Ranking the Top 30 Shooting Guards by Total Value

This is the second of five installments of my position-by-position rankings, where I consider the four major factors that affect a player's total value: talent (statistical performance), affordability, age and potential. To see a more detailed explanation of my approach, give my point guard rankings a gander.

To summarize a player's stats, I'll use the NBA Efficiency statistic, which is defined as:

EFF = ((Points + Rebounds + Assists + Steals + Blocks) - ((Field Goals Att. - Field Goals Made) + (Free Throws Att. - Free Throws Made) + Turnovers))

Essentially, the order of this list depends on the answer to the question - would you trade Player X for Player Y, assuming the goal is to win a title in the next three seasons, while also building a strong franchise for years to come?

On with the rankings:

1. Kobe Bryant, Lakers

Age: 29

EPG: 26.8

Contract: three years, $69.1 M ($23.0 M per)

His salary is astronomical, which makes it difficult to rank him ahead of the almost-as-effective-for-half-the-price Manu Ginobili, but Kobe is probably the league's best one-on-one player and is the only guy who can match Manu's fire and competitiveness.

2. Manu Ginobili, Spurs

Age: 30

EPG: 19.9

Contract: two years, $20.6 M ($10.3 M per)

Ginobili should still be effective for the next three years, so his very reasonable contract makes him a reasonably close second to Kobe. His game has no holes and he is one of the best players in the league in the clutch.

3. Brandon Roy, Blazers

Age: 23

EPG: 19.4

Contract: three years, $12.2 M ($4.1 M per)

Who would you rather have - Roy for $4.1 million per season or Dwyane Wade for $15.8 million? I'd take Roy and spend the difference elsewhere. He's a terrific combo guard that has helped to bring the Blazers back to respectability.

(See the rest of the list after the jump.)
Vote this post up or down: 

21 Comments On: "Ranking the Top 30 Shooting Guards by Total Value"

 
Peitrus was looking pretty good at the end of the season. If he gets consistent burn there is some serious potential there.
He is just kind of a spaz though. He will make an amazing block or dunk or something & then set a screen out of bounds.
Can't decide how I feel about him.
Good list though.

Do you think he will come back to the warriors next season?

Maybe I missed something but you have 'Buke and Peitrus on this list but no Monta Ellis?? are you just making up numbers?

He had him on the pg list.

My mistake then must have missed him on that list

I think he does play the 2 more often i think. Hard to tell on the Warriors what position anyone is playing, though. lol.

i think i should proof read so i don't say i think a hundred times. lol.

Ellis will *probably* play PG if he signs with a new team or if Baron Davis doesn't re-sign. I think most teams see Monta as a scoring point guard.

I'm hoping neither of those come true ;-)

Again, proud to be a Clippers fan..........

I take more issue with who he actually classifies as a shooting guard than the actual ranking of the players.

I get my stats (and positions) from DougStats.com. That said, there is room for improvement with how players are classified. Who would you move out of SG? I'll definitely move Kyle Lowry to PG next time I do these lists.

that list is crap, t-mac and ray allen are WAY WAY WAY too low

You understand that age and salary are a part of these rankings, right?

so you would rather see mike miller or stephen jackson on your team than tracy mcgrady for less money?

I think McGrady is probaly a solid three man...

B-Roooooooooooooooooooooy

Kevin Martin at number 5!!

someone finally got it right

He's a great value at that salary level.

wow the money these guys make...
All though Tony Parker is old for his salary he is decent and I would put him much higher

I like him, but there's not much upside there or longevity left, so his value isn't too high.

Your comment:



Featured Stories Today
 
CBS Saturday Night Fights - This weekend in Stockton
Should be some great fighting this weekend. One of my guys Mike Cook the heavyweight champ from...
8 Things Brett Favre Should Be Doing
Instead of playing for a team that isn't named the Packers, here are ten things that Brett Favre...
 
PSP TO ADD GPS FOR NEW BREED OF GAMES
Navigation, maps and GPS-supporting games are coming soon to a PSP near you. Yesterday's revelation ...
Fantasy Football RB Preview
Running back has been labeled the most important position in the history of fantasy football, and...
Baron Davis still has love for the Bay
Hollywood Boom Dizzle Davis yesterday spent about 90 minutes in Oakland speaking with kids from the ...
Most Comments Today
Most Comments This Week


Top 7 Related Stories
Most Popular Related Topics
Recent NBA Fans
Most Popular NBA Articles
More from the Blogosphere

MLB
Wednesday Jul 23 (EST)    See all MLB Scores >>
  • 5
    9
    San Diego
    Cincinnati
    Final
    Box Score
  • 3
    4
    Oakland
    Tampa Bay
    Final
    Box Score
  • 1
    5
    Minnesota
    New York
    Final
    Box Score
  • 8
    7
    Pittsburgh
    Houston
    Final
    Box Score
  • 8
    10
    Texas
    Chicago
    Final
    Box Score
  • 7
    1
    Detroit
    Kansas City
    Final
    Box Score
  • 3
    5
    Los Angeles
    Colorado
    Final
    Box Score
  • 11
    14
    Cleveland
    Los Angeles
    Final
    Box Score
  • 6
    3
    Boston
    Seattle
    Final
    Box Score
  • 2
    1
    Toronto
    Baltimore
  • 9
    4
    Atlanta
    Florida
    Final
    Box Score
  • 3
    6
    Philadelphia
    New York
    Final
    Box Score
  • 3
    0
    Milwaukee
    St. Louis
    Final
    Box Score
  • 10
    6
    Chicago
    Arizona
    Final
    Box Score
  • 4
    6
    Washington
    San Francisco
    Final
    Box Score
  •  
     
    © Copyright 2008 Yardbarker, Inc. All Rights Reserved