Found August 16, 2013 on Waiting For Next Year:
In a season that largely has been better than expected, it’s hard to tell that based only on the vitriolic commentary about the Cleveland Indians. Yes, of late, among the variety of possible scapegoats, shortstop Asdrubal Cabrera has been the most prominent and deserving punching bag. The 27-year-old former All-Star has been all over the place this season and is mired in a rough six-week slump. While now-released Mark Reynolds and closer Chris Perez also have taken turns as the enemies in the fans’ eyes, the criticisms of one player just don’t sit well with me. This fellow 27-year-old has never been an All-Star, but deservingly could have been one over the past few years. He’s also having his best offensive full-season in the major leagues, as demonstrated by his 29 doubles, 60 walks, career-high batting average and 129 OPS+. This player is, yes, the defensive albatross of Carlos Santana. And for all his misgivings, he’s still a very valuable player and highly undervalued in Cleveland. Back on July 27 (here and here), I was already pretty tired of the fans’ hatred of Santana – even from my family members. Thus, I started re-sharing some comparisons to a player who my colleague Jon once accurately described as currently an “average left fielder,” Michael Brantley. Brantley is a full year younger than Santana, so he likely does still have more potential in terms of growing as a player. Both players are 100% under guaranteed Indians control through the 2016 season. But these two players receive – in general – starkly opposite reactions from the Cleveland fan base. While Santana is seen as a major liability with his defense who has failed to live up to some unwieldy offensive and slugging expectations, Brantley is “Dr. Smooth” and a natural cog for any team. So what do the numbers say about a comparison between these two? Per Baseball-Reference, this again shows the unseen value of Santana. In terms of non-statistical analysis, it’s notable that Brantley made his debut back in 2009, at just 22 years old. Santana starred for the Indians during his brief rookie season in 2010. The categories might be a bit complex at first for the uninitiated, so here’s a quick key. These all are related formulas that aim to estimate value added to the team: Rbat – Runs from batting better or worse than average Rbaser – Runs from baserunning better or worse than average Rdp – Runs from avoiding double plays better or worse than average Rfield – Runs from all fielding better or worse than average Rpos – Runs from positional scarcity better or worse than average RAA – Total runs above average (sum of previous five columns) Rrep – Replacement level adjustment, per playing time RAR – Total runs above replacement (sum of previous two columns) WAR – Total wins above replacement (approximately, RAR/10) Let me now share some observations from this chart: Starting with the guy who is not the focus of this article: Michael Brantley is perfectly average. Yes, over the past two seasons he has been 18 Runs Above Average – nearly 2 wins better. And, as I said before, he is a year younger than Santana and could conceivably still improve. But considering Brantley now plays at left field with little power and as not a great on-base guy, this contract extension talk is a bit baffling. Even FanGraphs agrees. On the other hand, Carlos Santana is not merely average. He has been 48 Runs Above Average in these four seasons, including 18 last year alone, equaling Brantley’s (far improved) totals from the past two seasons. Santana provides slightly negative value with his baserunning and double play avoidance, but that marks a difference of only about 1 win compared to Brantley. The biggest reason for Santana’s far-better advanced statistics: His hitting. It seems so ordinary, but yes, Santana is a far better offensive producer than Brantley. With his bat alone, Santana has produced 6 wins more than the average player over these four seasons. His Batting Runs pace in 2013 (18 in 113 games) is by far his best for a full-time season. In fact, according to some research last night, Santana’s 127 career OPS+ ranks sixth-best all-time among catchers with 1,500 plate appearances. That’s extraordinary. The place where Santana receives the most criticism is with his defense. Catcher defensive statistics are still very raw, as Jon and others have shared. There is no real knowing how accurate these numbers are. Many teams likely have more advanced proprietary statistics, but there’s a reason why those are secretive and us lay fans are left with free sites like Baseball-Reference and FanGraphs. That being said, Santana’s defense was rated as fairly average over the previous three seasons. During that span, he was just 4 runs below average in terms of all aspects of fielding, a perfectly negligible number, especially with his advanced batting abilities. This season, he’s perhaps easily the worst defensive catcher in the game at 14 runs below average. Near-historic wild pitches have been an issue. Rookie Yan Gomes is out-playing him defensively in many fashions. While many want to say that stats don’t explain the true value of Michael Brantley, it’s then conversely factual that the naked eye doesn’t tell the true value of Carlos Santana. The ways in which the player acquired for Casey Blake in July 2008 is extraordinary aren’t really the sexiest aspects of baseball. Let’s take a look back at his career statistics, especially his rates per plate appearances of various outcomes (click the image to expand it and get a better view): The two minor league seasons where he had the largest sample sizes were in 2008 and 2009. The latter season, I was the media relations intern for the Akron Aeros when Santana played 130 out of 142 games and won the Eastern League Most Valuable Player award. From that season, I gained an up-close appreciation for Santana’s noted consistency and his remarkable patience at the plate. As a minor leaguer, he singled in 15.7% of his at-bats and walked in 13.4%. Just from those two possible outcomes – out of all of the things that could happen in the world – Santana’s on-base percentage was already over .290. He finished his MiLB career in 1,683 plate appearances with a spectacular .401 on-base percentage. What’s noteworthy is that Santana wasn’t a major slugger in the minors. He had a .210 iso rate (SLG – AVG), which was more because of his solid doubles numbers (69 in 2008 and 2009) than anything. At best, as a major league player, Santana was projected to hit homers in the 20-25 range or so each season. That was never his strength. Yet he was still an incredibly rare offensive talent. That talent and projectability shines through to his major league production. He walks a bit less, strikes out a bit more and overall isn’t as dominant – as expected against far better pitching. But the ratios are all fairly similar. His on-base percentage at .363 is stellar, ranking 33rd in baseball (min. 1,000 PAs) since 2010. He slugged 27 dingers in 2011, but he has exactly just one more homer and one more double in the majors than in the minors. All this goes to say that Carlos Santana as a 27-year-old MLB starter is much what we thought he would be as a 23-year-old Double-A MVP. He’s not a perfect player. He was old for his various minor league levels. But his offensive skills shine through as one of the best in baseball. Long-term, there will need to be a conversation about Santana’s defensive position. Gomes clearly has had a breakout season – despite never really being a prospect – and has deserved more playing time. Undoubtedly, when Santana moves to first base more often, he will take an added penalty for his overall value based on Rpos, the relative positional scarcity above or below average. While many think Santana has regressed overall as a player, there just flat-out wrong. His offensive numbers continue to shine and with the advanced specialization of bullpens and more, his consistent production is far more impressive compared to league norms. There’s no reason for him to be in the same conversation of the Cabreras or Reynolds or Brantleys, since his offense and overall value is simply still so darn good. – (AP Photo/Tony Dejak)
THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
RELATED ARTICLES

