Originally written on Shutdown Line  |  Last updated 11/17/14
Not going to lie here, I thought the Rangers should have been able to handle the Caps at even strength fairly easily based on these two team's play in the regular season. This hasn't been happening, though as the Rangers have been outchanced 39-36 by the Caps at evens heading into tonight's game. They aren't getting dominated but they were outplayed in two out of three games and were able to scrape out an ugly win on Monday. Those kind of wins always go a long way in the playoffs, though and it gave the Rangers a chance to climb back in the series. The Rangers are also a better team than what they showed in the first three games, so this series could very well go the full distance if the Rangers could return to their level of play during the regular season. Last night, we saw just that. The Rangers looked more like the team that many expected to see this playoffs as they had complete control of things for about 75% of the game. Their offense came back to life in recording a total of 23 scoring chances and keeping Washington's better forwards quiet for the majority of the game. They were able to do this well in Game 3, as well but didn't create much offense at even strength. This ended up being the difference maker last night as they did not allow the Caps to have much sustained zone time at all. In addition to that, the Rangers got something they've received little of this series, which is good bounces. Their first goal came after Taylor Pyatt knocked down a bad clearing attempt from Braden Holtby and it allowed Brad Richards to eventually score on an empty net. They got another one in the third period when Carl Hagelin was able to draw Holtby out of position and quickly get the puck to Derek Stepan, who fired the puck into an empty cage for the Rangers fourth goal of the game, which ultimately ended up being the game-winner. These kinds of chances & breaks weren't happening to the Rangers in the first three games, so being able to get these bounces likely played a role in the team's confidence. The Rangers obviously can't rely on bounces to advance but they have to like their chances now that the score is tied and their team just played easily their best game of the series. Washington Capitals vs. New York Rangers Game Four Period Total EV PP 5v3 SH 3v5 1 8 3 5 2 0 0 1 0 2 1 0 0 2 9 6 8 6 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 6 8 5 8 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Totals 23 17 18 16 2 0 1 0 2 1 0 0 This game was all Rangers for the first two periods. They outchanced Washington 17-9 and held Washington to only three total scoring chances for the first 30 minutes. Washington began to wake up after Carl Hagelin made it 2-0 in the second period and started to build more sustained offense. Score affects likely played a role here because the Rangers were basically just trying to defend their lead at that point and unfortunately for them, their strategy failed as the Caps were able to get two late-second period goals to tie the game off a couple of bad mistakes by the Rangers defense. However, the bounces continued to go in the Rangers favor in the third period as they scored a power play goal on their first scoring chance of the third period and reassumed control of the game for the next 10 minutes or so and got another goal from Derek Stepan. After that, however, they began to back off a little and reverted back to a more defensive style. I can't say that it was executed well since the Caps were able to get a fair bit of chances and Henrik Lundqvist had to do his part to keep the Rangers on top, but they still got the win in the end. I understand the mindset of employing the defensive shell when playing with the lead but it seems kind of pointless when you end up surrendering six scoring chances in a ten minutes span. Kind of like how the prevent defense in football. A win is a win, though and I thought the Rangers looked better than they have all series.  Also worth noting is that the Rangers (barely) won the special teams battle, which was going to be a deciding factor whether you like it or not. The Rangers power play, as a whole, looked bad but that goal from Dan Girardi at the beginning of the third period proved to be huge while the Caps ended up getting outchanced on their one power play opportunity in the first period. Much like the last game, it's an ugly win for the Rangers special teams but it ended up being a deciding factor. Rangers Individual Scoring Chances # Player EV PP SH 4 Michael Del Zotto 11:12 2 7 2:42 2 0 0:00 0 0 5 Dan Girardi  25:07 6 5 2:20 1 0 2:08 1 1 6 Anton Stralman 18:37 10 6 0:00 0 0 1:29 1 0 14 Taylor Pyatt 10:04 4 3 0:00 0 0 0:00 0 0 15 Derek Dorsett 7:18 2 3 0:00 0 0 0:00 0 0 16 Derick Brassard 14:41 7 2 2:48 1 0 0:00 0 0 17 John Moore 12:40 5 6 1:27 0 0 1:29 1 0 19 Brad Richards 12:12 4 8 2:39 1 0 0:00 0 0 21 Derek Stepan 16:50 7 5 2:11 2 0 1:42 1 1 22 Brian Boyle 19:04 4 6 2:30 2 0 1:55 1 0 24 Ryan Callahan 18:11 9 3 3:19 2 0 2:01 1 1 27 Ryan McDonagh  29:18 11 5 0:03 1 0 2:08 1 1 29 Ryane Clowe 12:19 2 7 0:00 0 0 0:00 0 0 30 Henrik Lundqvist  51:24 18 16 4:59 3 0 3:37 2 1 36 Mats Zuccarello  10:38 4 3 1:40 1 0 0:00 0 0 44 Steve Eminger 5:54 2 3 0:00 0 0 0:00 0 0 45 Arron Asham 4:21 0 0 0:00 0 0 0:00 0 0 61 Rick Nash 13:49 5 6 2:53 2 0 0:07 0 0 62 Carl Hagelin 14:45 6 2 0:00 0 0 1:29 1 0 Best EV Forward: Ryan Callahan +6 Worst EV Forward: Ryane Clowe -5 Best EV Defenseman: Ryan McDonagh +6 Worst EV Defenseman: Michael Del Zotto -5 The old sports cliche is that your best players have to rise to the occasion and I think most of the Rangers top layers did just that. Callahan, Hagelin & Stepan had a phenomenal game at even strength and led the way for the Rangers offense by producing two goals. That being said, neither of them were as good as Ryan McDonagh, who did an amazing job at containing Ovechkin's line and helped chip in offensively on top of that. John Tortorella basically kept him stapled to the Capitals top line even when he wasn't with Dan Girardi, and he still managed to dominate that line in head-to-head competition. Derick Brassard also had a great performance despite playing with a revolving door of linemates. Brassard has mostly given other teams fits on the power play over his career, but his game at even strength last night was very impressive. His play-making skills are second to none and they have been on full display in these last two games. What's even more impressive is that he managed to be on the ice for seven scoring chances while playing with third liners for most of the game. I would say that he could have a shot at taking over Brad Richards' spot but there are two problems with that. First of all, he played more minutes than Richards in the first place and secondly, Richards was stuck with Pyatt & Clowe on his line for most of the game and the latter had a brutal game defensively.  On the subject of bad defense, Michael Del Zotto got absolutely destroyed by the Capitals third line. His coverage on Perreault's first goal was...interesting to say the least but even outside of that embarrassing gaffe, he was making a lot of mistakes in his own end for the entire game. Just a brutal performance by him all-around. Girardi & McDonagh are the keystones of this defense but their lack of depth here is showing in a bad way with Marc Staal still not at 100%. Capitals Individual Scoring Chances # Player EV PP SH 4 John Erskine 15:03 3 3 0:00 0 0 0:59 0 1 8 Alex Ovechkin  20:04 3 9 3:32 1 2 0:00 0 0 9 Mike Ribeiro 16:06 4 3 2:21 1 1 0:00 0 0 10 Martin Erat 3:26 0 1 1:16 0 1 0:00 0 0 16 Eric Fehr 15:55 6 2 1:16 0 1 0:18 0 0 19 Nicklas Backstrom 14:05 3 5 2:21 1 1 2:44 0 1 20 Troy Brouwer 15:05 3 3 2:21 1 1 2:06 0 2 25 Jason Chimera 13:32 9 6 0:00 0 0 0:00 0 0 26 Matt Hendricks 9:30 0 5 0:00 0 0 1:01 0 1 27 Karl Alzner 17:13 10 4 0:00 0 0 3:21 0 2 38 Jack Hillen 18:23 3 9 0:00 0 0 0:39 0 0 42 Joel Ward 12:49 8 6 0:00 0 0 0:39 0 0 52 Mike Green 21:51 11 4 3:37 1 2 0:00 0 0 61 Steve Oleksy 10:17 1 8 0:00 0 0 0:39 0 0 70 Braden Holtby  50:07 16 18 3:37 1 2 4:59 0 3 74 John Carlson 20:21 4 8 0:05 0 0 4:20 0 3 83 Jay Beagle 8:33 0 5 0:00 0 0 0:39 0 1 85 Mathieu Perreault 12:36 9 5 0:00 0 0 0:00 0 0 90 Marcus Johansson 13:28 3 4 1:16 0 1 0:31 0 0 Best EV Forwards: Mathieau Perreault & Eric Fehr +4 Worst EV Forward: Alexander Ovechkin -6 Best EV Defenseman: Mike Green +7 Worst EV Defenseman: Steve Oleksy -7 I mentioned after Game Three that the Rangers best hope was to "contain" Ovechkin rather than shut him down completely, but they were able to do just that last night. Adam Oates didn't do a lot to get Ovechkin away from Girardi & McDonagh, but he did try to double-shift him with the fourth line and I think that kind of just made things worse since Tortorella was still able to shadow him with McDonagh then and he ended up not doing much with worse linemates. The Caps big guns were neutralized, but their second and third lines both contributed well. Eric Fehr was promoted to the second line after Martin Erat went down and you can see that he did a lot of good things. He always seems to be one of the Caps better territorial