Found July 10, 2013 on Buddy Nixon:
Welcome to DJ’s Chalk Talk: Off-season Week 3! This week we look at why EJ Manuel was the better draft choice than Geno Smith. Enjoy! Since January we all heard that this year’s draft was thin in first round quarterback talent to say the least. But that did not shy away our Buffalo Bills. After trading back from the eighth slot with the Rams, Buffalo acquired the 16th selection and an additional second and seventh round pick. This was the Buffalo front office’s dream scenario. To obtain extra picks and still draft the guy they wanted all along later in the first round; how could this have gone any better? As we all know, with the 16th selection in the 2013 NFL Draft the Buffalo Bills selected Florida State quarterback EJ Manuel. The new face of the franchise. When Buffalo drafted Manuel, this shocked many; including ESPN NFL Draft analyst Todd McShay. McShay called the move a “big mistake for the organization.” The draft analyst felt that Manuel has “slow eyes” and his accuracy is “below average to marginal.” These are strong criticisms  towards one of the more successful quarterbacks in this year’s draft class. When the Bills were on the clock at 16, both Manuel and former West Virginia Mountaineer Geno Smith, who most people felt was the top quarterback in the draft class, were both on the board. Buffalo passed on Smith, who ended up falling to the Jets in the second round (I wish you the best of luck) essentially linking the two quarterbacks’ legacies forever. But here’s why I feel that EJ Manuel is the superior pick to Geno Smith: EJ Manuel has outstanding leadership skills. Every team needs a good leader, and the Bills found their guy in Manuel. I’m not sure if you ever watched the video clip of Manuel’s pre-game speech before Florida State’s Orange Bowl game against Northern Illinois (the video was also posted June 10 on the Bill’s “Inside the Bills” blog.) For those of you who have not seen the video yet, I suggest you watch it. (Here’s the link: http://blogs.buffalobills.com/2013/06/10/example-of-ejs-vocal-leadership/.) This is just a glimpse of we have to look forward to when EJ Manuel takes over as quarterback in the near future. EJ Manuel also had the highest ceiling as a quarterback in the draft. Manuel is a mobile quarterback with a big arm. What’s not to like? The former Seminole isn’t quite polished yet. We know early in the off-season that Manuel worked tirelessly with offensive coordinator Nathaniel Hackett to help his footwork, which will improve EJ’s “accuracy problem.” Poor footwork can also result into holding on to the ball too long, which can lead to interceptions and sacks; something none of us want. If Manuel can get his feet underneath him and get his timing down, he will have a bright career with this team. Towards the end of the pre-draft process, Geno Smith started receiving criticism from some scouts and analysts. People started comparing him to Panthers quarterback Cam Newton, because Newton has been seen on the sidelines pouting  during his NFL career and well… We all know about his press conferences. As far as attitudes go on the sidelines, it’s fair to compare Smith to Newton. When West Virginia struggled against Syracuse in the Pinstripe Bowl this season, Smith was shown on TV sulking on the sideline. As a player this is not something you want to see your quarterback doing. This brings the morale down. I’ve never heard any criticism about EJ Manuel’s attitude on the field, sidelines, locker room, or off the field. I’ve seen the exact opposite. There were reports during the off-season activities that Manuel and roommate Marques Goodwin spend some of their free time at home on their iPads studying the playbook. That’s something you love to see! All you can do is stay tuned to see how the saga ends. The post The Draft: EJ Manuel v. Geno Smith appeared first on Buddy Nixon.
THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
RELATED ARTICLES

NT Marcell Dareus struggling to earn starting job

It was one year ago that Buffalo Bills defensive lineman Marcell Dareus was a man ready to be a star. Instead, the No. 3 overall pick in the 2011 draft hasn’t made the jump and now is struggling to earn a starting job on the team’s defensive line. Dareus' younger brother was tragically murdered a week before the start of the NFL season, and he was unable to focus on football...

Stevie Johnson says the Bills have the best receiving core

Wide receiver Stevie Johnson tweeted that the Buffalo Bills have the best receiving core in the NFL. Best WR Core in The @NFL Is coming from The @BuffaloBills #Recharged pic.twitter.com/HUxoZh5fRX — STVN (@StevieJohnson13) July 11, 2013 I appreciate Stevie’s confidence and I do believe the Bills group of receivers really improves this season, but they’re not the best.   Need...

Gragg, Manuel using extra time to get in sync

BY DAN BEGNOCHEWhile the Buffalo Bills' defense has been plugging along this offseason without its key playmaker Jairus Byrd, the offensive unit has had ample time together to get acclimated.Except for the crux of the tight end crew, that is.Despite his remarkably fast recovery, first-string tight end Scott Chandler has still missed a legitimate amount of time with his two new...

