Originally written on Fangraphs  |  Last updated 11/20/14

Eric Seidmen wrote an interesting article last Thursday about Atlanta reliever Craig Kimbrel‘s historic strikeout pace. So far, Kimbrel is sporting a blistering 42.7% strikeout rate (K%). Even for a relief pitcher in this era, that’s incredibly impressive. But one person who commented on the story noted that there was a non-reliever approaching the same level of whiff greatness (i.e. > 30% strikeout rate).

Nationals phenom Stephen Strasburg has thrown 182 innings in the big leagues and has struck out 32.5% of the batters he’s faced. No starting pitcher who lasted any significant amount of time ever finished his career with a strikeout rate higher than 30%. The closest  is Randy Johnson and his 28.5% strikeout rate. This season, Strasburg has a 33% strikeout rate. If he were to maintain that pace, he’d be the 10th starting pitcher in history to achieve the feat and would have the 23rd such season since 1916. But take a look at that list and you’ll note that the oldest instance came back in 1984.

The problem we run into with strikeouts — like many statistics in baseball — is that the playing environment has changed over time.

The average rate at which pitchers record strikeouts has jumped dramatically since 1916 (the earliest year we can calculate strikeout percentage). That year, the league-average starter had a 10.5 K%. Compare that to the current 18.6% rate this year, and we have a massive gap. Whether hitters are more prone to strikeouts, pitchers are simply nastier now, or some combination of environmental and structural changes to the game (e.g. how players are selected, technology, etc.), the fact is a strikeout in 1916 was rarer than one today.

Fortunately, integrating some context into the conversation is incredibly easy. We simply need to calculate a “plus” statistic for strikeout rate so that we can compare how much better than league-average an individual pitcher’s strikeout rate is in a given season. Here’s the formula for calculating what I will call K%+: [(Pitcher's K% / League Average K%) * 100].

Similar to wRC+, a K%+ of 100 means that a pitcher’s strikeout rate was league-average*. A pitcher with a 125 K%+ would have a strikeout rate 25% better than league average, and a 75 would indicate a rate 25% worse than league-average.

So if we adjust all individual qualified starter seasons since 1916 in this way, which pitcher had the greatest single season in terms of strikeout rate? The one and only Dazzy Vance.

Vance posted a 21.5 K% in 1924, which ranks as the 404th-best strikeout rate in a single season. But back then, the league-average K% was a mere 6.9%. That means Vance posted a whopping 312 K%+. That season, Walter Johnson had the second-highest K% at 13.8%, which translates to a 200 K%+**.

In fact, if we look at a K%+ leader board, Dazzy Vance appears more dominant in terms of strikeouts than any other pitcher.

Season Name K% League K% K%+ K% Rank K%+ Rank 1924 Dazzy Vance 21.5% 6.9% 312 404 1 1925 Dazzy Vance 20.3% 6.9% 294 587 2 1926 Dazzy Vance 19.6% 7.2% 272 725 3 1926 Lefty Grove 18.1% 7.2% 251 1082 4 1928 Dazzy Vance 17.8% 7.4% 241 1160 5 1999 Pedro Martinez 37.5% 15.6% 240 1 6 1941 Johnny Vander Meer 21.4% 9.2% 233 419 7 1984 Dwight Gooden 31.4% 13.5% 233 14 8 1928 Lefty Grove 17.0% 7.4% 230 1389 9 1946 Hal Newhouser 23.4% 10.2% 229 205 10 1927 Dazzy Vance 16.4% 7.2% 228 1627 11 1923 Dazzy Vance 16.6% 7.3% 227 1546 12 1946 Bob Feller 23.0% 10.2% 225 241 13 2001 Randy Johnson 36.7% 16.4% 224 2 14 1979 J.R. Richard 26.6% 11.9% 224 66 15 1939 Bob Feller 19.8% 8.9% 222 684 16 1976 Nolan Ryan 27.4% 12.4% 221 53 17 1995 Randy Johnson 34.0% 15.4% 221 6 18 2000 Pedro Martinez 34.8% 15.8% 220 3 19 2000 Randy Johnson 34.7% 15.8% 220 4 20 1989 Nolan Ryan 30.5% 13.9% 219 17 21 1955 Herb Score 25.1% 11.5% 218 120 22 1938 Bob Feller 19.2% 8.8% 218 799 23 1927 Lefty Grove 15.7% 7.2% 218 1908 24 1978 J.R. Richard 26.6% 12.2% 218 66 25 1928 George Earnshaw 16.1% 7.4% 218 1753 26 1999 Randy Johnson 33.7% 15.6% 216 7 27 1930 Lefty Grove 17.6% 8.2% 215 1219 28 1936 Van Mungo 18.1% 8.5% 213 1082 29 1978 Nolan Ryan 25.8% 12.2% 211 93 30