players even with limited minutes and he took advantage of getting more ice-time last night. The other line that had things going territorially for the Caps was the third line of Mathieu Perreault, Joel ward & Jason Chimera. This line actually produced two goals and the bulk of Washington's scoring chances. Chimera & Ward both are great skaters and were able to use this to their advantage against the Rangers depth players and they were pretty great at establishing zone time & puck possession. It's always good to get these kinds of contributions from your third line but when that's your best line in a playoff game, it probably isn't a good thing. The Caps third line played well but their third defense pairing got torn apart at even strength. Part of the reason for this was Tortorella being able to get his first line out against them but they also had trouble containing Richards & Brassard's line on top of that. Oleksy & Hillen were basically the opposite of how they played in Game Three where they performed well in limited minutes. That obviously wasn't the case last night. The Caps tough-minute defenseman, John Carlson, also had another rough game. He has seemed to have trouble when playing away from Verizon Center this series and I can't quite figure out why because he gets the tough matchups regardless. Oates relieved some of the pressure on him by putting Green/Alzner on Stepan's line for some portions of the game and these two had a very good performance offensively. Head-to-Head at Five-on-Five The Rangers first line beat Washington's tough-minute defense pairing to a pulp and outchanced the Backstrom line handily. Tortorella was also able to get some of his better forwards out against the Caps third defense pairing long enough for them to do significant damage, I'm not sure if he'll be able to do this while playing on the road, though. I'm also not sure if he'll be able to keep Del Zotto away from the Capitals more dangerous forwards without the benefit of the last change and that could lead to some bad results if he continues to struggle against third-liners. Tortorella doesn't seem to have an issue with riding Girardi & McDonagh like pack mules so they are always out against Ovechkin, though. Period Team Time Player NYR WSH   1 NYR 16:40 Boyle 16 22 36 4 44 30 9 10 20 38 61 70 5v5 1 NYR 15:24 Nash 21 24 61 5 27 30 19 90 20 27 52 70 5v5 1 WSH 13:47 Perreault 19 14 62 6 27 30 85 16 25 38 61 70 5v5 1 WSH 12:24 Ribeiro 21 24 5 27 30   9 19 20 8 52 70 4v5 1 WSH 8:09 Perreault 16 22 36 4 44 30 85 16 25 27 52 70 5v5 1 NYR 7:19 Callahan 21 24 61 5 27 30 26 83 8 4 74 70 5v5 1 NYR 6:38 Nash 19 61 62 6 17 30 26 83 42 38 61 70 5v5 1 NYR 4:23 Boyle 22 36 15 6 17 30 19 8 25 27 52 70 5v5 1 NYR 2:14 Boyle 22 62 6 17 30   9 19 20 8 52 70 4v5 1 NYR 1:34 Callahan 21 24 5 27 30   90 10 16 8 52 70 4v5 1 NYR 0:05 Stepan 19 21 22 24 61 30 20 27 74 70     5v3 2 NYR 17:45 Pyatt 19 14 62 6 27 30 85 42 25 38 61 70 5v5 2 NYR 17:23 Stepan 19 21 61 6 27 30 85 42 25 52 61 70 5v5 2 NYR 17:17 Stepan 21 24 61 5 27 30 85 42 25 52 61 70 5v5 2 NYR 12:33 Stepan 21 24 61 5 27 30 26 83 27 74 70   5v4 2 NYR 9:47 Hagelin - GOAL 16 29 62 4 44 30 85 42 25 27 61 70 5v5 2 WSH 7:56 Fehr 21 36 61 4 5 30 9 16 20 38 52 70 5v5 2 NYR 7:31 Brassard 16 22 36 6 17 30 9 16 20 38 61 70 5v5 2 WSH 6:55 Ward 19 15 29 4 44 30 85 42 25 4 74 70 5v5 2 WSH 6:52 Perreault - GOAL 19 15 29 4 44 30 85 42 25 4 74 70 5v5 2 WSH 2:58 Green 22 24 61 5 27 30 19 90 8 27 52 70 5v5 2 NYR 1:02 Brassard 16 24 14 5 27 30 26 83 8 38 74 70 5v5 2 NYR 0:57 Callahan 16 24 14 6 27 30 26 83 8 38 74 70 5v5 2 NYR 0:55 Callahan 16 24 14 6 27 30 26 83 8 38 74 70 5v5 2 WSH 0:18 Brouwer - GOAL 21 22 61 6 17 30 9 16 20 27 52 70 5v5 2 WSH 0:03 Carlson 21 22 61 6 17 30 85 42 25 27 74 70 5v5 3 NYR 19:01 Girardi - GOAL 16 22 36 4 5 30 19 20 4 74 70   5v4 3 WSH 18:27 Ward 19 29 61 6 27 30 85 42 25 27 52 70 5v5 3 NYR 13:58 Stepan - GOAL 21 24 62 5 17 30 19 90 8 38 61 70 5v5 3 WSH 12:29 Perreault - GOAL 19 29 61 4 17 30 85 42 25 27 52 70 5v5 3 NYR 11:21 Callahan 21 24 62 5 27 30 19 90 8 4 74 70 5v5 3 NYR 11:18 Hagelin 21 24 62 5 27 30 19 90 8 4 74 70 5v5 3 WSH 10:31 Green 16 22 36 6 17 30 9 16 20 38 52 70 5v5 3 NYR 9:51 Richards 19 15 29 6 17 30 85 42 25 27 74 70 5v5 3 WSH 9:20 Perrault 19 15 29 4 5 30 85 42 25 27 74 70 5v5 3 WSH 7:57 Johansson 21 24 62 5 27 30 19 90 8 4 52 70 5v5 3 WSH 5:09 Backstrom 21 22 24 5 27 30 19 90 8 27 52 70 5v5 3 WSH 3:42 Ward 19 14 29 6 17 30 9 16 42 27 52 70 5v5 3 WSH 3:21 Perreault 19 14 29 4 27 30 85 42 25 27 52 70 5v5 3 NYR 1:59 Boyle 16 22 36 6 27 30 9 16 8 38 74 70 5v5  
MORE FROM YARDBARKER

