
The whispers have turned into full-blown screams and yells.
With the Baylor Bears falling to a 4-4 and a losing record in Big 12 play after a blowout loss at Cincinnati, all preseason expectations have officially gone up in smoke. Even Dave Aranda seems to know it.
Three months ago, friend of the site Shehan Jeyarajah said in our preseason podcast that the expectation should be for Baylor to win somewhere between eight and 10 wins, in the hunt for a Big 12 championship appearance and a potential playoff spot.
Fast forward to today, and the Bears find themselves in a dogfight just to get to a bowl game, with a previously Heisman-contending quarterback having regressed, and the defense having given up 40 points for their second game in a row.
Following the game, a wave of fans on social media let it be known that they are ready for the end of the Dave Aranda era in Baylor.
Dave needs to be fired by noon tomorrow.
— Stanbino (@stanbino7) October 25, 2025
Dave Aranda is a very nice guy. It’s time for change. https://t.co/gS6gIb7wuT
— Kendall (@kendallkaut) October 25, 2025
A not-so-small contingent of fans think it shouldn’t stop there, lamenting Baylor athletic director for the current middling state of the football program:
Firing Dave Aranda isn’t enough.
— Zachary Miller (@_ZacharyMiller) October 25, 2025
Mack Rhoades needs to be fired, too. The decline of Baylor football is on him.
I’ve had some time to think about this.
— Oliver Mintz (Josh Allen and Baylor Enjoyer) (@olivermintz) October 26, 2025
While I do think Aranda needs to go, I think we have failed to address the main issue with this program: Mack Rhoades.
Others seemed to be turned off by a perception that Aranda has lost the locker room and players are no longer fighting for the sixth-year head coach:
It’s hard to blame @BUFootball fans for not supporting the team when it looks like the players don’t care about winning either.
— Trey Morris (@TreyMorris) October 25, 2025
They’ve quit on Dave.
It’s time for Aranda to go! #SicEm pic.twitter.com/JdIi6qC0iG
And the quit
— Brian Ethridge (@BE_SicEm365) October 25, 2025
However, if it’s one thing for fans to feel that way (it is short for fanatic for a reason). However, a recent article, titled “The Dave Aranda Era Has Run Its Course at Baylor, published in Dave Campbell’s Texas Football, one of the longest-running and well-respected publications in the state, could be tide-turning moment in the legitimacy of the argument to fire Aranda, and may signal the beginning of the end for the former LSU defensive coordinator.
It’s time in Waco https://t.co/PjqGiDcLm3
— Mike Craven (@CravenMike) October 26, 2025
Article author Mike Craven levies some pretty heavy criticism against Aranda, calling for Baylor to even make the change mid-season in the subheading of the piece, and coming to the conclusion with some evidence-based arguments:
“[Aranda’s] high was the 2021 season when he led the Bears to 12 wins and a Big 12 championship with a roster mostly left over from the Matt Rhule era.. Since that season, the Bears are 21-25 overall, and 14-19 against the Big 12. Three of his five full seasons have finished below .500”
Craven finishes off the article with the argument of a bleak present and an even bleaker future if the Bears continue along the current trend:
“What is the play if Rhoades & Co. decide to keep Aranda and run it back for Year 7?…How do you get a fan base to buy any hope in the future, especially if everything that’s made the last two seasons are no longer in Waco?...With in-state rivals like Texas Tech, TCU, and now Houston jumping to the from of the Big 12 line, the Bears must at now.”
Heavy criticism, but not any rooted in bias or untruthfulness. Only time will tell if Aranda will get the chance to change the narrative around his tenure to this point.
More must-reads:
+
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!