May 5, 2025; Boston, Massachusetts, USA; New York Knicks head coach Tom Thibodeau watches from the sideline as they take on the Boston Celtics during game one of the second round for the 2025 NBA Playoffs at TD Garden. Mandatory Credit: David Butler II-Imagn Images David Butler II-Imagn Images

The New York Knicks knew that they'd be at a disadvantage in lineup flexibility before these Eastern Conference Finals even got going.

Not only had the Indiana Pacers gotten this far through an abnormally deep rotation that consistently utilized double-digit contributors deep into meaningful games, but the Knicks were as starter-reliant as any remaining playoff team. Knicks coach Tom Thibodeau has built a reputation off of loading up the plates of his key players, with newly-announced Second Team All-NBA member Jalen Brunson relied on to carry his team in the clutch more than anyone.

Thibodeau opted to save Brunson for crunch time, leaving in backup point guard Cameron Payne to start the fourth quarter. The Pacers saw an opportunity and pounced, leaping out ahead and seizing a lead they'd never relinquish. In a sick twist, they delivered the same blow that the Knicks themselves gave in Game 1, only the Pacers never blew the lead they built.

Everyone watched in collective confusion alongside Brunson as the Pacers continued pulling ahead, and that included former NBA players with experience playing against Thibodeau.

Isaiah Thomas, the former Boston Celtics star and one-time MVP candidate, took a shot at Thibodeau after his famously unwavering approach betrayed him in the clutch.

Former All-Star-turned-journeyman Thomas isn't wrong in pointing out how consistently Thibodeau's teams fall short; whether or not it's his fault, this is his first time back to the conference finals in nearly a decade and a half, despite having a lead coaching job across nearly that entire span.

The Pacers went on to win, 114-109, giving them a 2-0 lead in the series. They're heading back to Indiana's Gainbridge Fieldhouse with a chance to close the series out on its home court, and Thibodeau's going to have to hear how he dropped the ball until his Knicks wrest some kind of control back in this series.

More must-reads:

TODAY'S BEST
Kentucky men's basketball makes huge announcement about key player
Commanders, Dan Quinn setting the tone on Day 1 of OTAs: 'We are always the hunters'
Browns' Joe Flacco, Kenny Pickett open up about four-way QB competition
Charlie Woods follows in dad's footsteps with first junior win
Giants teammates offer high praise for Russell Wilson amid OTAs
Raiders appear to have contract dispute with promising WR
Mammoth stay busy, ink another former first-round pick to entry-level contract
Mammoth sign former No. 6 overall pick to entry-level contract
Oilers' Zach Hyman out for Game 5, unlikely to return in series
Paige Bueckers makes history with impressive start to WNBA career
Steelers Hall of Famer rips team over Aaron Rodgers interest
Three takeaways from Knicks-Pacers Game 4: Tyrese Haliburton makes history in win
Stars-Oilers takeaways: Edmonton on verge of return to Stanley Cup FinalĀ 
Watch: Phillies' Bryce Harper leaves game after taking fastball to elbow
Bills' high-profile offseason addition suffers calf injury
Coco Gauff racket mishap proves to be no problem in opening match at French Open
Canadiens goalie leaves North America to sign massive five-year deal
WNBA releases findings of investigation of alleged racist comments directed at Angel Reese
Cubs star Kyle Tucker sends seven-word message after $600 million news
Bruins reportedly shopping top forward in potential offseason shake-up

Want more sports news?

Join the hundreds of thousands of fans who start their day with Yardbarker's Morning Bark, the best newsletter in sports.