Found August 16, 2012 on
Fox Sports North:
TORONTO (AP) The wide gap that existed in labor talks between the NHL and NHL Players' Association was hardly bridged on Wednesday, a day after the union presented its counterproposal and with the threat of a lockout now only a month away.
NHL commissioner Gary Bettman said the two sides are "still apart, far apart," and "not on the same page," in making his first public comments since having a chance to read through the NHLPA's offer. Adding that he was "a little disappointed" that the union has yet to present its full proposal, Bettman said the league isn't even at the point of making a counteroffer.
"I think there are still a number of issues where we're looking at the world differently," Bettman said, after the two sides met for about an hour at the NHLPA headquarters in Toronto. "So there's still a wide gap between us, and not much time to go."
NHLPA executive director Don Fehr described the gap between the two sides as "a pretty substantial monetary gulf." But he placed the blame on the NHL for creating the gap in the first place with the cutbacks in salary and limitations placed on free agency the league made in its initial offer last month.
The current collective bargaining agreement expires on Sept. 15, and the NHL has already warned that it will lock out its players if a new deal is not reached by then. The NHL regular season is set to open Oct. 11.
Bettman's response to the NHLPA's proposal and the large gap that remains between the two sides is regarded as a significant setback. That considerably raises fears that the NHL could be headed for its fourth labor dispute in 20 years. That's a timeframe that includes the 2004-05 season which was wiped out entirely by a lockout; and dates to April 1, 1992, when a 10-day players' strike led to 30 games being postponed and rescheduled.
Bettman was pleased that the union, in its proposal, stuck to the framework of a cap system and acknowledged the league has economic issues that need to be addressed. The problem was the union didn't entirely satisfy those concerns from the owners' perspective.
"What the issues are and how they get solved and how deep the issues go is something we're not yet on the same page," Bettman said.
Fehr disagreed by saying the union made significant concessions and addressed the league's concerns.
The trouble was, he said, the union's proposal wasn't what the NHL asked for.
"It's not a circumstance in which the players are just going to say, OK, take everything from us,'" Fehr said. "That's basically what it was: You had a 24 percent reduction last time, so let's have another one.' That was their proposal. That's what created the gulf."
Under the league's proposal, Fehr said, players' salaries would be scaled back to the level they were before the previous lockout.
Fehr also disagreed with Bettman's suggestion that the union has not presented its full proposal. He said the NHL has "almost everything" except for certain player contract issues that are tied to economics. He said the union is considering addressing those issues next week.
Though talks on a sub-committee level are scheduled to continue, Bettman and Fehr won't return to the table until next week. Fehr is leaving negotiations to meet with players in both Chicago and Kelowna, British Columbia, to update them on talks.
Fehr did say he will stay in touch with Bettman by phone.
The union's counterproposal stood in stark contrast to what the NHL made in its initial proposal a month earlier.
The NHLPA proposed a deal in which players would give up as much 465 million in revenue if the league's overall revenue continues to grow at an average rate over the first three years of the deal. Fehr indicated that number could balloon to 800 million if the league grows at the same rate it has over the past two seasons.
Players would then have the option in the fourth year to revert to the current system, in which they receive between 54 and 57 percent of league revenues.
The union also proposed that the NHL commit money to a revenue-sharing system to help struggling teams.
Fehr described the players' offer as one that could stabilize the industry.
The NHL's initial proposal placed much of the burden on its players. The league is seeking another 24 percent cut in player revenue and the introduction severe limits to free agency. That includes players waiting 10 years to be eligible to become unrestricted free agents, as opposed to seven in the current deal, and eliminating players' rights to salary arbitration.
Bettman noted that players in other major sports, such as the NFL and the NBA, agreed to reduce their revenue share in new deals that have been struck over the past year.
Fehr said it's unfair to make those comparisons. And he questioned why Bettman didn't mention major league baseball, which has revenue sharing among teams, doesn't have a cap system and has enjoyed labor peace.
BEST OF MAXIM
AROUND THE WEB
A.B. Poor Gary. He has the entire NHLPA, sports media & hockey fans on his back. Everyone knows a lockout will kill the sport. But how is the commish supposed to negotiate a new CBA if he can’t even work an umbrella.