Trend Spotting: On Zach McAllister and Scott Kazmir

Part two of evaluating Indians starting pitching to date and the recent results have been somewhere south of acceptable. The two guys we will be taking a look at are Zach McAllister and Scott Kazmir. The purposes of evaluating each will be slightly different, with McAllister it will be to suggest whether or not his success is sustainable and what to expect from him over the course...

'You can't hear his voice and not think of the Cleveland Indians'

CLEVELAND --Tom Hamilton has gone through this Cleveland Indians season almost like a player. Hes nearly blown a head gasket broadcasting the Indians nine walkoff wins. Hes played hurt. And hes been involved in a wee bit of controversy. Through it all Hamilton remains part of the team. Hes the recognizable voice of the Indians, and the friendliest, most upbeat guy imaginable, a guy...

Around The Farm: August 14, 2013

Around the Farm takes a quick look at some of yesterday’s performances by Indians prospects throughout the system. The positions listed below are where the player was playing in yesterday’s game. Note that the AZL Indians were off last night. Jake Lowery (C, Akron): 2-for-3, 1 BB It has been a while since Cleveland has developed a catcher, as Carlos Santana, Yan Gomes, and Lou...

Aguilar Sends Homer and Losing Streak Out of the Park

Akron, OH — It turns out that a change of scenery back to the friendly confines of Canal Park was exactly what the Aeros needed to snap their troublesome, six-game losing streak. Jesus Aguilar’s towering, tape-measure, three-run home run to left field in the bottom of the eighth inning rescued the Aeros from a 2-0 deficit, and led to a thrilling, 3-2 win over the Reading Fightin...

Around The Farm: August 15, 2013

Around the Farm takes a quick look at some of yesterday’s performances by Indians prospects throughout the system. The positions listed below are where the player was playing in yesterday’s game.  Dorssys Paulino (SS, Lake County): 1-for-3, 1 R, 1 HR, 1 RBI, 1 BB Lake County won by a score of 1-0 Thursday night with Paulino's solo shot being the only scoring on the night...

Clippers edge Indians 4-2

INDIANAPOLIS- Despite being out-hit by the Indianapolis Indians eight to six, the Columbus Clippers squeaked by with a 4-2 victory Thursday at Victory Field. Indianapolis right-hander Stolmy Pimentel tossed a excellent game but the Clipper offense came through with some timely hitting to best the starter. Clipper second baseman Juan Diaz was issued a two-out walk in the top of...

Adams, Aeros crumble late, lose 4-3 for sixth loss in a row

RICHMOND, VA- Hoping to turn their luck around against Richmond Wednesday night, the Aeros couldn't stop Richmond from scoring late in the game. Leading most of the game, it seemed as though the Aeros starter Will Roberts would pull the Aeros out of their losing streak. Unfortunately, an eighth inning three run home run by Richmond's Mark Minicozzi took the game right out...

Second Thoughts: Playoff outlook on a positive Thursday

The Minnesota series and really the last week and a half have been troubling even if you are a glass half full guy. Of course one could say the Indians have won three of their last four games to hang around in the wild card race.  Or you could point out that they have won three out of their last ten games, and struggled to take a series against a bad Minnesota team as well as barely...

Indians fail to capitalize on walks, drop series opener 3-2

Oakland, CA -- Eric Sogard hit a two-out, run-scoring double off Cleveland starter Justin Masterson, as the Oakland A's beat the Indians 3-2 in the opener of a three-game series. After Masterson induced two quick ground outs to begin the seventh, Stepehen Voght singled to right to act as the go-ahead run. Sogard followed with a double into the right-field corner, scoring Voght...

Report: Yankees sign Mark Reynolds

A person familiar with the deal says the New York Yankees have signed free-swinging corner infielder Mark Reynolds. Reynolds was released by the Cleveland Indians last week after a monthslong slump. The person spoke on condition of anonymity Thursday night because the deal has not been announced. Reynolds will provide a right-handed bat to back up lefty swinging Lyle Overbay at...

Yankees sign Mark Reynolds to a contract

The New York Yankees have signed infielder Mark Reynolds to a major league contract. Reynolds, 30, was released by the Cleveland Indians earlier this week and choose to sign with the Yankees over three other clubs. While Reynolds batted only .215/.307/.373 with the Indians he did mash 15 home runs and could see regular time filling in at first, third and the DH spot in New York.

Yankees land power bat with addition of Mark Reynolds

Mark Reynolds has agreed to a deal with the Yankees CBSSports.com has learned. Reynolds will help with the Yankees' right-handed power which has been an issue most of the year. Reynolds had 15 home runs 48 RBI and a .215 batting average when he was designated for assignment by the Indians. Reynolds has hit 14 home runs against the Yankeees in 165 at-bats most vs any AL team...

Series Preview: Indians at Athletics 8/16-18

There is a lot of scoreboard watching at this time of year, with the Indians competing in some way or another with Detroit, Oakland, Tampa Bay, Baltimore, Kansas City with Boston and Texas possibly in the mix in the future. With all those teams to watch, the most important games to the Indians remain their own. They did a good job coming back to win their last series against Minnesota...

Indians-Athletics Preview

Neither the Cleveland Indians nor the Oakland Athletics have played overly well of late, but both remain entrenched in the AL wild-card chase. This weekend's series between the clubs could go a long way in determining their postseason fate. The Athletics look to avenge a four-game sweep at the hands of Cleveland earlier this year as they host the Indians on Friday night. Oakland...
MLB News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.