Vance has four of the top five spots on the list and six of the top 12. Of his 11 qualifying seasons, his 170 K%+ was his worst. The best non-Vance season came fromLefty Grove in 1926 (251 K%+). To add some additional context, Randy Johnson posted eight seasons with a K% of greater than or equal to 30% (most all time, double the number by Pedro Martinez). Here’s Johnson’s top 10 K%+ seasons, compared to Vance:

Season Name K% League K% K%+ K% Rank K%+ Rank 1924 Dazzy Vance 21.50% 6.9% 312 404 1 1925 Dazzy Vance 20.30% 6.9% 294 587 2 1926 Dazzy Vance 19.60% 7.2% 272 725 3 1928 Dazzy Vance 17.80% 7.4% 241 1160 5 1927 Dazzy Vance 16.40% 7.2% 228 1627 11 1923 Dazzy Vance 16.60% 7.3% 227 1546 12 1930 Dazzy Vance 16.30% 8.2% 199 1670 58 1931 Dazzy Vance 16.30% 8.2% 199 1670 58 1929 Dazzy Vance 12.90% 7.3% 177 3291 136 1922 Dazzy Vance 12.50% 7.2% 174 3533 155 2001 Randy Johnson 36.70% 16.4% 224 2 14 1995 Randy Johnson 34.00% 15.4% 221 6 18 2000 Randy Johnson 34.70% 15.8% 220 4 20 1999 Randy Johnson 33.70% 15.6% 216 7 27 1997 Randy Johnson 34.20% 16.3% 210 5 36 1993 Randy Johnson 29.30% 14.2% 206 28 40 2002 Randy Johnson 32.30% 16.0% 202 11 50 1998 Randy Johnson 32.50% 16.3% 199 10 56 1994 Randy Johnson 29.40% 15.3% 192 27 81 2004 Randy Johnson 30.10% 16.0% 188 21 91

Johnson’s best season ranks 14th in terms of K%+; Vance had six seasons better than that. The point here isn’t to say that Johnson wasn’t that great (he was phenomenal), but to illustrate how much the changing environment impacts just how great today’s strikeout artists compare to those who played long ago.

So, getting back to Strasburg. Let’s assume he finishes this season with a 33% strikeout rate. As impressive as that would be, it would still only rank 129th historically in terms of K%+ — by far the lowest of the other 23 30%+ strikeout rate seasons we’ve seen from starting pitchers. Now, 129th out of 6,980 seasons is nothing to sneeze at. But it does illustrate the need to put the current strikeout successes that we are seeing into historical context. Strasburg is undoubtedly one of the most talented strikeout pitchers the game has seen. But he also is pitching in the most strikeout-friendly era of the past 96 years.

——————

**If we had K% data going back further, Johnson would no doubt have been more of a force on the leader boards.

MORE FROM YARDBARKER

Rex Ryan: My wife could coach Tom Brady

LIKE WHAT YOU SEE?

Why the Saints are legit playoff threat

For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.