South Carolina Gamecocks wide receiver Xavier Legette. Jeff Blake-USA TODAY Sports

Scout's view: The top receiver in the NFL Draft isn't who you think

Daniel Kelly spent four years in pro scouting with the New York Jets. He is the published author of the book "Whatever It Takes," the story of a fan making it into the NFL.

Believe it or not, Ohio State wide receiver Marvin Harrison Jr. did not make the cut for my top three receivers in the 2024 NFL Draft. On game film, the consensus top receiver didn't blow me away with his effort — he's still a first-round draft pick, but he reminds me more of former Jets/Buccaneers/Cowboys/Panthers wideout Keyshawn Johnson, an above-average pro, than Pro Football Hall of Famer Randy Moss. 

Here's what I look for in receivers for the player to transition smoothly from college to the NFL:

  • Quick release
  • Ability to gain "route leverage"  — positional advantage versus cornerbacks
  • Running well-defined routes
  • Long-range speed and burst of speed in short areas
  • Fluid hips, allowing quick and sudden changes of direction
  • Good focus and concentration 
  • Dependable hands 
  • Large catch radius
  • Desire shown on contested catches
  • YAC (yards after catch) 
  • Toughness factor
  • Does he make it look easy? 
  • Does he remind you of the greats? 
  • Run- and pass-blocking willingness

With that in mind, here are my top three receivers in the 2024 NFL Draft, set for April 25-27 in Detroit. 

1. Xavier Legette, South Carolina, 6-foot-3, 227 pounds

This Gamecocks receiver conjures memories of how Pro Football Hall of Fame wide receiver Art Monk — the former Washington star — ran his routes. (Monk, by the way, finished his 16-year career with 12,721 yards receiving and 68 TD catches.)

Legette — who has an impressive, muscular frame — is an instinctual long strider who glides into secondaries. As South Carolina QB Spencer Rattler's No. 1 receiver, he produced a breakout 2023 season with 71 catches for 1,255 yards and seven touchdown catches.

Legette's sudden and spontaneous moves win initial route leverage against corners and then he wins again at route breakpoints. On film, he shows off aggressiveness and physicality and isn't hesitant to mix it up with defensive backs.

Legette is the best in this draft class at "Mossin'" defenders — that is acrobatically outjumping corners for passes and coming down with circus catches. Legette isn't the next Moss, but he is darn good. He can go deep or sell the deep route well before settling back underneath and making those vitally important chain-moving intermediate-level receptions (11-19 yards)

This guy commands the respect of defenses. 

2. Adonai Mitchell, Texas, 6-foot-4, 196 pounds 

Mitchell is a clone of Dallas Cowboys receiver CeeDee Lamb. He's explosive and the most exciting receiver in this draft. 

In 2023, this Longhorn (55 catches, 845 yards, 11 TDs in 2023) showed the capability of masterfully setting up corners and consistently leaving them a step behind. He has the rare combination teams look for in size, dangerous speed and fluid hips, which allow him to make crisp changes of direction. 

Additionally, Mitchell shows that coveted short-area burst going into and coming out of breaks, which only further opens the throwing window for his QB. "Unpredictable" and "bendy" are apt descriptions for him, but his YAC — yards after the catch — is just decent, not great. 

The bottom line is corners must honor his deep game, which allows him to drive them off before coming back underneath at the intermediate route level and making catches.

Mitchell — who had big moments at Georgia before transferring to Texas — is a bit unpolished in his route running and so-so on contested catches. He must attack the ball the same way he drives into secondaries.

However, even "as is," Mitchell tends to draw pass-interference flags in his favor with his strong alpha demeanor. I'm confident an experienced NFL receivers coach will enhance his game.  

3. Malik Nabers, LSU, 6-foot, 200 pounds

Nabers is inconsistent on game film — his undisciplined route running and lack of stellar ability to secure 50-50 balls are correctable issues — but he has devastating speed and acceleration to blow you away. This dude explodes into secondaries. 

Nabers — who had 89 catches for 1,569 yards and 14 TDs last season — is an artist when it comes to making double moves that flat-out leave corners in the dust. Plus, he has a nasty change of direction on routes featuring breakpoints. He uses his frame nicely to box out defenders when it's time to make the catch. 

The biggest knock I have on Nabers is he occasionally loses focus and interest. However, the good far outweighs the bad. He is the perfect pick for a team looking to add an explosive, game-breaking receiver who's main zip code is the deep-route levels of the field (20+ yards), where Nabers is most dangerous. An accurate QB will help him.

More must-reads:

TODAY'S BEST
Timberwolves' Anthony Edwards puts on a show in Game 3 win over Thunder
Hurricanes-Panthers takeaways: Florida pushes Carolina to brink with dominant Game 3
Maple Leafs' Mitch Marner reportedly rules out six teams in free agency
Watch: Absurd Caitlin Clark three gives Fever distance over Liberty in early showdown
Report: Steelers eyeing notable QB as they wait for Aaron Rodgers
Ross Chastain has 'no idea' what to expect ahead of Coca-Cola 600
Royals acquire infielder in trade with Mets
Josh Hart shares one change he wants Knicks to make in Game 3
Jordan Love has three-word response to Olympic flag football question
Notable update emerges about Dodgers' Shohei Ohtani
Rafael Devers saga in Boston could take another interesting turn
Ex-NFL player makes worrisome prediction about Bears' Caleb Williams after book controversy
Pascal Siakam carries Pacers to Game 2 win over Knicks
Oilers-Stars takeaways: Unexpected heroes help Edmonton get even
2024-25 All-NBA teams feature Shai Gilgeous-Alexander, other stars
Former Steelers safety doesn't hold back on Aaron Rodgers saga
Kevin Stefanski details Browns' four-way QB competition
Duke adds top international prospect to stacked recruiting class
49ers' Brock Purdy addresses his critics after signing extension
Red Sox announce trade with Angels after Rafael Devers news