Tournament Style Vote Off ( Day 4 ) -- NFL QB's -- Up now -- K. Warner vs. J. Kitna -- Pick the Winner

This is a simple tournament style vote off. What you do here is vote for the best QB of the pair that is up at that time. This is a tournament so vote for the top paring first the next match up will begin after 15 total votes, the first to 8 votes, or the leader at the 24th hour, whichever comes first.

Then move to the next pairing on the list and so on till the list is complete and then we start round two which I will post with the new match ups. I will Post the new match ups every day till we crown the CHAMPION.

Lets be friendly and honest here is the match up. The NAMES in CAPS are the winners of that match up move on to the next round. When you see a pairing with a CAPS winner move down to where there are two QB's in lower case letters and that is the one we will be voting on at that time. When the next round comes out it will be posted the same as this one but with round 2, then 3, then 4 and so on till we have our two SUPER BOWL QB's. Only vote for the one in session.

Let's keep it friendly, and tell your friends we are here and lets make this fun for everyone.

Now in session is: K. Warner vs. J. Kitna ---

J.CAMPBELL defeats T.Jackson --- (11-2) --- J. CAMPBELL WINS

T.ROMO defeats M.Hasselback --- (8 - 6) --- T. ROMO WINS

P.MANNING defeats T.Brady --- (9 - 7) --- P. MANNING WINS

B. FARVE defeats A. Rodgers --- (7 - 6) --- B. FARVE WINS

E.MANNING defeats P.Rivers --- (9 - 7) --- E.MANNING WINS

D.MCNABB defeats C.Palmer --- (8 - 2) --- D. MCNABB WINS

D. ANDERSON defeats V.Young ---(12 - 4)---D. ANDERSON WINS

B.ROTHLESBUGER defeats T.Edwards --- (8 - 0) --- B. ROTHLESBUGER WINS

J. GARCIA defeats A.Rodgers --- (8 - 7) --- J. GARCIA WINS

K. Warner vs. J. Kitna --- IS NOW IN SESSION

R. Grossman vs. D. Garrard

J. Cutler vs. J. Delhomme

D. Brees vs. M. Bulger

J. Russell vs. M. Schuab

A. Smith vs B. Cryole

80 Comments On: "Tournament Style Vote Off ( Day 4 ) -- NFL QB's -- Up now -- K. Warner vs. J. Kitna -- Pick the Winner"

 
Now in session is: B.Rothlesburger vs. Trent Edwards ---

J.CAMPBELL defeats T.Jackson --- (11-2) --- J. CAMPBELL WINS

T.ROMO defeats M.Hasselback --- (8 - 6) --- T. ROMO WINS

P.MANNING defeats T.Brady --- (9 - 7) --- P. MANNING WINS

B. FARVE defeats A. Rodgers --- (7 - 6) --- B. FARVE WINS

E.MANNING defeats P.Rivers --- (9 - 7) --- E.MANNING WINS

D.MCNABB defeats C.Palmer --- (8 - 2) --- D. MCNABB WINS

D. ANDERSON defeats V.Young --- ( 12 - 4) --- D. ANDERSON WINS

B.Rothlesburger vs. Trent Edwards --- NOW IN SESSION

The score carried over from Day 3's results are as follows:

My vote was for Big Ben and LiL was also for Big Ben.

These were carried over from day 3.

The current score is:

B.Rothlesburger over Trent Edwards --- 2 - 0

If you guys are up for a laugh and / or like Paris Hilton you have to see her PRESIDENTIAL VIDEO on both
McCann and Obama. The link is below:

http://www.yardbarker.com/backyard/articles/Breaking_News_Paris_Hilton_on_both_McCain_Obama_YO_MAMA/302011

Make sure you stop by and join the FUNNY SPORTS PICTURES OF THE DAY and add your caption to them.
they are at:

http://www.yardbarker.com/backyard/articles/Sports_Pictures_of_the_DAY_for_8708_You_type_in_the_Caption_for_the_pictures/302377#add_comment

Big Ben

BB it is

I wish I didn't have to pick him, but I go with Big Ben

I take it your not a Pitt fan?

