Found October 14, 2012 on Larry Brown Sports:

Via Larry Brown Sports:

The Yankees were hurt by a brutal call during the eighth inning of ALCS Game 2 against the Tigers on Sunday that cost them two runs in a 3-0 loss.

Tigers second baseman Omar Infante was advancing from first to second on a two-out single to right by Austin Jackson. The throw into second caught Infante too far off the base, and Robinson Cano tagged him out. Unfortunately, second base umpire Jeff Nelson called Infante safe, keeping the inning going for Detroit.

The next better was pinch-hitter Avisail Cabrera, who blooped a single to right to score Infante and make it 2-0. Yankees manager Joe Girardi went out to replace pitcher Boone Logan, and was ejected after arguing with Nelson about the awful call.

Miguel Cabrera followed with a single to score Jackson, giving the Tigers a 3-0 lead. They eventually got out of a bases loaded jam and escaped down just 3-0, but not before the blown call cost them two runs.

Girardi was ticked off about the call after the loss.

“It’s frustrating. I don’t have a problem with Jeff [Nelson's] effort. I don’t, because he hustled to get to the point. But in this day and age, when we have instant replay available to us, it’s got to change,” said Girardi.

“These guys are under a tremendous amount of pressure. It’s a tough call for him because the tag is underneath and it’s hard for him to see. It takes more time for me to argue and get upset than to get the call right. There’s just too much at stake.

“We play 235 days to get to this point. We had two calls go against us. We lost a game by one run [in Game 1], and I’m not saying if Robbie Cano is safe last night then it changes the game. The outcome still might be the same, but I’d like to take my chances.

“There’s a lot more pressure on a pitcher when it’s 1-0 in the eighth inning than when it’s 3-0. I’d like to take my chances,” he repeated.

Nelson admitted after the game that he got the call wrong.

“The hand did not get in before the tag, the call was incorrect,” he said, per MLB.

About the only comforting thing we can say to Yankees fans is that maybe this blown call was karma for the Nate McLouth foul ball in the ALDS.

 

Also from Larry Brown Sports:

Video: Minnesota RB hit so hard his helmet decal flies off

Kobe Bryant rips former teammate Smush Parker

Video: Missouri guard dunks over six people

18 Comments:
  • I understand that the umps get one look at it and it's live, but HOW THE HELL COULD YOU POSSIBLY CALL HIM SAFE!!!!!!???
  • Human element!! that is what makes the game so great. I understand he blew it and he blew it big time, but that isnt the first nor the last time that will happen.
    Havent the Yankess had a few favors gone their way over the years? should Baseball go back and take titles away from them and other teams?
  • It would take no time at all for an official in the booth to review the play and flash an 'O' on the scorebard for overturned or a 'U' for upheld just like an official scorer posts an 'H' for a hit or an 'E' for an error. There's too much money riding on these games not to get it right. The manager can be held to just 2 challenges per game, and if you use one and get it wrong you don't get the second one. So for all those who feel it would slow the game down they'd be wrong. The manager and ump spend more time arguing than it would take to just get it right. Besides, any ump with any integrity would want to be sure the right call is made and they would be the first to admit that they miss calls at times because they're only human. Instant replay has not hurt football and it would not hurt baseball. Hell the game already has it for homeruns and fair or foul down the lines, what's the big deal if it's used for close plays at the bag.
  • Yes it was a blown call and no it didn't cost the Yankees the game, Detroit had a 1-0 lead before this call. The Yankess blew the game themselves by not scoring a run. I knew someone in the media would bring up this blown call and act like it cost the Yankees the game.
  • Please leep in mind that per a statement made by Bud Selig when Armondo Gallaragha had a perfect game taken away from him on a not so bang bang play. The human element is part of baseball.
    While I agree reply should be used a little more but for what and how often? fact is NY did not score any runs so the 1-0 score going into the 8th was still enough to win. NY had to approach the bottom of the 8th and 9th the same as they did in the bottom of the 7th to try and score runs and they didn't score at all. So this missed call is not the reason they lost
  • I agree 100%, leave the human element in Baseball and yes the Yankees still would have lost 1-0. So stop the Crying and Play ball!!
  • This article is pretty funny, but very predictable. First off Detroit gets no respect at all, and the boring Yankee friendly broadcast from TBS was shameful at best. These guy's sounded like there dog was ran over by a car, it was pitiful! Having said that I did notice that the game 2 guy's (not sure if they were the same) did start to give Detroit a little credit.

