Jamie Germano / USA TODAY NETWORK

The Buffalo Bills shocked the NFL world when they said goodbye to Stefon Diggs and Gabe Davis. The turnover at wide receiver has lowered some expectations for fans, but perhaps none lower than NFL analyst Craig Carton.

Speaking on Wednesday’s edition of “The Carton Show,” Carton braced for a return of the moribund version of the franchise that struggled throughout the Tom Brady era.

“I can’t figure out how anybody thinks the Buffalo Bills are going to be an above .500 team this year,” Carton said.

Many believe that the Bills are set for a long season this year without Diggs and Davis.

The playoffs might be a dream for Buffalo if Carton’s expectations come true. The vast majority of teams that make the playoffs do so after an above .500 campaign. If the Bills fall even one game lower, they will be in trouble.

2024 marks make-or-break season for Josh Allen

Patrick Mahomes saw his greatest weapon taken away in the form of Tyreek Hill. The Super Bowl winner appears to be doing more than just fine. Now, with Josh Allen also no longer able to use Diggs or Davis, the operation will fall even more on Allen’s shoulders, much like it did Mahomes after the Kansas City Chiefs traded Hill.

Allen has had his fair share of struggles in the past, so it remains to be seen how he manages without Diggs and Davis in 2024.

Allen’s performance without his two top receivers will reveal a lot. If he succeeds without his two biggest targets, it will prove himself as the driver of the team’s success to this point. That said, if the team hits a wall this season, it will be clear that he has been propped up with his surrounding talent.

Whatever happens this season could set an expiration date on the quarterback’s future. It could come on the doorstep of the 2040s or as soon as his current contract expires.

Even if Allen bounces back in 2025, the quarterback will have played his hand as rookie Keon Coleman and the other young players could be credited for his success.

When they don’t receive support, the best quarterbacks manage to tread water.

Will Allen prove to be the beating heart of the team or merely the representative of it?

More must-reads:

TODAY'S BEST
Watch: Jets eliminate Blues in instant classic double OT Game 7 win
Buddy Hield lifts Warriors to massive Game 7 win over Rockets
Pacers use balanced attack vs. Cavaliers to steal home-court advantage
Fever's Caitlin Clark dazzles in preseason debut vs. Brazil
Scottie Scheffler wins CJ Cup Byron Nelson in historic fashion
Former World No. 1 Naomi Osaka wins first tournament in four years
Watch: Giants' Willy Adames catches fire vs. Rockies
Joey Logano wins wild Wurth 400 at Texas in NASCAR overtime 
Why did Browns take Dillon Gabriel before Shedeur Sanders in draft and how could it affect their QB competition?
Celtics' Kristaps Porzingis reacts to facing Knicks in playoffs
Jalen Ramsey linked to notable NFC team
Why Bayern Munich's 33rd Bundesliga title should be even sweeter for Harry Kane
Chiefs sign first-round pick OT Josh Simmons to rookie deal
Rangers make coaching-staff shakeup amid offensive struggles
Troubling report emerges about Texans WR Tank Dell's knee injury
Key Blues defenseman to miss Game 7 vs. Jets
Wild’s Joel Eriksson Ek to undergo core muscle surgery
'It makes sense': Steelers see new Aaron Rodgers conspiracy theory emerge as team waits for 2025 decision
Jets offer key injury updates ahead of Game 7
Bill Belichick reportedly considering big career move

Want more Bills news?

Join the hundreds of thousands of fans who start their day with Yardbarker's Morning Bark, the best newsletter in sports.