Found December 25, 2008 on Goon's World: Yardbarker Blogger Network
The NHL has created an out of control battle between fans of the Pittsburgh Penguins and Montreal Canadiens.

The league?s All Star voting process has been tainted by fans and blog sites alike, to stuff the ballot box by any means necessary.

In a Nov. 11 home game against the Ottawa Senators, it was reported that the Canadiens heavily promoted all star voting during the game. One day ahead of the official start of voting.

When early results were tabulated, it was unusual to see all six Eastern Conference starters from the Canadiens

After these results, rumours surfaced that there was ballet box stuffing going on in Montreal.

Various news agencies investigated why the totals were so disparagingly high for Canadiens? players while other notable stars such as Sidney Crosby, Evgeny Malkin and Alexander Ovechkin were far off in the distance.

So, why were the votes so highly in favour of Les Glorieux?

Along with legitimate votes, a user on a Canadiens fans site urged people to vote using an automated program called Greasemonkey (a Firefox extension that allows the user to take control of a specific website browser). The program allows users to vote over and over again and this would explain why all six starters, at one point, were all Habs.

According to NHL voting rules, fans are allowed to vote, via internet and text messaging, as many times as they like but are prohibited from using automated voting machines.

?Use of automatic voting methods is prohibited,? says the NHL website. ?The NHL will have in place monitoring procedures designed to prevent individuals from unfairly influencing the outcome of the voting by generating significant blocks of votes using technical enhancements.?

The NHL moved quickly on this and eliminated thousands of votes from Canadiens? players, including 20,000 from Alexei Kovalev alone. The NHL took preventative measures and now the league claims that every real time vote you see has been cast by a real person.

Against the overwhelming number of votes, illegal or otherwise, going Montreal?s way, a popular Penguins blog site decided to do something about it.

On Dec. 10 fans were encouraged to vote and get Crosby and Malkin ahead of Kovalev and Canadiens captain Saku Koivu.

Whether this message had any effect on the vote standings is impossible to say but as of Dec. 25, Crosby and Malkin lead the Eastern Conference in voting, ahead of Kovalev and Koivu.

So far no rumuors of automated programs have surfaced from Pittsburgh.

Currently, Kovalev is third in voting; approximately 480,000 votes ahead of sixth-place Ovechkin, which brings another interesting facet to this debate.

The Penguins have entered into a relationship with the Washington Capitals to further drive this voting war.

The collective effort is called the ?Unholy Alliance? and they have made it clear what their intentions are.

?This one time only would bring Pens/Caps fans together to try and stun the world and get A.O. (Alexander Ovechkin) into the top three of the All Star voting,? said the Pens blog site.

?Yes, A.O. is a jackoff, but a Sid-Malkin-A.O. line in the All Star game would be a lot of fun on almost every level. Not to mention it would completely humiliate Habs fans.?

This isn?t the first time that ballot stuffing and agenda driven results have been effective.

Two years ago, 22-year-old Steve Schmid thought it would be a great idea to vote a hard-working, journeyman into the all star game. He chose Vancouver Canucks? defenceman Rory Fitzpatrick. The ?Vote for Rory? phenomenon was born.

Media outlets picked up on this and a few weeks later Canucks? players were wearing ?Vote for Rory? T-shirts. Rory?s supporters started promoting him with video montages on You Tube and soon after he was written about in publications like Sports Illustrated and the New York Times.

At that time, Fitzpatrick had nine NHL goals in his career. He had spent a month on the sidelines with a broken ankle and his name was nowhere to be found on any official NHL ballots.

On the strength of Schmid?s campaign, Fitzpatrick rose through the ranks to third in the Western Conference. He finished behind Nicklas Lidstrom and Scott Neidermayer.

To his credit Fitzpatrick backed out and never played in the 2007 All Star game in Dallas, Texas.

Any way you look at it the NHL has created a fair amount of publicity for itself. Although it?s hard to say if they wanted it through illegal voting. Judging by the desperate straits the league is in, they may take publicity any way they can get it.

