© Jenna Watson/IndyStar / USA TODAY NETWORK

A night that will live in the minds of Indianapolis Colts fans for years to come is the day former quarterback Andrew Luck retired from football.

In a recent interview on The Trenches Show with Colts linebackers Zaire Franklin and E.J. Speed, former Indy wide receiver T.Y. Hilton shared unknown details of Luck's retirement in 2019.

The Trenches Show posted on X: “If you didn’t send him off that way, you might’ve gotten another luck sighting”

Franklin kicked off with a question to Hilton, "What was it just like to see him get that send off?"

Franklin was referring to the Indy crowd booing the former No.1 overall pick after the news broke of his decision to hang up the cleats on his career.

Hilton replied, "It hurt, and I know it hurt him." Hilton continued by saying, "Indy shouldn't have did that."

The Colts legendary pass-catcher concluded with the quote that has been talked about by many Colts fans over the past 36 hours.

"I'm just gonna be honest, bro. If they wouldn't have did that, probably would've had a Luck sighting, and that's what's gonna hurt them even more."

Luck's injuries had taken a toll on the franchise QB. All of this culminated in his decision to dismiss himself from the NFL. Even nearly five years later, Luck's retirement lives on in the minds of not just Colts fans, but also current and former players like Hilton.

There is also a question of Hilton hinting that Luck possibly wanted to return to football that year or later. But, the treatment he received from the fans he played for years for deterred him.

Hilton mentioned that Luck deserves to be in the Colts Ring of Honor. The question is, will he want to return if he's given this franchise accolade after the negative treatment he received from fans? 

There's no doubt he should have the distinction, as through six seasons played in Indianapolis, Luck finished with a 53-33 record, 23,671 pass yards, 171 passing touchdowns, and 14 rushing scores. His career more than warrants his name to be etched in Lucas Oil Stadium. 

Sadly, nobody will ever know the hard details unless Luck speaks out on the situation. With how quiet the former four-time Pro Bowler has been since 2019, it's hard to say at this moment.

Fast forward to 2024, and Indy has a new franchise QB in Anthony Richardson and a bright leader in head coach Shane Steichen.

Regardless of the successes that may or may not come, the Luck retirement won't go away anytime soon. Yet again, the "what if" on Luck's career has resurfaced after this information divulging from Hilton. 

More must-reads:

TODAY'S BEST
Canucks won't have linchpin forward for Game 7 vs. Oilers
Pacers ride historic shooting performance to Game 7 blowout of Knicks
Watch: Aaron Judge blasts 13th home run in Yankees' seventh straight win
Knicks' Jalen Brunson suffers serious injury in Game 7 vs. Pacers
Phil Foden lifts Manchester City to fourth consecutive English Premier League title
Dodgers add recently acquired left-hander to active roster
Report: 2023 No. 7 pick expected to terminate KHL contract, join Flyers
Mavericks advance to Western Conference Finals aided by controversial call late
Connor McDavid, Oilers hammer Canucks to force Game 7
Tyson Fury-Oleksandr Usyk epic increases excitement for potential rematch
Seize the Grey wins in muddy Preakness
Even Mike Budenholzer admits the Suns need a point guard
Watch: Juan Soto's first multi-homer game as a Yankee
Xander Schauffele, Collin Morikawa lead at PGA Championship
Knicks could get major boost for Game 7 showdown with Pacers
Giants All-Star pitcher suffers setback in recovery from injury
Panthers star named winner of 2024 Selke Trophy
WNBA to investigate $100,000 sponsorship deals for Aces players
Tiger Woods blames one big factor for missing the cut at PGA Championship
'Ain't good enough': Draymond Green claims Celtics must 'win it all' or it's a 'failure'

Want more Colts news?

Join the hundreds of thousands of fans who start their day with Yardbarker's Morning Bark, the best newsletter in sports.