May 13, 2025; Cleveland, Ohio, USA; Indiana Pacers forward Aaron Nesmith (23) and guard Tyrese Haliburton (0) celebrate during the second half of game five against the Cleveland Cavaliers in the second round for the 2025 NBA Playoffs at Rocket Arena. Mandatory Credit: Ken Blaze-Imagn Images Ken Blaze-Imagn Images

On Wednesday night, the Indiana Pacers improbably rallied to snag a shocking comeback victory for a third time in their postseason. It's gotten to be such a habit, it probably shouldn't be quite so shocking at this point.

Trailing the New York Knicks, in New York, by 14 points at the 2:51 mark of regulation (119-105), Indiana mounted an insane rally.

More Indiana Pacers News: Pacers' Historic Game 1 Win May Prove Team of Destiny Claims

A flurry of heat-check Aaron Nesmith treys and one Tyrese Haliburton buzzer-beating long two clinched the comeback, sending the contest into overtime.

Indiana had outscored the Knicks 20-6 in those final 2:51 of regulation to tie the game.

Indiana ultimately outlasted the Knicks in the bonus period, winning by a single possession, 138-135.

All of the Pacers' starters scored 14 or more points. Haliburton notched a 31-point, 11-assist double-double in the victory. Nesmith scored 30 points (20 in the fourth quarter alone) while shooting 9-of-13 from the field (8-of-9 from long range).

Ex-Knicks power forward Obi Toppin, shining in a reserve role for Indiana, pulled down a team-high 10 rebounds in just 19:36 of action, while scoring eight points.

More Indiana Pacers News: Pacers' Rick Carlisle Talks Major Challenges Knicks Present

According to Ben Golliver of The Washington Post, Indiana beat near-impossible odds to rally against New York late.

Golliver reports that New York boasted a 99.7 percent win percentage with the aforementioned 14-point lead at the 2:51 mark.

But there was no stopping a resilient Indiana squad — especially when nervous Knicks players kept splitting their free throws, and the team seemingly forgot to defend anyone down the stretch.

More Indiana Pacers News: NBA World Reacts to Pacers Epic Game 1 Comeback Win

Now, with the Pacers having stolen homecourt advantage from New York, Indiana will look to nab a second straight road victory at Madison Square Garden on Friday.

The Knicks are formidable foes. This could prove to be a tougher series than the Pacers' second round matchup against a very banged-up Cleveland Cavaliers club, and New York has a . But Indiana has shown a real knack for beating the odds in these playoffs.

More Indiana Pacers News: 

Pacers' Rick Carlisle Talks Major Challenges Knicks Present

Gilbert Arenas Takes Major Shot at Pacers Star Amid Playoffs

Pacers vs Knicks Playoff History: Who Has the Upper Hand?

Pacers Legend to Call Eastern Conference Finals Games vs Knicks

For more news and notes on the Indiana Pacers, visit Indiana Pacers on SI.


More must-reads:

TODAY'S BEST
Timberwolves' Anthony Edwards puts on a show in Game 3 win over Thunder
Hurricanes-Panthers takeaways: Florida pushes Carolina to brink with dominant Game 3
Maple Leafs' Mitch Marner reportedly rules out six teams in free agency
Watch: Absurd Caitlin Clark three gives Fever distance over Liberty in early showdown
Report: Steelers eyeing notable QB as they wait for Aaron Rodgers
Ross Chastain has 'no idea' what to expect ahead of Coca-Cola 600
Royals acquire infielder in trade with Mets
Josh Hart shares one change he wants Knicks to make in Game 3
Jordan Love has three-word response to Olympic flag football question
Notable update emerges about Dodgers' Shohei Ohtani
Rafael Devers saga in Boston could take another interesting turn
Ex-NFL player makes worrisome prediction about Bears' Caleb Williams after book controversy
Pascal Siakam carries Pacers to Game 2 win over Knicks
Oilers-Stars takeaways: Unexpected heroes help Edmonton get even
2024-25 All-NBA teams feature Shai Gilgeous-Alexander, other stars
Former Steelers safety doesn't hold back on Aaron Rodgers saga
Kevin Stefanski details Browns' four-way QB competition
Duke adds top international prospect to stacked recruiting class
49ers' Brock Purdy addresses his critics after signing extension
Red Sox announce trade with Angels after Rafael Devers news

Want more sports news?

Join the hundreds of thousands of fans who start their day with Yardbarker's Morning Bark, the best newsletter in sports.