Could be dark (and wet) days ahead…
This certainly puts the pending NHL lockout in perspective.
NHL commissioner Gary Bettman said a ''wide gap'' remains in labor talks between the league and the NHL Players' Association in issuing his first public comments on Wednesday, a day after the union presented its offer.
While Bettman said he can understand the proposal the NHLPA made, he cautioned that the two sides see the world differently. He added that he...
Twenty-four hours after receiving a CBA proposal from the NHLPA, NHL Commissioner Gary Bettman told NHL.com that there is still a "wide gap" between the two parties in terms of the economic system. "I think it's fair to say that we value the [Union's] proposal and what it means in terms of its economics differently than the Players' Association...
NHL Commish Gary Bettman said there is a Goatse.cx-wide gap (don’t Google this) between the League and the Player’s union, and with the Collective Bargaining Agreement expiring on September 15th, it appears likely that the players do no begin hockey activities in time to start the season on, uh, time. Hopefully it is nothing worse than what the NFL went through or even the...
NHL labor talks are set to resume with a wide gap remaining and time running out to avoid a potential lockout.
NHL Players' Association executive director Don Fehr and NHL commissioner Gary Bettman are scheduled to be back at the negotiating table at the union's headquarters in Toronto on Wednesday. It will mark the first time in a week the respective leaders will meet face...
When the NHL labor dispute began, everyone knew that the initial offer from the owners to the players would be insulting. In fact, many called the offer laughable. So after that, the league and its’ owners, as well as commissioner Gary Bettman, fully expected the NHLPA to make an equally insulting counter-offer back to the owners.
They were wrong.
TSN’s Aaron Ward...
On Tuesday, it sounded to me like the NHLPA had presented an intelligent, alternative view as a frae work for the new NHL CBA. Given ample time to digest the players' proposal, Gary Bettman all but torched the plan and let it smolder in the trash can. By Wednesday afternoon, the fear and loathing of another lockout--- the third on Bettman's watch--- was hovering over hockey...
The NHLPA's proposal to the owners on Tuesday seemed to spark some hope for a new deal to get done between the two sides in the near future. Scratch that. NHL Commissioner Gary Bettman apparently wasn't all that impressed with the offer and claimed on Wednesday that there was still a "wide gap" between the two groups. While players like Milan Lucic stand united...
For those of you who don't know, I live in the Pacific Northwest and it is one of the most beautiful places you can find in America to live in. But sometimes there's a price for living in such a scenic area and that is fire season.
Forest fires are one of the most frightening experiences a person can go through because you never know what happens when you'...
The NHL issued a new proposal to the players' association Tuesday as a lockout looms next month.
And at least one side is happy about it.
''We believe,'' NHL Commissioner Gary Bettman said, ''that we made a significant, meaningful step.''
Time will tell, but at least NHLPA executive director Donald Fehr and his players have another proposal...
National Hockey League commissioner Gary Bettman sounded nearly dismissive a little more than a year ago when it came to possible labor strife, citing the fact that the nation's three other major professional sports leagues had their respective collective bargaining agreements expiring before the NHL's did.
In the ensuing months, all those leagues came to terms on new deals...
As most of you know the NHL Commissioner threw cold water on the NHLPA’s proposal and now NHL hockey fans have to worry if there is going to be a work stoppage that could cost us a good share of the NHL season. To quote Gary Bettman, "There's still a wide gap between us with not much time to go."
A while back, my good buddy Redwing77 suggested that the NHL contract...
There are now less than thirty days before the owner's September 15 deadline to have a new collective bargaining agreement in place for the NHL. Meanwhile, what appeared to be progress made earlier this past week was rapidly squandered when news broke that the gap between the NHL and NHLPA is quite immense in terms of cash and desires. So you do the math; this isn't looking...
With just a month remaining until a lockout becomes official, the NHLPA and owners are still duking it out to create a new CBA. At this time, both parties appear to be nowhere close to nailing down a deal and a work stoppage seems imminent.Here we go again.For those counting at home, this would be the third lockout in NHL history, spanning the last 18 years. The 1994-1995 season...