Found August 26, 2013 on
The Detroit Sports Site:
New York Mets
This past week, Max Scherzer added two more wins to his astonishing stat line, pushing his total to 19 for the 2013 season. As the victories pile up, Scherzer also continues to impress along the way statistically.
As a result, at this point in the season, there’s no use debating who should be the American League Cy Young award winner. Scherzer, with his eye popping win-loss record, dominating strikeout numbers and low ERA is the only conventional choice among all the available pitchers.
The critics, of course, will argue that Scherzer is playing for the best offense in baseball, receiving nearly five runs a game of support. Never mind the fact that Scherzer himself has very good statistics, whiffing the second most batters in baseball, trailing only Yu Darvish by 29 strikeouts while having the fourth best ERA in the league. He’s raised his game against Detroit’s divisional competiton (3-0 against Cleveland with a 2.70 ERA, 3-0 versus Kansas City); he’s won pitching duels like this weekend’s against Matt Harvey. What else must Scherzer do to prove himself worthy?
Naturally, all anybody wants to do is come up with reasons why Scherzer shouldn’t win the award. Playing with good teammates should do nothing to diminish his personal achievements, the likes of which haven’t been seen since Roger Clemens in Toronto and New York. Besides, any of the best pitchers would likely admit they had help from their teammates along the way in order to achieve their levels of personal success.
Scherzer, as he continues to win almost every match up, adds to the list of superhuman accomplishments by Tigers’ players lately. There was Justin Verlander’s phenomenal 2011 season, Miguel Cabrera’s fantastic triple crown year in 2012 and now, amongst more Cabrera drama chasing a second straight triple crown, Scherzer has very quietly racked up 19 wins to only one loss. That’s five better than the closest competition in the victory category and two better in the loss column. The competition simply doesn’t stack up.
Once again, just like the silly questions about if Verlander and Cabrera’s 2011 and 2012 performances were MVP-worthy, there’s no doubt that Scherzer deserves to win the Cy Young. The eye test has been present this season, as he’s dominated and won nearly every game he’s pitched in with the exception of one. In late August, what pitcher can ever say that? Only Ray Face and Johnny Allen could, and until he lost his final two decisions, Clemens in 2001. That places Scherzer within pretty rarified pitching air.
Any time history intervenes, there shouldn’t be a question in the minds of the voters. They should always make the easiest choice and reward a fantastic, once in a lifetime type performance. Scherzer’s turning in something special from the mound in 2013, and has already earned the hardware.
After Scherzer’s 18th victory this week, we posted a graphic celebrating the accomplishment on Facebook. One of our savvy readers managed to notice yet another reason Scherzer’s season should be considered a lock for the Cy Young award in 2013.
Shelley Woodworth: Love the fact that he didn’t walk a batter today!
That was fantastic. Consider, also, that Scherzer hasn’t walked a batter in six games this year, while Matt Moore has only accomplished the feat twice, Yu Darvish three times, Justin Masterson once and Felix Hernandez five times. The deeper baseball voters want to go with statistics, Scherzer still manages to prevail over all his competition.
Max DeMara is a senior editor at The Detroit Sports Site. You can find him on Twitter @SportsGuyTheMax
BEST OF MAXIM
AROUND THE WEB
Max Scherzer is an incredible 19-1, and he’s also considered the frontrunner in this year’s race for the American League Cy Young Award. There is no debating the reality of his record — his record is his record, as numbers are numbers. There is, however, debating whether or not he should be in the lead […]
1st Round Picks over the last 10 years: Detroit Tigers
The Detroit Tigers have had some rather solid success under the regime of GM David Dombrowski and his Director of Scouting David Chadd. The Tigers were known for spending “over slot” to get the guy they wanted for several seasons before bonus spending caps went into place. The Tigers also have been able to draft some lesser...
The Detroit Tigers' bullpen has been in flux for most of the season, and one reason for this inconsistency has been the absence of right-handed reliever Octavio Dotel. The veteran has been recovering from injury for much of the year, as there were even questions whether or not he'd pitch again. Since then, Dotel has resumed pitching, and he recently joined the Tigers'...