    "Blown call costs Yankees in Game 2 of the ALCS" Really? I taught is was the fact that the Yankee's didn't score a run, (just like game one until our sorry closer came in). Eventually that was mentioned later in the article, but the headline was a joke! The play mentioned in this article was an obvious blown call. I'm assuming the ump was over the player and not at ground level (like the camera shot) and didn't see the tag. But the play it self was an over run of the base, it wasn't like it was a direct play, or part of a double play or something. The Tiger player already had second and wasn't paying attention and didn't get back in time, but the hit was a hit and he had already had second. This article is making it seem as if it was a play at the plate. I know if the teams were reversed in this scenario this writer would be making my argument.
  • I agree, the headline to this article is a joke and my respect for yardbarker has been diminished. This article also fails to make the Yankees accountable for needing only one out to end the inning but failed to do so. Give credit where credit is due. The Tigers have dominated the Yanks in every phase of the game not counting the Valverde meltdown in game one.
  • Uhhhhhh. The Tigers had already scored more runs than the Yank's would in that game before the missed call...... Ump at the plate made up for any missed calls on the field! (in the Yankees favor)
  • Thank you. Excellent point.
  • You can't say that play cost the Yankees the game. Yes, it was a bad call. But, no one can predict the future and say what would have happened if the runner had been called out. You can only assume. And what happens when you assume? We all know. It may have ended up 6 - 0 or something or worse.
  • hahahahahaahahahaha
  • It was a bad call. Cano's glove is clearly sliding down Infantes chest and belly before the runners right hand reaches the base. Jeff Nelson was possitioned correctly to make the right call. He just missed it.
    Benjamin Quiñones
    bengieq12@gmail.com
  • Whatever. It was a bang-bang play, and New York was losing anyway. If certain uber-millionaires on that team weren't in 0 for 28 slumps, being benched, or not flirting w/ cute hot-dog vendors, maybe they'd need more than a call to go their way to avoid being down 2-0. What was their excuse when Verlander kept them at two singles from Ichiro in Game 3, a blown strike call in the 4th?

    The umps did this rotten team a favor against Baltimore, now they want to pout and whine w/ the shoe on the other foot? And I love how every time somethihng goes against teams like New York, that's all the headlines show. "Yankees fail to get a hit or reach base against extremely lucky opponent pitcher, aided by blown call during first-pitch ceremonies."
THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
RELATED ARTICLES
GET WELL SOON

Jeter out for playoffs with fractured ankle

Derek Jeter suffered an ankle injury during the 12th inning against the Tigers and is done for the postseason for the Yankees.

Leyland: Closer by ear

Tigers manager Jim Leyland, at least for now, will handle save situations "by ear," according to a published report. MLB.com's Jason Beck says Leyland plans to "mix and match" the closer's role in the short run and won't use Jose Valverde in Game 2 of the American League Championship Series in New York on Sunday. Valverde blew a four-run lead in...

Brett Gardner Could Start Game 3

From Andrew Marchand:With the idea of shaking up the lineup going into Game 3 against the Detroit Tigers’ ace Justin Verlander, Yankees GM Brian Cashman said that Brett Gardner could be a starting outfielder. "He still might play a role in this thing," Cashman said on ESPN New York 98.7 FM’s "The Michael Kay Show." "You could very well see Gardner...

