Found November 30, 2012 on Raise the Jolly Roger!:
The Pirates are indeed going to non-tender Jeff Karstens. Jeff was entering his third arbitration year and was projected to make around $4 million. Instead, the Bucs are allowing him to become a free agent. This move doesn’t make sense to me. Karstens has shown to be a very reliable starter/long reliever during his time for the Pirates, which spanned parts of five seasons. Obviously he’s no ace or anything like that, but to me he was a steady middle-of-the-rotation presence that gives the team a good chance to win every time he takes the mound . His numbers aren’t going to blow anyone away but in 2011 and 2012 he improved quite a bit, posting a 3.59 ERA over 41 starts. The decision to let Karstens go comes down to two things: cost and health. Karstens missed two months early in the season with shoulder inflammation, then missed another couple of weeks after a hip flexor problem in late August. The injury forced him out of this strong performance against the Brewers in the seventh inning, but he insisted he was fine afterwards. Jeff made his next start on the road against the Brewers and got shelled–it was apparent that he wasn’t really ready to pitch. He hit the DL, but even when he returned and was healthy the Pirates essentially ignored him for the rest of the year, sticking him in the bullpen while giving starts to Kevin Correia, Jeff Locke, and Kyle McPherson. As the non-tender rumors started to swirl this offseason, the thought seemed to be that his injury concerns or lack of durability would be the cause. To me, if he’s completely healthy now, I don’t understand why the Pirates wouldn’t take a risk on him. $4 million or so is good value even if he does miss some time…heck, the Pirates gave $5 million to Erik Bedard last year using that exact mentality. I do think it’s worthwhile to note that the Pirates doctors/staff know about Karstens’ arm/shoulder/hip/whatever better than anybody else right now and they could have easily seen something that led to this decision. For the Pirates’ sake (not Jeff’s–he’s a great guy and I wish him well) I hope that is the case, because if not this seems like a very poor decision to me. Taking Karstens out of the equation leaves the Pirates’ rotation like this: A.J. Burnett, Wandy Rodriguez, James McDonald, Locke, and McPherson. Gerrit Cole is lurking in Indy, but won’t start the season in the Burgh.  Even assuming Cole can make it up relatively soon, the rotation is going to need some work, and the non-tender of Karstens (following yesterday’s hefty investment into Russell Martin) leaves doubt as to whether or not the Bucs will spend to address it. Starting pitching is expensive and the 2013 payroll already looks like it’ll be around $65M as things stand now (most don’t expect it to top $70M). Again, maybe there was something with Karstens the Pirates didn’t like and maybe they have plans to invest heavily in an upgrade. There’s a lot of offseason left and it’s silly to judge everything before the Bucs get a chance to replace him (a lot of folks weren’t happy about declining Paul Maholm‘s option last year, but that was later offset by the additions of Bedard and Burnett), but I think the Pirates have made things harder on themselves here. PHOTO: Charles LeClaire-US PRESSWIRE
THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
RELATED ARTICLES

Pirates Trade Yamaico Navarro and Chris Resop

Chris Resop has been traded to the Athletics. The Pittsburgh Pirates have made two trades, dealing Yamaico Navarro and Chris Resop in separate deals, both announced by a team press release. They dealt Navarro to the Orioles for Jhondaniel Medina, and dealt Resop to the Athletics for Zach Thornton. Medina has pitched as high as short-season A-ball, although he only had four innings...

First Pitch: Trying to Make Sense of Today’s Moves

The Pirates had a busy day. They traded Chris Resop, who was arbitration eligible for the second time and projected to make $1.3 M. They also dealt Yamaico Navarro (same link), who wasn’t arbitration eligible, but was designated for assignment the other day. They non-tendered Jeff Karstens, then reached a deal with Charlie Morton for $2 M (I’ll get into this in a bit). Finally...

Winter Leagues Recap: Fuesser Throws Six Shutout Innings Again

In Winter League action last night, Starling Marte had a rough game, going 0-for-4 with three strikeouts. In his previous three games combined, Marte has a total of seven hits and eight RBI’s. Alen Hanson had his second straight pinch-running appearance. He was immediately erased on a caught stealing. Hanson was playing in his seventh game of the DWL season. Anderson Hernandez...