Recently it appeared the the Detroit Tigers could be without catcher Alex Avila for an extended stretch after he experienced a headache during a rehab contest. However, Avila made it through another few rehab games without feeling any ill effects, and manager Jim Leyland told reporters -- including Jason Beck of MLB.com -- that, if everything continues to check out OK, there'...
DETROIT It has been about two months since I thought Miguel Cabrera could win the Triple Crown in consecutive seasons. Hes running away with a third straight batting title and the RBI crown. However, Baltimore Orioles first baseman Chris Davis has stayed comfortably ahead in the home run derby.
Cabrera would hit one to draw closer, and Davis would hit one to keep the lead safe...
77-54, 1st place, 5.5 up on the Indians.
The Tigers just treated us to one of the most exciting games of the season, but wound up on the wrong side of 8-6. There was another Miggy Moment, the 2-run HR to right field on a 3-1 pitch off the plate that tied the game. Miguel Cabrera is the Babe Ruth of our time, make no mistake. No pinstripes on that guy, either. He’s a TIGER. Fielder...
Max Scherzer is now 19-1 after picking up a win in Saturday’s game against the New York Mets.
Scherzer pitched six scoreless innings and struck out 11 Mets.
The 29-year-old right-hander has a 2.73 ERA and a 0.91 WHIP. Scherzer allowed three hits and walked three while throwing 78 of 118 pitches for strikes.
This time a month ago Scherzer was sporting a 3.14 ERA...
With the Tigers clinging to a one-run lead in the top of the ninth closer Joaquin Benoit was starting to warm up in the bullpen.
Before the Tigers made their second out Benoit was no longer needed to save the game as the lead had ballooned in the raucous ninth.
Eight consecutive batters reached base — seven on singles — and the Tigers quickly turned a nail-biter into a laugher...
By STEVE KORNACKI
DETROIT Detroit Tigers catcher Alex Avila returned from the seven-day concussion disabled list on Tuesday, and was back in starting lineup against the Oakland As. Hed been through plenty in the last three weeks, having had his left ear bleed after taking a foul ball off his catchers mask and experiencing headaches and nausea before a concussion...
In 2012, Miguel Cabrera added to his mantle a Triple-Crown and a hotly-contested MVP, edging out Mike Trout in one of the most debated award-races in recent memory.
In 2013, there will be no such debate. In 2013, the question isn’t whether Miguel Cabrera’s season deserves to stand atop the current crop of players that look so human in comparison.
The question is where this season...
The Dominican Summer League playoffs started today, with the Pirates2 taking on the Detroit Tigers affiliate. The playoff format is best of three in the first round, with the two best teams in the league getting first round byes. The Pirates2 won the Wildcard spot with a 46-26 record, so they met up against the Tigers, who finished 49-22 on the season. The two teams played each other...
NEW YORK (AP) -- Max Scherzer outpitched Matt Harvey in their All-Star rematch, striking out 11 and hitting a stunning RBI double that sent the Detroit Tigers to a 3-0 victory over the New York Mets on Saturday.
Scherzer (19-1) joined Rube Marquard in 1912 and Roger Clemens in 2001 as the only major league pitchers to win 19 of their first 20 decisions in a season.
Andy Dirks had...
TIGERS LEAVE METS IN TATTERS AFTER 11-3 MAULING
The Mets got pounced on by the Tigers who beat them 11-3 this afternoon at Citi Field to complete a three game sweep and leave them licking their wounds.
Dillon Gee started for the Mets and wasn’t nearly as sharp as we’ve seen from him of late. The right-hander let up four runs and got knocked around for ten hits including home...
Detroit Tigers starting pitcher Max Scherzer outpitched New York Mets starter Matt Harvey in their All-Star rematch Saturday. Scherzer striked out 11 and hit an RBI double with one out in the second inning to lead
Let me get this straight ...
I paid $480 to attend a baseball game started by Matt Harvey and Max Scherzer end in a 3-0 score in favor of Scherzer's team, with Harvey's team getting three hits back in July, when I could have done the exact same thing for about $450 less yesterday?
For an extra $450, I got six less hits, 20 more degrees, the privilege of spending ten...