Yes, tonight the
Oakland Raiders were just flat out greater than
Matt Leinart.
I know there are hundreds of thousands of fantasy fans out there waiting for
Matt Leinart to morph back into the confident and accurate lefty that helped turn USC into one of the most feared college offenses in NCAA history, but too bad for them, because the NFL doesn't seem to be a fairytale game.
Matt's Week 1 and 2 Pre-Season performances allowed some hope to creep back into the hearts of Cardinal fans and former USC homers, but Week 3 against the Raiders was a completely different story. We'll hop into Matt's awesome stats for that game in a second, but first I need to conjure up a way to actually calculate such a magnificent quarterback rating.
The problem with Matt is this: he has to go to practice every single day and start every single pre-season game with the reality check that he's not the best quarterback on the team. That's right,
Kurt Warner is the best Cardinal signal caller, and it seems like every single player on this team understands that. Heck, it seems like everybody in the NFL knows that. And I know Matt knows that - watch him play. If there was ever a quarterback looking over his shoulder, Matt's the guy. You think it'd be easy for a guy with two All-Pro receivers like
Larry Fitzgerald and
Anquan Boldin, but Leinart's play early last season and against the defensive dynamo in Oakland today shows me that he's not having an easy time at all.
Matt can't run the hurry-up. Matt can't throw the deep ball. Matt isn't as accurate as his back-up. Matt doesn't have the respect of his team. Matt doesn't get the job done. The Titans picked
Vince Young over
Matt Leinart because Young proved he's a winner. Sure, he might not have the accurate arm and he might not make the best decisions - but when it comes to winning or losing, Vince does work.
In Arizona, they call in a former MVP as a late-inning reliever.
Today in Oakland, Matt was 4 for 12 for 24 measly yards zero touchdowns and 3 interceptions. If there was a negative quarterback rating, I'm pretty sure Matt managed it tonight. I know the Raiders have a decent secondary, they might even have a great secondary, but with 'Quan and Fitz on the edges, you just can't miss that many throws. Even when he's had good stats this season, he hasn't looked good.
Be prepared, fantasy owners,
Matt Leinart is not the answer. Stop pretending that this is college, and the Cardinals play in the Pac-10. In the NFL the talent level is fairly even across the board, unless of course you have Boldin and Fitzgerald playing receiver. Ugh. Even with that advantage Matt can't seem to figure it out.
When all is said and done, I figure
Matt Leinart will be one of the best college quarterbacks there was. He ran that USC offense to perfection. But when his NFL career is over, he'll always be considered an underachiever. At least that's how I see it. He seems like a good guy, and I hope he proves me wrong, but I can't help but see it how it is. Maybe I'm being too critical, and maybe I'm not giving him a chance, but I'll be stunned if Matt has a good season in Arizona.