Originally written on Shutdown Line  |  Last updated 11/8/14

This was a game that I would like to erase from my memory permanently if it were possible, but I have a job to and am here to share all of the ugly details of the 4-0 shutout the Canes endured at the hands of the Montreal Canadiens. I don't even need to get into scoring chances to illustrate how ugly this game was for Carolina because through the first 30 minutes, they were being outshot 25-6. They were going up against a team who is dressing three rookie defensemen, including one who was playing his first NHL game, and could only manage six shots through 30 minutes. Let that sink in for a minute. That is unacceptable no matter what team you are. The final stats don't look as ugly because the Canadiens decided to sit back in the third period while the Canes tried to muster up any offense they could to break the shutout. There's not much you need to do when you're leading 4-0 and outshooting a team 32-12 through two periods of play.

TSN color commentator Ray Ferraro called Carolina's play "one of the worst defensive efforts he has ever seen" and I am inclined to agree with him. Although, I felt that the forwards are much more to blame than the defense corps. So many forwards were guilty of lazy back-checking (Skinner on Subban's goal, for instance) and completely forgetting to tie up Montreal players in the neutral zone and it forced the defensemen into a lot of bad situations. To make things worse, the powerplay was lifeless yet again and Carolina wasn't creating much offense at even strength either when the game mattered. It was a pathetic game all-around and hopefully a wake-up call for a team that's now lost six of their last seven.

We'll revisit the disaster after the jump

Carolina Hurricanes vs. Montreal Canadiens 10/17/11

Period Totals EV PP 5v3 PP SH 5v3 SH 1 2 8 0 6 2 0 0 0 0 2 0 0 2 5 5 5 5 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 5 2 4 0 1 0 0 0 0 2 0 0 Totals 12 15 9 11 3 0 0 0 0 4 0 0

Carolina's chances are in red, Montreal's are in white

Yes, you're reading that correctly. The Hurricanes had zero even strength chances in the first period. They also had only four shots on goal compared to 16 by the Canadiens. When you get off to that bad of a start, it's hard to build any momentum and create a comeback. The chances were even in the second period but this is due to the Canes trying to mount a comeback after being down by three and Montreal capitalizing on their mistakes. The awful defensive play by pretty much everyone on the ice on Travis Moen's goal was the final nail in the coffin for this team.

Yes, they held Montreal to no even strength chances in the third but the Habs were collapsed into a defensive shell for the entire period and didn't need to do much of anything. The only great chance the Canes had in the third was Eric Staal's on the powerplay which was stopped by Price. Nothing else was of too high quality. In the words of Homer Simpson, Carolina just plain sucked last night.

Individual Scoring Chances

# Player EV PP SH 4 Jamie McBain 14:52 1 2 4:32 2 0 0:00 0 0 5 Bryan Allen
16:39 2 1 0:00 0 0 1:16 0 0 6 Tim Gleason
15:40 2 1 0:00 0 0 1:55 0 2 11 Zach Boychuk
8:55 0 3 0:19 0 0 0:00 0 0 12 Eric Staal
15:34 4 4 5:07 2 0 0:21 0 0 15 Tuomo Ruutu
11:43 4 4 3:18 1 0 0:00 0 0 16 Brandon Sutter
13:34 3 3 0:37 0 0 2:11 0 4 19 Jiri Tlusty
11:00 1 2 0:00 0 0 0:20 0 0 22 Zac Dalpe
8:23 1 2 0:00 0 0 0:00 0 0 23 Alexei Ponikarovsky
11:14 2 2 3:16 1 0 0:21 0 0 27 Derek Joslin
13:51 2 3 1:46 0 0 0:57 0 2 30 Cam Ward
48:46 9 11 7:47 3 0 2:52 0 4 36 Jussi Jokinen
12:48 3 4 4:17 2 0 0:39 0 2 37 Tim Brent
11:26 1 1 0:08 0 0 0:20 0 0 39 Patrick Dwyer
11:32 1 1 0:08 0 0 1:15 0 1 44 Jay Harrison
18:00 6 8 2:46 0 0 1:36 0 4 51 Tomas Kaberle
18:30 5 7 5:45 3 0 0:00 0 0 53 Jeff Skinner
13:38 4 4 4:53 3 0 0:00 0 0 59 Chad LaRose
15:27 3 3 1:20 0 0 0:17 0 1

Best EV Forwards: Eric Staal, Brandon Sutter, Chad LaRose, Jeff Skinner, Patrick Dwyer, Tim Brent, Alexei Ponikarovsky, Tuomo Ruutu EVEN

Worst EV Forward: Zach Boychuk -3

Best EV Defensemen: Bryan Allen & Tim Gleason +1

Worst EV Defensemen: Tomas Kaberle -2

Carolina had no real standouts in their forward corps which is what you would expect after such a horrible offensive showing. However, I will say that Staal and LaRose were the team's best players tonight. They were creating the most pressure out of anyone and while they weren't resulting in chances, they looked a hell of a lot better than anyone else tonight. I also thought Skinner had a decent game but his defensive shortcomings really hurt the team.

The fourth line has been struggling to earn ice-time and they got a little more in this game due to things getting out of hand early. Unfortunately, Boychuk and Dalpe were on ice for two Montreal goals and the latter looked particularly bad on that Moen goal I mentioned earlier. Tomas Kaberle is really beginning to test my patience. His underlying numbers are declining and his play on the ice seems to be getting worse with every game. Harrison was also pretty brutal in the first period as he was bumped off the defense pairing after being on ice for four of Montreal's even strength chances then along with two goals. Maybe he just isn't meant for that kind of role?

