Found November 21, 2012 on Blue Seat Blogs:
Ice_hockey_f4d4
Image: Getty Images Gary Bettman became NHL commissioner on February 1, 1993, and has been in this position for almost 20 years. Under Bettman, the league has seen three work stoppages, but also unparalleled growth. While many believe the league over expanded in the Bettman era, it’s worth evaluating each move/relocation to see where the faults/successes were. There were six new teams added to the league under Bettman’s reign –keep in mind that San Jose (1991), Ottawa (1992), and Tampa Bay (1992) all joined the league before Bettman took over as commissioner, so they are omitted from this evaluation– and five relocations. The grades (Pass or Fail) are based on both team success and financial success. 1993 – Anaheim Mighty Ducks enter league It took the Ducks three years to make the playoffs following expansion to Anaheim, and they even made it to the second round in 1996 before losing to the Red Wings. Following the acquisition of Scott Niedermayer and (re)acquisition of Teemu Selanne in 1995, the Ducks became a legitimate Stanley Cup contender behind their two leaders and J.S. Giguere, who had single-handedly taken the team to the Stanley Cup Finals in 2003. The Ducks won the Cup in 2007, but have been relatively irrelevant in postseason hockey since. Despite their successes, the Ducks have been losing roughly $8 million per year and average roughly 86% capacity in attendance numbers. A second team in the LA area likely wasn’t a good idea. Grade: Fail. 1993 – Florida Panthers enter league While the argument can be made that SoCal could support a second NHL franchise in Anaheim, based off the Wayne Gretzky popularity build, the thought that Florida could support a second NHL franchise –TB entered the league in1992– was a complete gamble. Outside of a very passionate core of fans, the Panthers have had trouble drawing fans. The fact that they haven’t been successful until last year (aside from 2000) didn’t help either. The Panthers lose an average of $7 million per year, and like the Ducks, draw fans to an 86% capacity. Grade: Fail. 1993 – Minnesota North Stars relocate to Dallas The move to Dallas was a risky one, considering Minnesota is an incredible hockey market. But the Stars were incredibly successful in Dallas, both in the standings and on their bottom line. Solid ownership and shrewd hockey moves have kept this team in the hearts and minds of the fans in Dallas. It wasn’t until recently –when the Stars saw fan favorites Mike Modano, Jere Lehtinen, and Marty Turco either leave or retire– that the Stars fell on to bad times. Still, it’s been proven that if the team is successful, the fans will show. The Stars lost $1 million two seasons ago, and only managed to draw fans to a 76% capacity. However, I’m going to give them a mulligan on the past few years. Rebuilding in a non-traditional market isn’t exactly easy. Grade: Pass. 1995 – Quebec Nordiques relocate to Colorado Economics drove the Nordiques to Colorado, and that market has been great to the Avalanche. Like the Stars, they saw immediate success upon relocation, and parlayed that into a very nice fan base. Also like the Stars, the Avalanche have seen a changing of the guard, and it’s affected their attendance at games. Despite that, they still make a profit. The Avalanche make $6 million and draw fans to an 86% capacity. Grade: Pass. 1996 – Winnipeg Jets relocate to Phoenix Without spending too much time on this, let’s just say that a relevant and successful team in Phoenix may have resulted in a different result. It wasn’t until very recently that Phoenix became a solid hockey club. But that doesn’t matter, this team is now in an ownership mess, and it’s clear the city of Glendale doesn’t want them there anymore. Revenues ($24 million loss) and attendance (72%) are the lowest in the league. This move should never have happened. Grade: Fail. 1997 – Hartford Whalers relocate to North Carolina If I didn’t make enemies with my Anaheim grade, I will with this one. Carolina is a very well run organization, and has had some success since the relocation to Raleigh. It isn’t the best market, as the Hurricanes draw fans to an 86% capacity and still lose about $4 per season. That said, Hartford (the city, not the fans) didn’t do much to keep the Whalers. They needed a new arena, and they didn’t get it. Much like the Islanders, the team would have worked had the city coughed up the necessary commitment. Grade: Pass 1998 – Nashville Predators enter league It’s amazing what smart ownership and shrewd team management can do for a franchise. The fans in Nashville love the Predators, despite the fact that they have seen every single star player (save for Pekka Rinne and Shea Weber) leave town for greener pastures. The Preds are still a solid team, and proof that hockey can work in non-traditional markets, in terms of attendance at least. The Predators lead the way among new NHL franchises with a whopping 96% capacity average for attendance. However, they still lose about $7 million a year. Nashville is one of two teams (Minnesota) on this list where a new CBA is actually the only option. The cap floor system doesn’t work for them, despite their success. Grade: Pass. 1999 – Atlanta Thrashers enter league Hockey failed once in Atlanta (Atlanta Flames), why would they try it again. Grade:Fail. 2000 – Columbus Blue Jackets enter league The Blue Jackets are the toughest team on this list to really evaluate. They hemorrhage money ($13 million a year) and barely average an 80% attendance rate, but their lack of success on the ice hasn’t exactly helped them. The CBJ fans I’ve corresponded with believe that their franchise would be in much better financial shape if they could get someone in there that can actually run a franchise. Grade: Incomplete, pending a competent GM. 2000 – Minnesota Wild enter league Minnesota is another place where hockey should have never left. Bettman did the right thing when he added another franchise here, and the fans (98% capacity) have rewarded his decision. That said, Minnesota is a small market, and the salary cap floor doesn’t exactly help them out. The Wild, despite their attendance rates, still lose $6 million a year, which is why Leipold is playing hardball with the negotiations. Minnesota is the only other franchise, aside from Nashville, that needs revenue sharing and the elimination of the cap floor. Other than that, hockey works in Minnesota. Grade: Pass. 2010 – Atlanta Thrashers relocate to Winnipeg Hockey should have never left Winnipeg to begin with. Grade: Pass  Timeline source: Detroit Hockey.net: http://www.detroithockey.net/nhl/timeline.php. NHL Valuation Source: Forbes.com: http://www.forbes.com/nhl-valuations/list/ Tweet
THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
AROUND THE WEB
RELATED ARTICLES

