In this 2009 offseason extravaganza I plan on looking at each area of the team including, starting pitching, relievers, positional players, bench, and what ever else I feel like coming up with. In this section I'm going to covering third base.
In 2008 the Reds for the 1st time actually gave
Edwin Encarnacion a fair shot at being the everyday third baseman. What I mean by that is there was no mid season trip to the minors and no long term benchings. What they got was a bunch of errors, and a team leading 26 homers (if you don't count Dunn). Of course the errors are a big time problem, but as I stated in the first base section Edwin's problems aren't related much to his actual fielding, but more related to his throwing.
Throwing Errors: 16
Feilding Errors: 6
On the other hand his hitting although was good for a team 2nd OPS of .804, but in terms of how that compares to the rest of the majors it is well pretty much average.
OPS+: 106
So there's the problem the Reds are stuck with. Either some how improve Edwin's defense to an above average level, or move him to another position to limit the flaws in his defense. If it wasn't for
Joey Votto the choice would be pretty obvious because Edwin could then move to 1st with out much of a problem in my opinion. The other option is moving Edwin to left field. The problem there would be that he would have to improve his batting substantially, or prove to be one of the better defending left fielders in the major leagues. It's quite a problem that I'm pretty happy I'm not having to find an answer for. Don't forget the possibility of a trade involving Edwin.
If of course Edwin does make a move, either trade or position, the Reds would then need to find their new third baseman. They have an option in Todd Frazier, although he probably wont be ready until late 2009.
Redsminorleagues.com:
Frazier's bat is legit. He can do it all, hit for power, hit for average and draw his fair share of walks. The main question with him is where he will play on the field. The Reds have had him at SS, 3B and 1B this year. Still, no matter where he ends up, his bat will play there just fine. Look for him to start in Carolina next year.
As for free agents the choices are pretty thin. Which likely means you are going to have to overpay if you land one of them. This option is probably very unlikely given the price tag, and the lack of options.
Key Free Agents:
Casey Blake Joe Crede