Originally posted on Fox Sports Detroit  |  Last updated 11/11/12
DETROIT -- Justin Verlander deserves to win his second consecutive American League Cy Young Award. He's unlikely to get it, though, when the results of voting by the Baseball Writers Association of America are announced Wednesday night. Tampa Bays David Price is the favorite, and Jered Weaver of the Angels also could finish ahead of Verlander among those three finalists. Price already got the stamp of approval from his AL peers. They honored him last week with the 2012 Players Choice award for pitchers. Among baseball pundits, one doesn't think Verlander even deserves to be a Cy Young finalist. Harold Reynolds of the MLB Network said he would have picked Tampa Bay closer and ex-Tiger Fernando Rodney over Verlander. So the Tigers ace has his detractors, and Price would be a fine choice for the Cy Young. But lets look at the case for Verlander: He was 17-8 with a 2.64 ERA and a league-leading 239 strikeouts. Verlander, at 7.5, also had the runaway best Wins Above Replacement rating of any pitcher in the league. Rounding out the top five are Price (6.4); Matt Harrison, Rangers (6.2); Chris Sale, White Sox (5.7); and Felix Hernandez, Mariners (4.6). Ratings of 8.0 or above are MVP quality and 5.0-plus is All-Star worthy. This statistic is all the rage with sabermetricians, who have concocted it by pouring oodles of numbers into a formula that takes every player quality under the sun into consideration and spits out a rating that few understand. Angels outfielder Mike Trouts MVP candidacy is being touted largely because of his major league-leading 10.7 WAR rating. Hey, if its being used by some to deny Tigers Triple Crown winner Miguel Cabrera the MVP, why not use it to win the Cy Young for Verlander? Turnabout, after all, is fair play. I have my own formula, just devised, to make an even better case for Verlander: Pitching Quotient. It gives equal weight to wins, earned-run average, strikeouts, WHIP (walks plus hits per inning pitched) and WAR. Im proposing this rating system because most cant agree on which pitching statistic is most important. Based on recent Cy Young voting, wins aren't supposed to matter. Hernandez won it with a 13-12 record in 2010, when CC Sabathia of the Yankees was 21-7. In 2009, Zack Greinke, then with the Royals, won it with a 16-8 mark, while Hernandez, Sabathia and Verlander each won 19 games. So why should Verlander be penalized for a lack of wins this year -- especially after having eight quality starts for a defensively-porous team end up as losses or no decisions? Earned-run average has become the favorite measuring stick in recent years. Five of the last six major league ERA winners won a Cy in their league. But that happend after four consecutive major league ERA leaders didn't win the Cy. There doesnt seem to be any long-term consensus on just how important any one stat matters -- although Hernandez (2.27) and Greinke (2.16) won almost strictly based on ERA. This year, Price (20-5, 2.56, 209 strikeouts) is the AL leader in ERA, with Verlander a close second. Verlander took the other pitching Triple Crown stat, strikeouts. Weaver (20-5, 2.81, 142 strikeouts) tied for Price for most victories and led the league with a 1.018 WHIP. Based on the statistical split decision, the Cy Young race should be a tossup. Thats where the Pitching Quotient comes into play as an evaluation tool. Heres how it works: Award 5 points to the league leader in each of these categories -- wins, earned-run average, strikeouts, WHIP and WAR -- and scale down from there: 4 points for second, 3 points for third, 2 points for fourth and 1 point for fifth. Then total the points for each pitcher and divide it by five, for the number of categories, to get their average point total. A pitcher finishing first in each statistic would rate a 5.0. Verlander, with 3.9 points on the Pitcher Quotient, is the easy winner. Price is second at 3.1 and Weaver third at 2.5. By choosing to focus only on the accepted Triple Crown pitching stats -- wins, earned run average and strikeouts -- Verlander drops to 3.5 on that limited Pitcher Quotient formula, with Price (3.2) and Weaver (2.5) close behind. Even with all that number crunching, were not giving Verlander any formula credit for leading the league with 238 13 innings pitched and six complete games. In fairness to Price, he had seven quality starts in which he either lost or didnt figure in the decision. Thats just one fewer quality start without a win than Verlander had -- athough Price had a far superior defense playing behind him. If youre not into statistics, simply trust your eyes. FOX Sports analyst Tim McCarver did during the postseason and several times called Verlander the best pitcher on the planet. We'll find out Wednesday if the Baseball Writers Association of America agree.
GET THE YARDBARKER APP:
Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45
MORE FROM YARDBARKER

WATCH: K-State players storm student section after big win

Tony Dungy coaches his way into Canton

Top eight takeaways from NFL Honors awards

Report: Austin Rivers out 4-6 weeks with broken hand

Brett Favre Hall of Fame discussion took less than 10 seconds

WATCH: Pop wishes Kobe well in heartfelt message

LIKE WHAT YOU SEE?
GET THE DAILY NEWSLETTER:

Eric Berry named NFL Comeback Player of the Year

Cam Newton to be named NFL MVP

Ezekiel Elliott hung out with Jim Brown

Rickie Fowler taunted by fans over his ex-girlfriend

Roger Goodell speaks about future of Pro Bowl in annual address

Mike Krzyzewski provides an update on his health

Another star confirmed for Super Bowl 50 halftime show

WATCH: Wayne Simmonds loses his cool, earns match penalty

Winners and losers from 2016 Hall of Fame vote

Brett Favre, Tony Dungy headline Hall of Fame Class of 2016

Terrell Owens says he was not elected to Hall of Fame

Bruins prospect hit in throat with puck, taken to hospital

WATCH: Mavs rookie laughed at for trash talking Spurs bench

Norris Cole has No. 30 retired with LeBron James, New Orleans Pelicans in attendance

Three keys to victory for the Broncos in Super Bowl 50

Torrey Smith: ‘This is probably the best offense’ for Kaepernick

Byron Scott thought D’Angelo Russell would be further along

Under-the-radar Super Bowl 50 matchups

Is Tim Lincecum's run with the San Francisco Giants done?

MLB News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

By clicking "Sign Me Up", you have read and agreed to the Fox Sports Digital Privacy Policy and Terms of Use. You can opt out at any time. For more information, please see our Privacy Policy.
the YARDBARKER app
Get it now!
Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45

The 14 biggest plays in Super Bowl history

Five outrageous predictions for Super Bowl 50

QUIZ: Name the winning starting quarterback from every Super Bowl

The top six matchups that could decide Super Bowl 50

Seven unheralded players set to make major impacts in SB 50

10 underrated performances in the NBA Slam Dunk Contest

X-factors in Super Bowl 50

NHL nightmare: No Canadian teams in playoff hunt

QUIZ: Name the Super Bowl halftime performers since 1991

Manziel's father fears for QB's life

Today's Best Stuff
For Publishers
Company Info
Help
Follow Yardbarker