Gary Bettman Bombarded By Disgruntled Flyers Fan During News Conference

Hockey fans are getting angry, and they’re not afraid to let NHL commissioner Gary Bettman know it. On Wednesday, the league and the Players’ Association met for another round of negotiations, reportedly making an insubstantial amount of progress. NHL deputy commissioner Bill Daly was originally scheduled to address the media after the session, but instead Bettman himself came...

Report: Fan has his say to Bettman

Hockey fans are getting angry, and they're not afraid to let NHL commissioner Gary Bettman know it. On Wednesday, the league and the Players' Association met for another round of negotiations, reportedly making an insubstantial amount of progress. NHL deputy commissioner Bill Daly was originally scheduled to address the media after the session, but instead Bettman himself...

NHL, NHLPA Meet Monday After Brief Hiatus, Paul Kelly Believes ‘Some Progess Was Made’ (Video)

After commissioner Gary Bettman suggested that the NHL and NHLPA take a two-week break from CBA negotiations, the players wanted nothing to do with that. Four days after Bettman’s idea was shot down, the two sides met on Monday in New York to rekindle talks in hope of salvaging some part of the 2012 season. The meeting lasted roughly two hours, and the two sides plan to meet again...

Bruins Fans MAY Like How The Montreal Canadiens Are STICKING IT To Gary Bettman (PHOTO)

Photo: Yahoo During times when hockey is ACTUALLY played, Bruins fans HATE the Montreal Canadiens like HOT FIRE. Our Black & Gold blood just BOILS at the sights of Guy LaFleur, Patrick Roy & P.K. Subban. However, during a time of  labor unrest (the fourth one under commissioner Gary Bettman), fans UNITE no matter what color the laundry is. And Bruins fans have to LIKE how...

Bettman After The CBA Meeting

Bettman says business is losing $18-20 mil per day. Says players are losing between $8-10 mil per day. — Darren Dreger (@DarrenDreger) November 21, 2012   Bettman says PA "expects our best offer to get better" despite lockout $ losses. Commish is trying to be positive though — Pat Leonard (@NYDNRangers) November 21, 2012   Bettman --...

Erik Cole, NHL Players Wearing ‘Puck Gary’ Hats, Taking Dig at Gary Bettman (Photo)

The NHL lockout isn’t quite past the point of no return, but it became more than insufferable a long time ago. The players and owners continue trading places as the dinks, and it’s Erik Cole and members of the Motnreal Canadiens who is now wearing the “dink” hat. Well, actually, he’s wearing a different kind of hat, but is no less of a dink. TVA Sports (via LFPress.com...

Gary Bettman: Three Strikes You’re Out

While the calendar continues to turn month by month, one thing has been consistent: a lack of NHL hockey.  Since the second lockout of Commissioner Gary Bettman’s tenure in the 2004-2005 season, hockey’s popularity in North America has grown exponentially.  The average attendance in the NHL last year was 17,455, higher than the rival NBA, and up 1.8% from two seasons ago, while...

Bill Meltzer: Meltzer's Musings: Competitive Balance; Phantoms Roster Updates

In his recent interview with the Winnipeg Free Press, NHL Commissioner Gary Bettman reiterated one of his pre-lockout talking points that essentially attempted to justify the lockout as something the game needs. A steep reduction of the cap ceiling as well as the cap floor is not a money grab, he claimed, it's about giving every team a fair shake to put out a competitive project...

NHL lockout talks break off again

NEW YORK (AP) Jaymes Hall had a question for NHL Commissioner Gary Bettman about the lockout, which already has wiped out more than a quarter of the regular season: Why not put aside the money in dispute and get back on the ice. Hall tried to get in his question while Bettman was responding to media members outside the league's Manhattan office. When the commissioner was done...

NHL Players Irked That Owners Won’t Budge as Lockout Talks Break Off in Frustration

NEW YORK — NHL labor talks broke off soon after they resumed Wednesday, with players maintaining their new proposal was a huge economic concession and commissioner Gary Bettman pretty much saying the only deal he will agree to is the one management proposed last month. On the 67th day of a lockout that already has wiped out more than a quarter of the regular season, the sides headed...

NHL rejects players' proposal; no new talks set

Any optimism that a deal between the NHL and the Players Assn. might be imminent following the unions presentation of a comprehensive collective bargaining proposal Wednesday morning lasted only a few hours. Thats all it took for the sides to meet and for the NHL to reject the proposal, in which players said they had made moves toward the NHLs stance in several areas. We are still...

NHL labor talks to resume

NEW YORK (AP) -- For the first time in eight days, the NHL and the players' association are back at the bargaining table to try again to reach a deal that will end the two-month old lockout. Talks resumed on Monday, the 65th day of the lockout that has already wiped out 327 games and threatens the entire season if a settlement isn't reached soon. After turning down a suggestion...
Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.