Dan Hamilton-USA TODAY Sports

In the midst of the NHL preseason, defenseman Conor Timmins is making waves and giving the Toronto Maple Leafs management plenty to ponder. Timmins, a promising prospect, has been dazzling fans and his own team with standout performances, challenging initial expectations for his role.

The highlight of Timmins’ preseason spectacle was undoubtedly his four-point display (2 goals, 2 assists) during the Kraft Hockeyville event, where he earned the first-star honors in front of an enthusiastic West Lorne crowd. This exceptional performance propelled his preseason point total to an impressive six points in just two games.

Timmins’ on-ice prowess hasn’t gone unnoticed by his teammates. Max Domi praised Timmins for his remarkable skills, especially his pinpoint pass that set up a breakaway opportunity. Sam Lafferty, equally impressed, described Timmins’ performance as “unbelievable” and a pleasure to watch, emphasizing the young defenseman’s standout abilities.

As Timmins continues to light up the preseason, the Maple Leafs management faces a dilemma. One option is to keep him on the roster for the regular season, recognizing his potential and offensive prowess. However, a riskier alternative involves placing Timmins on waivers, hoping that he goes unclaimed and can be assigned to the AHL. This second option, as some fans and analysts have expressed, carries uncertainty and hesitation, especially when you factor in how he’s played of late.

Will Klingberg’s Injury Open a Door for Timmins?

Timmins, initially acquired as a pending restricted free agent, signed a two-year extension with a $1.1 million cap hit under former GM Kyle Dubas. He’s been mostly an extra and a practice player for the Leafs since signing. Now, with Timmins no longer exempt from waivers, the Maple Leafs may have a difficult choice to make.

While unfortunate, news that something might be bothering John Klingberg potentially gives the Leafs a bit more time. It was said that something “tightened up” on Klingberg so he was pulled from the game. Timmins has already seized an opportunity once. Will he do so again?

As head coach Sheldon Keefe revealed, Klingberg’s early exit from an exhibition game was precautionary, but the extent of the injury remains uncertain, adding an extra layer of complexity to the Maple Leafs’ defensive decisions.

More must-reads:

TODAY'S BEST
Report: Cavs owner 'would never' trade Donovan Mitchell to this team
Kim Mulkey adds legendary LSU alum to coaching staff
Insider details LeBron James' role in Lakers' head-coaching search
Cardinals switch up offensive line, move 2023 first-rounder to new position
Commanders poach another key overseer of Lions rebuild
Commanders to hire veteran executive as player personnel director
Guardians designate outfielder for assignment
Patriots' Drake Maye starts OTAs in surprising position
Bettors are buying Bronny James hype before the 2024 NBA Draft
Mets release veteran infielder
Anderson Silva, Chael Sonnen will finish off their trilogy in a boxing ring
Victor Wembanyama, Chet Holmgren highlight 2023-24 All-Rookie team
Jaguars' Doug Pederson discusses Trevor Lawrence contract extension
Saints, star CB 'moving forward' following trade chatter
Pacers ride historic shooting performance to Game 7 blowout of Knicks
Timberwolves mount incredible second-half comeback to stun Nuggets in Game 7
Xander Schauffele proves doubters wrong with historic win at 2024 PGA Championship
Four things we learned from Joey Logano's All-Star Race win at North Wilkesboro
Phil Foden lifts Manchester City to fourth consecutive English Premier League title
Watch: Aaron Judge blasts 13th home run in Yankees' seventh straight win

Want more sports news?

Join the hundreds of thousands of fans who start their day with Yardbarker's Morning Bark, the best newsletter in sports.