I got you for BB

I just think Ben's overrated

I know a lot of people feel that way about him since his 1st year. I still wonder if that bike accident in some small way doesn't bother him. You know, like when Kerry Collins got popped in the mouth and busted his jaw, he was never the same QB after that hit. I know one was game related and one wasn't, but i wonder if there may be some lingering injury he doesn't admit to.

Worthlessburger

You think that nickname would stick for him, LOL

Will anybody vote for Edwards? haha

Big Ben!

I don't know, maybe 1, cause they'll feel bad, lol

I got you down for BB.

The current score is a SHUTOUT so far with:

B.Rothlesburger over Trent Edwards --- 4 - 0

big ben al day he got a ring!!! and edwards has not done nething!

PhillyMP BB it is

Make sure you stop by the FUNNY SPORTS PICTURES OF THE DAY and make up your own caption to them.
they are at:

http://www.yardbarker.com/backyard/articles/Sports_Pictures_of_the_DAY_for_8708_You_typ

The current score is a SHUTOUT so far with:

B.Rothlesburger over Trent Edwards --- 5 - 0

Big Ben.

Ok NN, I have you down for BB, thanks for stopping in

The current score is a SHUTOUT so far with:

B.Rothlesburger over Trent Edwards --- 6 - 0

I have to go with Big Ben but I think Edwards will be a very good quarterback in a couple years.

ok fbkid, BB it is, glad to see you back with us.

Big Ben easy on this one..

Thanks REDS, BB it is,

IT OFFICAL THIS SESSION IS OVER AND WE HAVE OUR FIRST SHUTOUT:

FINAL SCORE IS:

B.ROTHIESBUGER defeats Trent Edwards --- 8 - 0

B.ROTHIESBUGER WINS 8 - 0

NEXT SESSION IS:

J.Garcia vs. A.Rodgers

My vote is:

A. Rodgers

The current score is:

A. Rodgers over J. Garcia 1 - 0

Rodgers. Garcia has been productive but his career is coming to an end while Rodgers is now about to get his time to shine.

FBK...Rodgers it is

Why is Rodgers on the list twice? And being as Favre was raded shouldnt that give Rodgers an dautomatic vicory over brett

That aside my vote is Rodgers

Good question WJB, we figured if brett was going to be run out of town we would put them together to see how you guys felt. We felt all along that Brett was going to the NYJ, hence you don't see any NYJ QB's on this list.

We thought that if we put Brett up against any NYJ QB that Brett would win hands down. So since we thought that putting Favre on here twice would look like a setup for Brett winning this whole thing, so we put Rodgers up twice instead and also up against the two 38 year old veterans to see how the Yard truly feels about this kid.

I hope this answered your question.

J. Garcia... Garcia is a proven pro bowl qb.. He has a few pro bowl apperance.. and dates super models...
Where Arron rogers... has hardly played and is injury proned.

Ok REDS, Garcia it is

Question for you though, how can you call someone injury prone when he's never started and played a NFL game? What are you basing your comment on?

Gimme rodgers

JWW, AR it is.

The current score is:

A. Rodgers over J. Garcia --- 4 - 1

Garcia. Like Reds1214 said-he is proven.

Hello Vikefan, Garcia it is.

gotta go with garcia!!! he's fighter and a winner!!! he can take the crowd in philly booing him and not cry about it!!! his girlfriend is smokin' hot too!!!! he also pissess off t.o. !!!!!!!!!

Garcia is a scraper, he's got a calf injury now, but should be ok in 3-4 weeks b4 he's 100%

A. Rodgers. He's got better WRs than Garcia.

I like his WR's better too

your figure Dean he has been whhat hurt I think thwice out of 3 seasons... He has hardly played and he has been hurt I believe twice....

Didn't know, to be honest he wasn't high on my list of QB to look at, if like Sorgie or how ever you spell his name, the backup for P. Manning, I just never study those type of guys 'cause of who they play behind and that there's really no competing for a starting spot and most back ups worth a salt are on other teams, you know what I'm trying to say here?

Garcia might be the most accurate QB in the NFL. I'll go with him.