Furniture store will refund purchases if OSU wins title

A gift from Santa: NFC edition

Is SI ashamed to mention Jameis Winston on its cover?

Kobe Bryant disappointed Lakers didn't get Rajon Rondo

Niners OT Anthony Davis takes shot at offensive coordinator

Report: Josh Smith expected to sign with Rockets

LIKE WHAT YOU SEE?
GET THE DAILY NEWSLETTER:

Cullen Jenkins thinks his roughing the passer fine is unfair

Bochy: Peavy trade was best in-season move of 2014

Report: Anderson Varejao out for season with torn Achilles

Kevin Nash arrested after alleged fight with son

Report: Celtics, Cavs discussing three-team trade

NFC playoff picture, Week 17: Division showdowns

Baseball cards: a fan's love for the ultimate stocking stuffer

Packers game is a career defining moment for Stafford

Jason Grilli signs with Atlanta (sort of) for two years

10 Week 17 NFL matchups that will impact the playoffs

WATCH: Bahamas Bowl ends on insane Hail Mary play

Mike Yeo slams Wild for not having 'winner's attitude'

Michigan St. QB, Ohio State TE have awkward Twitter exchange

Will FIFA ever care to change?

Top storyline for each NFL Week 17 game

The 40 greatest Christmas-related names in sports

NBA teams rooting for others to win

WATCH: Vlade Divac drains half-court shot, wins $90K for charity

NHL News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

By clicking "Sign Me Up", you have read and agreed to the Fox Sports Digital Privacy Policy and Terms of Use. You can opt out at any time. For more information, please see our Privacy Policy.

10 Week 17 NFL matchups that will impact the playoffs

Bahamas Bowl ends on crazy Hail Mary

49ers OT Davis takes shot at coordinator

Will FIFA ever care to change?

Top storyline for each Week 17 game

40 great Christmas-related sports names

Nick Mangold and dealing with feelings as a sports fan

Ibaka, Aldridge ejected for scuffle

Baseball cards: a fan's love for the ultimate stocking stuffer

Nick Young on Kobe-less win: He needs to pass

NFC playoff picture, Week 17: Division showdowns

J.R. Smith: Knicks' season a 'nightmare'

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.