Add Comment

• eagles4life05 said April 04, 2009

  McNabb #1. we could have easliy ended up with Couch, Smith, Culpperper(although that wouldn't be THAT bad), and McNown. the rest is a really good list Potter

  Reply

  
• GARCIA20 said April 04, 2009

  I think you meant the Reggie Bush hit but I think DJackson will be higher because everyone said he was way to small and would never make it in the NFL and plus he's only gonna get better!

  Reply

  
  • HarryPotter replied April 04, 2009

    i agree about desean, and yeah i meant bush
• Rhino56 said April 04, 2009

  Another bad list. Lito sheppard, shawn andrews Michael Lewis Corey Simon and Derrick Burgess all made the probowl before and none of them made the top ten list. What about the Raheem Brock in the 7th round that Doesn't make the list.

  Reply

  
  • HarryPotter replied April 04, 2009

    YOU SUCK! i tried to not use too many high draft picks, michael lewis and corey simon didnt last here too long, burgess was a good pick but only had one good year with us, and raheem brock didnt play a down for us
    • Rhino56 replied April 04, 2009

      Corey Simon was here 5 years. Michael lewis was here 5 years you got guys on your list who have been here one season.
      • HarryPotter replied April 04, 2009

        it ended ugly, and they were early picks, hard to call them "successes"
        
• HakeemNicks said April 04, 2009

  Why is McNabb not #1? Let us not kid ourself, it is too early to start coining DeSean the next Steve Smith. Give him some time

  Reply

  
  • HarryPotter replied April 04, 2009

    because he was the #2 pick overall, westbrook was a third round pick and has been the cornerstone of our offense the last few years
• apollokid said April 04, 2009

  Shawn Andrews is top 3

  Reply

  
  • HarryPotter replied April 04, 2009

    i love shawn, but the fact they traded a first and 2nd to trade up for him makes him somebody that better be good, not a great pick
• Bigwhit said April 04, 2009

  Potter, it hurts me to say this but, good list.

  Reply

  
  • Rhino56 replied April 04, 2009

    Why are you now sucking up to potter. Everybody on his list was on the team last season. He had some obvious omissions on both his list that he either forgot about or didn't know, and instead of admitting it he tries to justify it. He says probowlers aren't sucesses to support his argument that's ludicris.
    • HarryPotter replied April 04, 2009

      michael lewis had one good year and then they benched him, corey simon was overrated too, stfu
      • Rhino56 replied April 04, 2009

        Michael lewis was good in 03, 04,05 young boy. you must have been watching Blue's clues. Your knowledge falls short of your opinion. Corey Simon had 9.5 sacks as a rookie was a pro bowler in 03.
• Rhino56 said April 04, 2009

  They were Early picks? Donovan was the second pick in the whole draft...

  Reply

  
  • HarryPotter replied April 04, 2009

    i know, but they could have made the mistake of taking akili smith, ricky williams, or cade mcnown, there is something to be said for making the right call when all of philly is calling you out on it
• MidniteGreen said April 05, 2009

  Good list Potter. I understand the fact that you were talking about draft picks according to VALUE. Also, McNabb was the best choice of all the QBs that went that year, so that would be considered great VALUE.

  Reply

  
• khollen said April 06, 2009

  mcnabb should be number 1 and shawn andrews should be on it.

  Reply

  
• HarryPotter said April 06, 2009

  like i said, i do like the andrews pick, but to trade up for him makes it something they better get right

  Reply

  
• crazyphillyfan said April 08, 2009

  how about shawn andrews?

  Reply