Add Comment

Comments (15)
  • all that i have to say about this is wow. The penguins stuffing of the balot is 1. completely fair and 2. completely justified. Are you going to say that Sidney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin, and Alexander Ovechkin are not worthy of being all star game starters? Alex Kovalev, Saku Koivu, and Alex Tanguay are not worthy of being in the game which is why their balot stuffing is unjustified. What The Pensblog wanted to do was to get the best players in the eastern conference voted in. As you can see in the results, its not like they were trying to get an unworthy third forward in for the penguins, but they were trying to get the best forward outside of pittsburgh in. They didnt encourage voting of Ryan Whitney, Sergei Gonchar, and Marc-Andre Fluery either. Who cares how many votes crosby and malkin get, as long as they are in the game because they deserve to be in the game.
  • use to love hockey now its watered down and a joke
  • carey price;mike komaserik;saku koivu over tim thomas;phil kessel;and savard give me a break talk about favoring hab players just because it's montreal's 100th anniversary compare goaltender stats compare goals for who's ahead of who I would like the eastern conference to put their best on the ice and that's not with the first three they should just have their one canadiens player from their team no other habs player deserves to play in the allstar game not this year anyway
  • Goon48
    I think that the League should limit fans votes to one fan vote per day.
  • Go HABS go!!! 100th year in existence and see all the controversy created by the jealousy??? That's what happens when you win all those Stanley Cups!!!
  • the pens blog he speaks of is thepensblog.com its awesome, the pens fans did nothin to taint the voting, we did not use voting machines, we did what fans are supposed to do, we voted. Who can argue that Sid and Malkin dont belong as starters they are 1 and 2 in the scoring, AO should be their too. Im sorry if this upsets the Habs fans but that is the truth.
  • GO BACK TO THE OLD WAY OF CHOOSING, BY STATS AND PERFORMANCE. LET THE SPORTS WRITERS AND COACHES DECIDE. WHEN EVERYBODY GETS INTO IT, THIS PROBLEM WILL HAPPEN EVERY YEAR. EVEN AS A HAB FAN I WOULDNT WANT TO SEE ANY UNDESERVING CANADIENS OUT THERE. IT IS OUR 100TH ANIVERSARY SO IM SURE THERE WILL BE LOTS OF TRADITION RE-VISITED THROUGHOUT THE ALL STAR WEEKEND. ON THE ICE HOWEVER LETS HAVE THE BEST OF THE BEST OUT THERE.
    THE ALL STAR GAME IS JUST SHINNY ANYMORE, NO SERIOUS CHECKING(THERE WAS A BIT AT ONE TIME, BUT RESPECTFULLY DONE) NOT MUCH BACK CHECKING, THE GOALIES GET POUNDED AND THE SCORE REFLECTS THAT OF A FOOTBALL GAME SOMETIMES. SO PEOPLE, THERE IS NO USE GETTING ALL BENT OUT OF SHAPE OVER A TOTALLY NON-SERIOUS GAME. I DID LIKE THE EUROPE VS NORTH AMERICA FORMAT THEY HAD FOR A FEW YEARS THOUGH, MAYBE THEY COULD CHANGE IT UP EVERY OTHER YEAR OR THIRD YEAR JUST TO MIX THINGS UP A BIT. ANY OTHER IDEAS OUT THERE?????
  • I agree with Iahabfan24 they should change the format they should have the stanley cup champions playing against the nhl allstars what better way to have the best of the best playing against each other and let sportswriters and coaches have the final say as to who plays for the allstars because if you leave it up to the fans they'll just screw up the voting AGAIN
  • i think of curse MALKIN CROSBY OVESKIN BY FAR THE BEST THEY BRING EXCITEMENT YO HE GAME NOW OH HOW JEALOUS monteal can b hey wer babies then and still cry babies
  • Penguins Blog...."A.O is a jerkoff"?
    Get over yourselves Penguins fans, as far as I'm concerned you can keep your Unholy Alliance. I'd rather see Ovechkin get snubbed in a stupid popularity contest and continue to light up lamps in every city he goes to.
    I can't stand that the NHL and its constant beating of a dead horse marketing campaign of Sid the Kid.
    There is a reason that despite the most injuries in the entire league, the Caps still have a 9 point edge over the Pens. A.O the Jerkoff is that reason.
  • Let the players from each conference pick the All Stars for their conference. They are the most knowledgeable. I believe they would pick the very best to represent their particular conference.
  • stuffing the ballot box is uncool but don't pick on the habs fans because they would like to see their own in the starting line-up in the allstar game. I call it loyalty towards their team. I would do the same. Secondly i would also like to see ovechkin over sid as starting line up any day.
    • I would like to see kessel chara and thomas or fernandez over kovalez komisarek price and markov in the allstar game any day plus they have better numbers than your hab players and mark savard has almost twice as many points as your habs top scorer has
  • The Penguins have been in and out of bankruptcy court so often over the decades they've worn holes in the welcome mat -- so it's nice to see them offer something other relolation threats for a change. Though, by far, it's the attorneys who keep the bill collectors at bay who are most valuable to this woeful franchise.
    Anyway, since the fans of the Ice Dodards have the luxury of dropping their "SAVE OUR PENS!" placards for a bit, let them vote how they please. After all, how would you feel if your team had to take the plunge every decade and swim through the sewer for top draft picks just to keep the U-Hauls away? Leave them be.
  • 1 fan 1 email address 1 vote period.
    The whole thing is a joke. $1200 for nosebleed tickets in the Bell Centre? They can keep it. I'll be on a cruise.
    Eff Montreal.
Featured Yardbarker Articles
Want more? Juice it up!
Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers
Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Join the Yardbarker Network (YBN) for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Yardbarker is a sports site where everyone’s an insider! Sports fans, bloggers, and professional athletes all hang out in the Yard to read and discuss sports articles, view the latest sports photos and videos, and debate and interact with each other.