Head-to-Head at even strength

So yeah...not a lot of good things to say about this. The only players who won a matchup convincingly were the second line and the Kaberle/Harrison pairing, which is odd because those two were awful against everyone else. Allen and Gleason had a solid night overall in a game that was full of defensive errors so it's nice that our best healthy defensemen are playing well when the rest of the team isn't. I saw some people defending the fourth line tonight and I honestly don't know why. I watched this game twice and they had maybe two good shifts. Sure, they were getting the puck into the offensive zone but they were not sustaining any pressure at all. Then again, I could count the number of Carolina players who had good nights on one hand so it's not fair to single them out completely.

Okay, now let's forget this game ever happened and get ready for Buffalo.

 

Team Period Time Note CAR Opponent
MTL 1 19:10 Plekanec 5 6 15 30 36 53 14 21 26 31 32 76 5v5 CAR 1 14:33 Staal 4 12 30 36 51 53 14 26 31 32 76
5v4 MTL 1 12:45 Cammalleri 11 12 16 27 30 44 13 14 31 62 68 81 5v5 CAR 1 9:59 Skinner 4 15 23 30 51 53 15 21 31 68 74
5v4 MTL 1 8:28 Gomez 12 16 27 30 44 59 11 13 31 32 62 76 5v5 MTL 1 7:17 Darche 15 30 36 44 51 53 14 21 26 31 52 61 5v5 MTL 1 6:39 Desharnais 4 12 16 30 51 59 26 31 51 67 68 72 5v5 MTL 1 4:52 Pacioretty 6 16 30 36 44
14 31 51 67 68 72 4v5 MTL 1 4:44 Weber - GOAL 6 16 30 36 44
14 31 51 67 68 72 4v5 MTL 1 3:38 Moen 12 30 44 51 53 59 14 21 31 32 61 74 5v5 CAR 2 17:09 Skinner 15 30 36 44 51 53 31 51 61 67 72 74 5v5 MTL 2 16:04 Gionta 23 30 37 39 44 51 13 14 21 26 31 76 5v5 MTL 2 13:47 Subban - GOAL 15 30 36 44 51 53 26 31 51 67 72 76 5v5 MTL 2 6:04 Palushaj 4 15 19 27 30 36 15 31 52 60 62 68 5v5 CAR 2 5:51 Ruutu 15 30 36 44 51 53 26 31 51 67 72 76 5v5 CAR 2 5:45 Skinner 15 30 36 44 51 53 26 31 51 67 72 76 5v5 CAR 2 5:01 Sutter 5 6 12 16 30 59 11 31 32 61 74 81 5v5 MTL 2 3:53 Cammalleri 11 19 22 30 44 51 13 14 21 31 62 68 5v5 CAR 2 1:12 Harrison 12 30 37 39 44 51 31 32 51 61 74 81 5v5 MTL 2 0:38 Moen - GOAL 11 22 23 30 44 51 11 26 31 32 76 81 5v5 CAR 3 17:43 Ponikarovsky 12 22 23 30 44 51 11 31 32 62 68 81 5v5 CAR 3 16:32 Sutter 16 27 30 44 53 59 13 14 21 26 31 76 5v5 CAR 3 14:27 Staal 12 30 36 51 53
14 26 31 76

4v3 MTL 3 12:11 Cammalleri 16 27 30 39 44
11 13 14 31 68 72 4v5 MTL 3 11:38 Cammalleri 16 27 30 44 59
11 13 14 21 31 68 4v5 CAR 3 9:47 LaRose 4 16 19 27 30 59 15 26 31 52 76 81 5v5 CAR 3 8:59 Staal 5 6 12 15 23 30 13 14 21 31 68 74 5v5
MORE FROM YARDBARKER

Mike Wallace benched for disciplinary reasons

Browns owner sends stern message to Johnny Manziel

Report: Ray Allen is leaning toward retirement

Ravens clinch playoff spot

DeMarco Murray, Dez Bryant set Cowboys records in win

Report: Browns feel Josh Gordon 'has to go'

LIKE WHAT YOU SEE?
GET THE DAILY NEWSLETTER:

Jets contacted Rex Ryan's agent about replacements for him

Justin Gilbert inactive after being late to team meeting

Report: Browns had to search for Manziel after he threw party

Report: Jim Harbaugh to Michigan is done deal

Amari Cooper not a fan of New Orleans, thinks it smells

WATCH: Jennifer Lawrence does Louisville chant at game

WATCH: Ndamukong Suh steps on Aaron Rodgers

Nation's top recruit says he won't follow Jim Harbaugh

Eric Decker's wife was concerned about hubby's groin

WATCH: Lamar Miller has longest run in Dolphins history

WATCH: Pats fans serenade Pete Frates with 'Happy Birthday'

Harbaugh rumors affecting Michigan basketball ticket prices?

WATCH: Dez Bryant burns Redskins defender for TD

Detroit bar offering free food, booze if Lions beat Packers

Jameis Winston: I would throw in Richard Sherman's direction

WATCH: Nebraska safety pukes on field, keeps playing

WATCH: Nyquist holds puck for 28 seconds, scores OT winner

WATCH: Kevin Garnett blows in David West's ear

NHL News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

By clicking "Sign Me Up", you have read and agreed to the Fox Sports Digital Privacy Policy and Terms of Use. You can opt out at any time. For more information, please see our Privacy Policy.

WATCH: Suh steps on Aaron Rodgers

Browns owner sends message to Manziel

Ray Allen leaning toward retirement?

Ravens clinch playoff spot

Murray, Bryant set team records

Pats fans serenade Pete Frates

Browns to part ways with Josh Gordon?

Manziel was late after throwing party?

Amari Cooper not a fan of New Orleans

Harbaugh to Mich. is done deal

WATCH: Jennifer Lawrence supports Louisville with chant

Did Bielema do ‘Horns Down’?

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.