Cardinals outfielder Tyler O’Neill is not in Wednesday's lineup, with Dylan Carlson taking his center field spot.
It appears as though this is relation to a play in Tuesday night’s game where O’Neill was thrown out at home while trying to score from second on a single by Brendan Donovan. Manager Oli Marmol is of the opinion that O’Neill wasn’t running with full effort on the play and spoke on the record about it Tuesday night and again Wednesday, as relayed by Derrick Goold of the St. Louis Post-Dispatch and Katie Woo of The Athletic.
“There is a standard,” Marmol said. “You meet it, you play. You don’t meet it, you don’t play. There’s going to be a style of play that we are known for. It’s going to involve effort and it’s going to involve being relentless. It’s going to involve being smart. We’re going to hold guys to that, because that’s how you sustain being good for a long time. There’s a lot of good players in that clubhouse, and down below, and I love competition. And the last thing you want to do when you’re in competition is open up a window.”
O’Neill doesn’t agree with Marmol’s view of the situation.
“I’m trying to do everything I can to stay on the field and give it my best effort,” O’Neill said. “I’ve never been known to be a dogger in any caliber. So for him to say that is very strong words.”
The outfielder also took exception to Marmol talking to the media about the situation.
“I don’t think it should’ve been handled that way,” O’Neill said. “I think if there’s internal issues they should be handled internally. We should have each others backs out there. Sometimes it doesn’t go that way I guess. Live and you learn.”
The club came into the season with a glut of outfielders, including O’Neill, Carlson, Jordan Walker, Lars Nootbaar, Alec Burleson and Juan Yepez. Nootbaar is currently on the injured list but there’s still plenty of guys for three spots, while Nolan Gorman has been the designated hitter most days so far this year.
Marmol’s comments suggest that his feelings about the play in question are strong enough that O’Neill is at risk of losing playing time beyond just Wednesday’s benching. Time will tell as to how it plays out, but O’Neill didn’t seem to have a good answer when asked how they will move past this. “I don’t know,” O’Neill said. “Continue with our communication. But really? I don’t know.”
O’Neill can be an excellent player when healthy, which he showed in 2021. He hit 34 home runs that year and slashed .286/.352/.560 for a wRC+ of 144. He also stole 15 bases and was given strong grades for his outfield defense, leading to a tally of 5.6 wins above replacement by FanGraphs. Last year, injuries limited him to 96 games and he wasn’t as impactful while on the field. He’s making $4.95M this year and can be controlled via arbitration in 2024 before he’s slated to reach free agency.
More must-reads: