Former NFL quarterback Peyton Manning. Barbara J. Perenic/Columbus Dispatch / USA TODAY NETWORK

Peyton Manning and Shannon Sharpe question Broncos' decision to go for game-winning 64-yard FG

Penalties, fumbles and a questionable field goal attempt cost the Broncos a victory in Russell Wilson’s return to Seattle. 

Denver had an opportunity to win the game in the closing moments of the 4th quarter. However, rather than letting Wilson drive the Broncos farther downfield, rookie head coach Nathaniel Hackett decided to run the clock down and attempt a 64 yard field goal; kicker Brandon McManus missed the kick with 15 seconds left.

“I thought he had plenty of distance on that one and we were gonna be able to make that,” Hackett said in a Monday news conference after the game. “If we have to put him in that situation again, I think he’ll be able to make it.” 

If McManus made the kick it would’ve been the second longest in NFL history, his career long was 61 yards, so it was a big ask. The Broncos had three time outs, running the clock down and not relying on Wilson to make one more play on fourth-and-5, puzzled former Broncos.

“If I’m paying 200-plus million for a QB, I’m not trotting my kicker out to kick a 64 yard field goal,” said Hall of Famer Shannon Sharpe on Twitter. 

ESPN’s Adam Schefter also tweeted fellow Hall of Famer Peyton Manning pleading the Broncos to call a timeout and run one more play, during Monday’s Manning cast on ESPN2.

How the Broncos fell into this situation is equally concerning.  

The Broncos left 14 possible points on the board, running backs Melvin Gordon III and Javonte Williams both fumbled near the goal line on consecutive drives. The 14-point swing can’t be understated, if the Broncos scored on both of these opportunities, they would’ve taken a 27-17 lead heading into the 4th quarter. 

The Broncos were penalized 12 times for 106 yards, extending Seattle drives and stalling their own.

More must-reads:

TODAY'S BEST
Hurricanes' power play finally comes through with season on the line
Watch: An outstanding first half by Donovan Mitchell keeps the Cavaliers alive in Game 3 vs. Celtics
Mavericks come from behind to down Thunder, take 2-1 series lead
Tigers lose veteran starting pitcher to injury
Justin Allgaier dominates at Darlington for first win of 2024
Watch: Minor league baseball game interrupted by turtle delay
Rangers ace continues to be plagued by nerve irritation in thumb
Cowboys hint at timeline for extension talks with offensive star
Steelers first-round pick has already 'apologized' to new locker mate
Former Packers WR makes bold prediction about Jordan Love
Watch: Paul Skenes wastes no time showing why Pirates drafted him No. 1 overall
Broncos release former Super Bowl champion WR
Nationals had 'substantive discussions' with former top prospect about extension
Patriots make unsurprising decision on top executive
Cowboys release veteran WR
Longtime Steelers DT Cameron Heyward hints contract extension is coming
'Great mind': One-time NBA champion endorses candidate for Lakers HC job
Jrue Holiday jokes about beating departing Celtics assistant who just landed Hornets job
Orioles manager explains Craig Kimbrel's new role
Rays activate key bullpen arm from injured list