Jose Altuve has been one of the cornerstones of the Houston Astros’ golden era, but in 2025, the 35-year-old veteran is facing a reality check — not at the plate, but in the field. After nearly 1,750 starts at second base, Altuve was moved to left field this season in an effort to maximize the team’s flexibility. Over a month into the experiment, however, the numbers are not kind to the nine-time All-Star.
According to Baseball Savant, Altuve’s average throwing velocity from the outfield is just 79.1 mph — dead last among 92 qualified outfielders across Major League Baseball. For context, the average arm strength for left fielders sits at 87.2 mph. That eight mph gap has been glaring, especially as the Astros try to stay afloat in a crowded AL West.
The numbers only get more troubling from there. Altuve has posted a defensive WAR of -0.8 in 2025, dragging his total WAR to -0.6 on the season. For a player who has long been one of the most productive second basemen in the game, the steep decline on defense — both at second base last year and now in left — has become impossible to ignore.
The outfield may not be the best spot for Jose Altuve
Altuve acknowledged the position change during Spring Training, stating it was a team-first move in the wake of the trade that sent Kyle Tucker to the Cubs. “I want to help this team however I can,” he said at the time. While the gesture was admirable, the execution has left Houston fans and analysts scratching their heads.
Manager Joe Espada and the front office now face a dilemma. With Yordan Alvarez locked in at designated hitter and the outfield already thin, there aren’t many clear paths forward. Mauricio Dubón appears to be the most logical solution. The 2023 Gold Glove winner at utility had solid metrics in left field in 2024 and could easily slide back into that role.
Astros beat reporter Brian McTaggart recently noted that Altuve may start in left field only at Houston’s home park, Daikin Park, which features shorter dimensions. On the road, especially in spacious stadiums like Coors Field, Camden Yards, or Comerica Park, Houston could pivot to better defensive options.
Altuve’s declining range and arm strength are just the latest reminders that even franchise legends must adapt with age. As the Astros sit at 18-18 and third in the division, their margin for error is shrinking. A tough decision may be looming, especially if Houston wants to remain a contender in 2025.
Ultimately, Altuve’s willingness to switch positions speaks to his leadership — but the numbers are clear. If the Astros want to recapture their edge defensively, they may need to explore alternatives in left field sooner rather than later.
More must-reads: