Getty Images

17 most memorable country music one-hit wonders

As the old saying goes, lightning only strikes in the same place once. That certainly seems to be true for some artists, who rise to fame quickly before being relegated to the annals of history. In the world of country music, there are plenty of these so-called "one-hit wonders," all of whom notched major success on the charts just once. 

Flip through the gallery for 17 of country's most memorable one-hit wonders, from '90s classics like "Should've Asked Her Faster" to temporarily forgotten favorites like "I Loved Her First" and "Don't Get Me Started." 

1 of 17

"Achy Breaky Heart," Billy Ray Cyrus

Ebet Roberts/Redferns

Even though Billy Ray Cyrus is a household name now, "Achy Breaky Heart" was his only #1 hit in the United States. The song arrived at the peak of the line dance craze and made Cyrus's famous mullet a punchline as it sold more than a million copies, earning a Platinum certification from the Recording Industry Association of America. 

2 of 17

"Harper Valley P.T.A.," Jeannie C. Riley

Keystone/Hulton Archive/Getty Images

"Harper Valley P.T.A." might be a legendary country song that inspired its own film, but it was the sole top-40 hit for Jeannie C. Riley. It was a major crossover success, but Riley never managed to replicate that magic again. 

3 of 17

"In Color," Jamey Johnson

Paul Natkin/Getty Images

Though he's a prolific songwriter who's written a slew of hits for artists like George Strait, bearded country outlaw Jamey Johnson's only had one top-ten hit of his own. Released in 2008, "In Color" was a massive success for Johnson, earning him Song of the Year at both the ACM Awards and the CMA Awards in 2009. 

4 of 17

"I Loved Her First," Heartland

Ethan Miller/ACMA/Getty Images for ACMA

Even if you don't remember the band Heartland, you very likely remember "I Loved Her First." Released in 2006, this tender song about the bond between a father and daughter remains a staple at wedding receptions. 

5 of 17

"Leave The Pieces," The Wreckers

Moses Robinson/WireImage for Philips Arena

The Wreckers, comprised of pop singers Michelle Branch and Jessica Harp, only released one full-length country album, 2006's "Stand Still, Look Pretty." That's a real shame because the song's lead single "Leave The Pieces" was a huge success, reaching #1 on the country charts and selling more than a million copies. 

6 of 17

"Nobody Knows," Kevin Sharp

Ron Wolfson /Getty Images

Released in 1996, Kevin Sharp's version of "Nobody Knows" appeared on his debut album, titled "Measure of a Man." It hit #1 in the United States and Canada, earning him an ACM Awards nomination for Top New Male Vocalist. Shortly after, Sharp began battling health issues that followed his childhood bout with a rare bone cancer. 

7 of 17

"Shut Up and Kiss Me," Mary Chapin Carpenter

William Campbell/Sygma via Getty Images

Even though this '90s country icon charted more than a dozen songs, Mary Chapin Carpenter only scored one #1 hit. 1994's "Shut Up And Kiss Me" was a massive success for Carpenter, earning her a Grammy Award in 1995 for Best Female Country Vocal Performance. 

8 of 17

"Don't Get Me Started," Rhett Akins

Tim Mosenfelder/Getty Images

Both a prolific songwriter and the father of current country star Thomas Rhett, Rhett Akins has only had one major hit as a solo artist. Called "Don't Get Me Started," the 1996 hit spent 21 weeks on the Billboard Hot Country Songs chart, including plenty of time at #1. 

9 of 17

"Single White Female," Chely Wright

Sherry Rayn Barnett /Michael Ochs Archives/Getty Images

It took four albums for Chely Wright to find the song that would finally really resonate with artists, and that arrived in 1999 with "Single White Female." The lead track from Wright's fourth full-length album, it remains her only #1 hit. 

10 of 17

"Break Down Here," Julie Roberts

Debra L Rothenberg/FilmMagic

In 2004, Julie Roberts scored her first and only #1 with "Break Down Here," a truly excellent pop-country ballad that boasts background vocals from Trisha Yearwood. 

11 of 17

"What I Really Meant to Say," Cyndi Thomson

Kevin Winter/Getty Images

Cyndi Thomson has released only one full-length album to date, 2001's "My World." That album was a huge success, largely thanks to "What I Really Meant to Say." The song peaked at #1, and remains a favorite among pop-country fans. 

12 of 17

"Pour Me," Trick Pony

Vince Bucci/Getty Images

Even though it only peaked at #12 on the Billboard Hot Country Songs chart, Trick Pony's "Pour Me" remains an iconic country drinking song, perfect for listening to in a honky-tonk. 

13 of 17

"Your Love Amazes Me," John Berry

Terry Wyatt/Getty Images for the Inspirational Country Music Awards

Despite his strong vocals and the enduring power of "Your Love Amazes Me," still a beloved country love song, John Berry has only notched this one #1 hit to date. 

14 of 17

"One Voice," Billy Gillman

KMazur/WireImage

In 2002, the clear tenor of 12-year-old Billy Gilman stopped country fans in their tracks as soon as they heard "One Voice." A touching song about children living in a world full of violence, Gilman earned a Grammy nomination and made him the youngest person in country music history to earn a spot on the Billboard charts. 

15 of 17

"Marie Laveau," Bobby Bare

kpa/United Archives via Getty Images

Bobby Bare notched a bunch of top-ten hits in the '70s, but only one, this Shel Silverstein-penned anthem about a Louisiana voodoo practitioner, hit #1 on the country charts. 

16 of 17

"Butterfly Kisses," Bob Carlisle

Amazon

This sweet little song about the love of a parent shot Bob Carlisle, a songwriter, and Christian singer, right to the top of the country charts in 1997. It was a crossover success, also landing at #1 on the Adult Contemporary Charts and earning a Grammy Award for Best Country Song.

17 of 17

"Should've Asked Her Faster," Ty England

Brigitte Engl/Redferns)

Formerly a guitarist for Garth Brooks, Ty England struck out on his own in 1995 with "Should've Asked Her Faster." The song hit #3 on the charts, marking England's biggest success to date. 

More must-reads:

TODAY'S BEST
The most influential movies ever made
20 period pieces you should watch
Longtime ‘SportsCenter’ anchor announces he is leaving ESPN
Second chances: Notable bands and musicians who experienced a career resurgence
The 25 most entertaining horror movies
The 20 concert tours you can't miss in 2024
20 albums turning 50 in 2024
The 20 greatest heist movies
20 movies that should be adapted into musicals
Super Bowl LVIII halftime show takeaways
Brad Pitt shades Eagles while praising Philly superfan Bradley Cooper
The 20 best modern rom-coms
20 performances that thwarted audience expectations
Comedy gold: 20 funny films that won an Oscar
23 actors that need to have a renaissance
The best karaoke songs from the 2020s
20 great movies that didn’t get nominated at the 2024 Oscars
The 25 best movies about high-school sports
The 23 best films of 2023
The 50 best albums of 2023