Making A Case For And Against A Bills Playoff Run

There has been extreme optimism and positive energy among Buffalo Bills fans ever since the franchise revamped the front office and coaching staff. An influx of multiple new players brings a bright outlook going into the 2013 season for many. But do the Bills have a legitimate chance at making a playoff run? Here at BuddyNixon, I decided to make cases both for and against the team...

One Fan’s Journey Through Buffalo Bills History

Queen City Sports is proud to announce that Buffalo Bills writer Carl Pfeiffer has released his third book entitled Someday! In Someday! Pfeiffer takes you on a twisted and emotional, journey through Bills history. For countless people who call Buffalo and Western New York home, the Bills are more than a football team; they are a member of the family. A family member who sometimes...

Report: Bills, Jairus Byrd don’t have any contract talks scheduled

According to WGR 550 in Buffalo, there haven’t been any contract talks scheduled between the Bills and safety Jairus Byrd. According to Tim Graham of The Buffalo News, a source tells him that there have been no contract talks scheduled between the Bills and his agent Eugene Parker, and that there are no plans to have those contract talks any time soon. I get the feeling the Bills...

Return to Relevance – Defensive Backs

Previous Return to Relevance Posts Offensive Line Running Backs If you are a first time reader of the Return to Relevance series, I’ll bring you up to speed faster than Willis McGahee running out of a Dave and Buster’s; relevancy in the NFL is defined as postseason play. By that logic, the Buffalo Bills have not fielded a relevant squad since 1999. The purpose of this column...

Catching Up With Former Buffalo Bills Safety Mark Kelso

Mark Kelso played his entire eight year NFL career with the Buffalo Bills. From 1986-1993 Kelso played 99 games with the Bills, starting 95 of the games. Kelso ended his career with 30 interceptions, eight fumble recoveries and two defensive touchdowns. Currently, Kelso is an Advancement Director at St. Mary’s High School and color analyst for the Buffalo Bills on WGR 550. Mark...

Why C.J. Spiller Should Be Avoided In 1st Round of Fantasy Drafts

Living in Jacksonville, Florida, I knew about C.J. Spiller in high school. I knew about him long before his days at Clemson, I knew about the size, the speed, the agility and the Heisman aspirations in college before he made the move to the pros.And when Buffalo pulled the trigger in the 2010 Draft and his name was called with the ninth pick, one ahead of my Jacksonville Jaguars...

Report: Geno Smith won’t attend Mark Sanchez’s “Jets West” camp

According to Seth Walder of the New York Daily News, Jets rookie quarterback Geno Smith is in Florida and will not attend Mark Sanchez’s “Jets West” camp. Geno Smith is working out in Florida and will not be attending Jets West, which began in southern California Thursday, according to a source. Smith’s presence at Mark Sanchez’s annual Jets West was a point of much speculation...

Ge-No Show: Smith not at Sanchez's 'Jets West'

BY NICK ST. DENISThere's a slight chance Mark Sanchez won't be the New York Jets' starting quarterback at the beginning of the season, and there's a slightly better chance he won't be at the end.But until then, he's acting the part. Sanchez's annual pre-preseason camp in California, which is open to Jets skill position players, kicked off this week.And...

Ge-No Show: Smith not at Sanchez's 'Jets West

As Mark Sanchez and Geno Smith prepare to battle it out for the Jets starting quarterback job, the veteran headed for the California, while the rookie decided to train in Florida. Find out how the annual Jets West camp is unfolding and how Smith's absence could impact Gang Green's chemistry this upcoming season.

Deserving of a shower in the swamps of Jersey, New York Jets quarterback Mark Sanchez says he’s ‘going to win’ against Geno Smith

Saying he’s “going to win” the New York Jets quarterback competition, Mark Sanchez expects to start under center against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers on September 8. A bush league chucker, Sanchez is in the midst of battling rookie passer Geno Smith for the job. “When it’s a straight-up competition for the job, let’s roll,” said Sanchez, 26, who deserves praise for penetrating...

Why Greg McElroy Should Not Be Overlooked in Jets' QB Battle

Mark Sanchez and Geno Smith are set to be in a heated QB battle when the preseason picks up.Sanchez, the incumbent, seems like the favorite to keep his job as starting quarterback for the New York Jets.But, there is another quarterback who the New York Jets' staff has overlooked. That man, is Greg McElroy. McElroy was drafted by the Jets in the 7th round of the 2011 Draft out...
NFL News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.