Add Comment

• TheOneNOnly said April 03, 2009

  I like the whole list except the ten spot. I could name a load of WRs better than Holmes. Wes Welker, Quan, Dwayne Bowe, Antonio Bryant, Hines Ward, thats just a few.

  Reply

  
  • HarryPotter replied April 03, 2009

    i want to see bryant be more consistant, im still not convinced about bowe yet, still dont love quan, AND I HATE WELKER he feeds off of the success of randy moss and would not be good in any other system, i would not put him in my top 20 receivers
    • TheOneNOnly replied April 03, 2009

      I didn't say that they should be in the top 20, which some of them should, but they are definitely better than Holmes.
      • HarryPotter replied April 03, 2009

        i think holmes is a beast, next year will be a breakout year after that superbowl, ill name 15 more guys not on my list better than welker, just for kicks, edwards, t.o., boldin, burress, bowe, bryant, ward, vincent and desean jackson., eddie royal, berrian, coles, holt, colston, lee evans
      • TheOneNOnly replied April 03, 2009

        Yes, but you don't have Holmes better than Welker.
      • HarryPotter replied April 03, 2009

        yeah i do, its my list + those 15
      • TheOneNOnly replied April 03, 2009

        Oh. Quick response too.
      • HarryPotter replied April 03, 2009

        yeah im clutch lol
• meatgoat said April 03, 2009

  Andre's the sh*t! No Boldin? I'd tell ya Reggie Wayne's a pretty boring pick for this list but I usually say crap like that then go look at the stats and have to come back and apologize to ya. And you know I want to see T.O. up there,too.

  Reply

  
  • meatgoat replied April 03, 2009

    I didn't see the "honorable mentions". Wow, you can disregard everything I've said. Ehhh....it's for the best anyway.
• eagles4ever05 said April 03, 2009

  I like it except for Holmes

  Reply

  
  • HarryPotter replied April 03, 2009

    its an outside pick, but i like his potential and he dominated in the superbowl
    • eagle77 replied April 03, 2009

      for once i agree with you.nice list.
      • HarryPotter replied April 03, 2009

        thanks man
    • eagles4ever05 replied April 04, 2009

      yes he did dominate but I am still not sold untill Ward goes away
• eagles4life05 said April 03, 2009

  9 and 10 i don't really agree with and white should be around 10. also Fitz is #1 but the rest is pretty good

  Reply

  
• Zukny1 said April 04, 2009

  bump santonio holmes and reggie wayne and you start to have a list.

  Reply

  
• mjmaus said April 04, 2009

  pretty solid list

  Reply

  
• I_bleed_green said April 04, 2009

  One game does not catapult Holmes to the top ten receivers in the entire NFL. He may not even be top 20 to be honest with you. Desean Jackson had 7 more catches during the season and almost 100 more yards receiving than Holmes did last year.....as a rookie. You're telling me Holmes is ahead of those 4 on your honorable mention? Come on man, you're gonna lose credibility with stuff like that.

  Reply

  
  • HarryPotter replied April 04, 2009

    you may be right, im going out on a limb a little, but i think hes going to be really good next year
• I_bleed_green said April 04, 2009

  So is Desean. and Desean had better numbers last year....but I don't think Desean is near the top 10 either...i just think he's above Holmes.

  Reply

  
• BenPhranklin said April 04, 2009

  Boldin may be mentionable here.... he scores TDs
  TO still has breath in his lungs

  Reply

  
• hockeychick23 said April 04, 2009

  holmes is my hero.

  Reply

  
• khollen said April 04, 2009

  i agree except holmes hasn`t proven enough in regular season to be ahead of LEE EVANS. every one who has made one of these lists hasn`t put him on it why?last year 63catches 1017 yds 3td`s. last 6 years 296 catches 4744 yards,32 td`s.

  Reply

  
• DeWare said April 04, 2009

  yeah solid list, but like everyone else I disagree about Holmes. Would probably put Boldin there. Next 5 maybe...Lee Evans, Colston, TO, Welker, and then Holmes.

  Reply

  
• 1way2play said April 04, 2009

  yeah pretty good list I won''t nit pick but I still like T.Holt, and T.O. in this list

  Reply

  
• I_bleed_green said April 04, 2009

  how can Holmes even be in the top 15 if he had lower numbers than Desean Jackson did? because he made a big catch in the super bowl?

  Reply

  
  • HarryPotter replied April 04, 2009

    ok i get it
• apollokid said April 04, 2009

  I gotta say man, the list is fairly solid. Although it should be a crime that you don't have Boldin on that list. Hes better than half the WR's on there, I mean cmon, SANTONIO HOLMES is on the list and ANQUAN BOLDIN ISNT? Thats crazyness man. And also, best pure WR in the game is Calvin Johnson. He may be top 3 in NFL history by the time hes done.

  Reply

  
• mjmaus said April 04, 2009

  the Eagles should get half off for Boldin since he's broken

  Reply

  
• tugboatjon said April 05, 2009

  love the list especially since andre johnsons at the top its a shame its took this long for ppl to recognize him for his talents

  Reply

  
  • HarryPotter replied April 05, 2009

    i agree, ive been saying how good he is for years, but espn was too busy sucking off randy moss on the raiders to realize he was a player
• tugboatjon said April 05, 2009

  and whats with the TO ppl the guys a has been smack talker with nothin to back it up lol oh and did i mention cry baby lmao

  Reply

  
• tugboatjon said April 05, 2009

  shaubs good to an extent but ill always wonder wut it would be like to have a QB that could really get the ball to andre

  Reply

  
  • HarryPotter replied April 05, 2009

    i know, i feel the same way about calvin johnson, but he has more time than andre does, but if these guys could get a qb they could be breaking records, just see moss's one year with brady
• tugboatjon said April 05, 2009

  2 shay do ya think the texans got somethin better for andre with orlovsky
  
  

  Reply

  
  • HarryPotter replied April 05, 2009

    no, schaub is better than orlovsky, schaub isnt bad, hes just a middle of the pack starter
• tugboatjon said April 06, 2009

  yeah i believe schaub will keep the spot as long as he can stay healthy just thank god rosenfels is out of the picture dependable at times but a real kick in the crotch lol

  Reply

  
  • HarryPotter replied April 06, 2009

    sorry to bring this up but i was watching the rerun of the colts texans game that he blew last year, man was that bad
• tugboatjon said April 06, 2009

  lmao its a game to be remembered thats for sure

  Reply

  
• UNC23Tarheels said April 06, 2009

  Harry Potter loved the List with the exception of One itsy bitsy little thing,Why Roddy White gotta be at #7 for?? Gotta stick up for my Falcons,LOL still a good list though..

  Reply

  
  • HarryPotter replied April 06, 2009

    hes definately climbing it, but i like the 6 above him better
• Mega2184 said April 06, 2009

  how about T.J? he was 6th in receiving stats last year.

  Reply