Pirates would like Jason Grilli to return, interest as closer elsewhere

 The Pittsburgh Pirates are pushing to break .500 in 2013. With a reported signing of Russell Martin as the teams backstop the Pirates are working to re-sign Jason Grilli. Grilli was a key cog in the Pirates bullpen last season setting up for closer Joel Hanrahan. Should the Pirates be successful in re-signing Grilli, he would figure to be first inline between Hanrahan for saves...

Mark Appel Tops the Early 2013 Draft Rankings

Today Baseball America released their top 100 college prospects for the 2013 draft. At the top of the list was Mark Appel, who ranked as the top prospect in the draft in their rankings back in August. That’s similar to last year, when Appel was the top prospect in the draft pre-season, but fell to eighth overall on draft day. Other notable players on the list: 21. Kent Emanuel...

First Pitch: Why the Pirates Shouldn’t (Have) Sign(ed) Russell Martin

Earlier today I wrote my “First Pitch” article, titled “Why the Pirates Shouldn’t Sign Russell Martin”. I spent some time taking a deep look at Martin, and looking at the Pirates’ situation. I had it all set up to post at midnight. Then the Pirates signed Martin to a two year, $17 M deal. Nothing really changed with my thoughts below, except for the fact that the move...

Bucs trade Resop, sign Morton, tender others

The Pirates’ decision to non-tender Jeff Karstens was the big news of the day, but they still had seven other players to deal with in advance of Friday’s midnight deadline. Chris Resop was traded to Oakland for Zach Stewart, a reliever in high-A ball. Basically, he was non-tendered and the Bucs got a tiny return instead of nothing. I thought there was a chance Resop would be...

Pirates Make the Russell Martin Signing Official

The Pittsburgh Pirates have made the Russell Martin signing official via a team press release. The release includes the following quote from Neal Huntington. “With the signing of Russell Martin, we have acquired a quality defensive catcher who is a disciplined hitter that adds power to our lineup,” said Huntington. “He also brings experience, leadership and a strong desire...

Pirates Trying to Retain Grilli

Ken Rosenthal has Ann update on the Pirates and Jason Grilli. https://mobile.twitter.com/Ken_Rosenthal/status/2745601049620848644 Grilli would probably require a two year deal. He’d be a great option for the Pirates as a closer if they deal Joel Hanrahan this off season. As a set up man he would be expensive for the Pirates, since he’d probably command $3-4 M per year.

Pirates Tender Five, Come To Terms With Morton

The Pittsburgh Pirates have tendered offers to Neil Walker, James McDonald, Joel Hanrahan, Garrett Jones, and Gaby Sanchez.  No real surprise there. Charlie Morton has also agreed to a deal with the Pirates.  No word on what that deal entails but it’s at least slightly amusing that Charlie Morton, who will almost certainly miss time [...]

Chan Ho Park retires from baseball

Chan Ho Park last pitched in 2011 with the Orix Buffaloes. His last appearance in Major League Baseball came in 2010 with the Pittsburgh Pirates. Park spent seventeen seasons in the major leagues after signing with the Los Angeles Dodgers in 1994. Park, 39,  was once one of the best pitchers in baseball. In his eight seasons with the Dodgers the right hander was 80-54 with a 3.80...

Pirates fill hole behind the plate with Russell Martin

The Pittsburgh Pirates were reportedly hot in pursuit of former Yankees catcher Russell Martin, and for two years and $17 million, Martin is now a Pirate. Martin, who will turn 30 this coming February, made $7.5 million with the Yankees this past season, his second with the club. In 133 games, he had 21 homers and a .211/.311/.403 line, providing 2.2 wins above replacement for...

Pirates Sign Russell Martin

As per Ken Rosenthal on Twitter, the Pirates have reached terms with Russell Martin, pending a physical.   We will continue to flesh this out with more details about the terms of the deal as they become available.
MLB News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.