'Sensitive' Swisher says Yankees fans blaming him for Jeter's injury

Nick Swisher is a lot of different things to a lot of different people — overrated agitator to opponents or pie-throwing cheerleader to his teammates. But one thing the gregarious New York Yankees slugger never thought he would be is an outcast with his beloved Bleacher Creatures out in right field. Now it looks like the crowd favorite is hearing things from the fans he's...

Jeter breaks ankle, out for postseason

NEW YORK (AP) -- Delirious only minutes earlier, fans at Yankee Stadium sat stunned in utter disbelief while they watched Derek Jeter being helped off the field. Their worst fears were met, too. The durable captain broke his left ankle and is out for the rest of the postseason. Three innings after Raul Ibanez sent the 47,122 in Yankee Stadium into a frenzy with a tying two-run...

Yankees Injury News: Derek Jeter Shows No Sign of Injury

Derek Jeter had to be removed from Game Three of the New York Yankees division series victory over the Baltimore Orioles.  He left in the eighth inning after striking out and apparently re-aggravating the bone bruise that has been bothering him for weeks now.  However, he was able to play in Game Four, and last night he showed no ill-effects as the Yankees took down the Orioles...

Nick Swisher would like Yankees fans to spare him the poisonous barbs

Sad NY Yankees right fielder Nick Swisher, who apparently purchases eye black from BJs when he stops in for some chew, is sad. The league's second phoniest player, (So, he has that.) after... Full story at Bob's Blitz ~ http://www.bobsblitz.com

Yankees lose Jeter to broken ankle as Tigers pull out Game 1

NEW YORK -- Another logic-defying moment for Raul Ibanez and the New York Yankees eventually gave way to a 12-inning defeat to the Detroit Tigers. Even more shocking and devastating to the Yankees than their 6-4 defeat was the season-ending loss of Yankees captain Derek Jeter. One of the greatest postseason players in the game's history was carried off the field with a broken...

(Video) Ibanez carries Yanks to extra innings where Jeter is carried off with a fractured ankle; Swisher blows game

The ALCS started off commonly enough...Yankees SS Derek Jeter got his 200th career postseason hit in the 2nd. Your browser does not support iframes. Later, trailing 4-0 in the 9th inning,... Full story at Bob's Blitz ~ http://www.bobsblitz.com

Tigers 6, Yankees 4(12)

Delirious only minutes earlier, fans at Yankee Stadium sat stunned in utter disbelief while they watched Derek Jeter being helped off the field, his left leg dangling. Their worst fears were met, too. The durable captain broke his left ankle in the 12th inning of the AL championship series opener on Saturday night and is out for the rest of the postseason. ''It's kind...

Watching a Relievers Life Flash Before His Eyes

I guess the three run lead that Jose Valverde gave up against the A's in Game Four of the ALDS just wasn't good enough for him. Either that, or, Jim Leyland has given up on cigarettes giving him a heart attack. Of course, you would think that a four run lead is safe wouldn't you? Of course you would. Even with his struggles this year, Valverde is still a "proven...

Column: Day of reckoning had to come for A-Rod

(Eds: With AP Photos.) By TIM DAHLBERG AP Sports Columnist Joe Girardi should be manager of the year just for the guts it took to sit down his $275 million third baseman and help the New York Yankees advance a step closer to the World Series. Benching Alex Rodriguez might turn out to be the easiest move in a drama that is suitable for Broadway, but will play out instead in the Bronx...

Top 10 takeaways from Tigers - Yankees Game One

Seriously, Tiger Fan, Get On This 10) It's somewhat telling that many of the Yankee fans in my social media feeds posted after the Raul Ibanez tying home run in the ninth, but not after the final outcome9) If the Yankees' infield defense improves now that Derek Jeter is out for the year, it's all a testament to his leadership8) Somehow, it just seems really wrong that...

New York Yankees face Detroit Tigers in ALCS Game 2

Can Yankees stars make up for the absence of Jeter in ALCS Game 2?
MLB News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.