Michigan QB J.J. McCarthy Rick Osentoski-USA TODAY Sports

Michigan QB J.J. McCarthy falls out of top 10 in new mock draft

Perhaps the hype surrounding Michigan quarterback J.J. McCarthy is all smoke and mirrors.

In his latest mock draft, Matt Miller of ESPN asked scouts to make the top 10 picks of the NFL Draft. None of them selected McCarthy. 

"This was a chance to learn a lot about how evaluators truly see this class and how pressure to fill needs — especially at quarterback — influences what general managers will do," wrote Miller. "However, it's notable that none of our [scouts] drafted McCarthy, who is ranked No. 19 on my board but is also widely expected to be drafted in the top six."

It's worth noting that there were no trades in Miller's mock since scouts were anonymous and couldn't collaborate. QB-needy teams, such as the Denver Broncos (No. 12), Las Vegas Raiders (No. 13) and Minnesota Vikings (No. 11), may move up for the national champion.

Offering another opinion, ESPN's Adam Schefter believes McCarthy won't slide on draft day and could still be one of the first three players off the board.

"Well, I think he's jumping up draft boards," Schefter told Brad Galli of WXYZ-TV in Detroit. "I think he's going to be picked somewhere between two or three or 11 and 12, somewhere in that range, and he's going to be a first-round pick." 

The Commanders – who have the second overall pick – are showing interest in McCarthy. Per Sports Illustrated's Albert Breer, Washington hosted McCarthy and fellow quarterback prospects Drake Maye (North Carolina), Jayden Daniels (LSU) and Michael Penix Jr. (Washington) on Tuesday. 

Regardless, it's interesting none of the scouts took McCarthy. While his stock has soared during the draft process, his numbers in 2023 didn't wow. In 15 games, he completed 72.3% of his passes for 22 TDs, four interceptions and a 167.4 passer rating. 

Still, teams will take a risk if they don't have an answer at the most important position. With that in mind, don't be surprised if McCarthy is a top-10 pick.  

More must-reads:

TODAY'S BEST
Bengals star WR not expected to sign franchise tender before OTAs
Red Sox RHP diagnosed with ligament damage in elbow
Watch: Caitlin Clark shows off range with logo three, but Fever fall short
Former Dolphins receiving leader announces his retirement from NFL
Detroit Lions dominate PFF's top-25 players under 25
Hall of Famer, legendary Raiders offensive lineman dead at 86
Report: Cavs owner 'would never' trade Donovan Mitchell to this team
Kim Mulkey adds legendary LSU alum to coaching staff
Insider details LeBron James' role in Lakers' head-coaching search
Cardinals switch up offensive line, move 2023 first-rounder to new position
Commanders poach another key overseer of Lions rebuild
Commanders to hire veteran executive as player personnel director
Guardians designate outfielder for assignment
Patriots' Drake Maye starts OTAs in surprising position
Bettors are buying Bronny James hype before the 2024 NBA Draft
Mets release veteran infielder
Anderson Silva, Chael Sonnen will finish off their trilogy in a boxing ring
Victor Wembanyama, Chet Holmgren highlight 2023-24 All-Rookie team
Jaguars' Doug Pederson discusses Trevor Lawrence contract extension
Saints, star CB 'moving forward' following trade chatter