarez can settle in as a Carlos Pena/Mark Reynolds type player — hitting for a lot of power, but putting up a low average in the process. One thing that drives his average down is his inability to hit left-handers. If you added a platoon player who could replicate his power against left-handers, while hitting for a better average or getting on-base at a higher rate, then you’d add value from the third base position. The value wouldn’t be coming from Alvarez, but that’s not important. A guy like Brandon Inge would be the perfect complement to Alvarez in a platoon. Inge has a career .791 OPS against left-handers. He’s got a .194 ISO, which is better than Alvarez’s .144 ISO against lefties (.172 in 2012). He plays good defense at third, and can serve as a bench bat and backup infielder during the time that Alvarez is starting. The downside is that if you turn Alvarez into a platoon player now, he’s got no chance of improving against lefties. He’s seen some improvements with his power against left-handers over the last three years. 2010: .114 2011: .131 2012: .172 That was a big jump in 2012, and his OPS was .648, which was right around where it was in 2010 (again, he couldn’t hit anyone in 2011). So how do we know that’s the ceiling? What if Alvarez improves again in 2013? If he saw another improvement, he could become passable against left-handers just on his power alone. The reason I wouldn’t necessarily recommend Inge is because he has a Matt Diaz look to him. Diaz had good career numbers against lefties, but was coming off a down year when he came to the Pirates. He then proceeded to struggle against left-handers in 2011. Inge has good career numbers, but wasn’t close to those numbers in 2012. He had a .209/.276/.417 line. The ISO was better than Alvarez, but the OPS was only 50 points better. I’m not sure that a 50 point difference in OPS over about 100-200 at-bats is worth benching Alvarez. The Pirates would be better off waiting to see if Alvarez continues his upward trend of power against lefties. In the mean time, they can keep Inge in Triple-A or on the bench in the majors to see if he can still hit left-handed pitchers. If Alvarez doesn’t show any improvements against left-handers, or starts to fall from his 2012 power numbers, then it wouldn’t be a bad idea to start considering a platoon. Alvarez would still be able to provide an impact going up against right-handers, but a platoon in that situation would allow the Pirates to upgrade the at-bats where Alvarez would normally be struggling against lefties. Links and Notes **The 2013 Prospect Guide is now available. The 2013 Annual is also available for pre-sales. Go to the products page of the site and order your 2013 books today! **Spring Training 2013 Position Battles: Right Field. **Pirates Close to Deal With Brandon Inge.
GET THE YARDBARKER APP:
Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45
MORE FROM YARDBARKER

SEC commissioner wrote classy note to injured Arkansas RB

John Daly taken to hospital after collapsing on course

Rex Ryan keeping Bills' starting quarterback a secret

Braves fan dies after falling from upper deck

Randall Cobb suffers shoulder injury vs. Eagles

WATCH: John Harbaugh, Jay Gruden get into shouting match

LIKE WHAT YOU SEE?
GET THE DAILY NEWSLETTER:

WATCH: Brian Hartline drags toes on great TD catch

Julio Jones, Falcons agree on 5-year contract extension

WATCH: Blue Jays' Edwin Encarnacion blasts three homers, extends hit streak

WATCH: Usain Bolt does LeBron stomp dance after relay win

WATCH: Vick's first pass as a Steeler is a 63-yard bomb

WATCH: Montana's Ben Roberts makes amazing TD catch

Will Jimmer Fredette find success with Spurs?

Every NBA division's most interesting rookie for 2015-16

American Pharoah upset at Travers Stakes

Steve Smith joins family in stands after getting ejected from game

WATCH: Cordarrelle Patterson rips off 107-yard return TD

Steve Sarkisian giving up most of USC's playcalling duties

Animal shelter cancels fundraiser at Heinz Field

Mets acquire RP Addison Reed from Diamondbacks

WATCH: James Rodriguez scores unreal goals

Vin Scully: I believe next year will be my last

Charles Barkley wants to blow his former agent’s brains out

The Texas Rangers are firing on all cylinders

WATCH: Rutgers ends training camp with dance off

MLB News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

By clicking "Sign Me Up", you have read and agreed to the Fox Sports Digital Privacy Policy and Terms of Use. You can opt out at any time. For more information, please see our Privacy Policy.
the YARDBARKER app
Get it now!
Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45

Every NBA division's most interesting rookie for 2015-16

Fantasy football round-by-round draft strategy

Ronda Rousey's Carl’s Jr. ad

The WWE Divas Revolution is getting ugly

The NFL’s season kickoff isn’t going as planned, but plans don’t matter in the NFL

The Opening Drive: What happened to all the great Michigan tailbacks?

The 1980s Lakers represent the NBA’s ultimate creation story

The Orioles’ frustrating season

Five greatest NBA players of all-time

Finding signs of life for the Red Sox

Today's Best Stuff
For Publishers
Company Info
Help
Follow Yardbarker