Ed Mulholland-USA TODAY Sports

Last night, ironically, the Toronto Maple Leafs might have played their best first period of the season AND their worst game of the season both on the same night. The result was a disappointing 6-3 loss to the New Jersey Devils at Scotiabank Arena.

Interestingly, the Maple Leafs opened the game playing lights-out hockey. The team dominated the first period with a barrage of shots on Devils’ goalie Jake Allen. Yet, when the horn sounded to end the period, the Maple Leafs found themselves trailing the Devils by a score of 2-1. The Devils capitalized on the Maple Leafs’ large number of defensive lapses and costly mistakes.

The only two bits of good news were that Auston Matthews scored his NHL-leading 59th goal and William Nylander continued his scoring with his 40th goal of the season. Otherwise, the Maple Leafs couldn’t overcome their lack of discipline and defensive gaffs.

Too Many Bad Things Happened to Allow the Maple Leafs to Win

The Maple Leafs’ defeat can be attributed to several key factors. First, defensive errors plagued the team throughout the game, allowing the Devils to capitalize on their fewer scoring opportunities.

Second, a lack of discipline and composure further hindered the Maple Leafs’ performance. Maple Leafs head coach Sheldon Keefe made that very clear after the game. As he noted, his team lacked maturity and leadership on the ice.

Last, goalie Joseph Woll struggled to contain the Devils’ offence. As good as he was against the Hurricanes in his last start, he wasn’t that strong last night. He gave up five goals on 24 shots.

Speaking specifically about Woll, he struggled to stop the Devils’ offensive onslaught. New Jersey mainly scored on rushes; and, a few simply got past Woll. In the end, he yielded five goals.

His play highlighted the uncertainty surrounding the Maple Leafs’ goaltending situation heading into the playoffs. With the postseason coming in a month, Toronto must address its goaltending situation if the team is to bolster its chances of success.

Keefe Was Even More Animated than Usual

This season, fans have seen a different side of head coach Keefe. He’s been more animated and willing to be critical. Last night, following the disappointing loss, he admonished his team for its immature play and lack of focus. He was right and called a spade a spade. Even even called out captain John Tavares, which doesn’t happen often. It was that frustrating a game for the coaching staff.

As the Maple Leafs strive to secure a playoff berth, they must fix their defensive deficiencies and maintain discipline in the season’s remaining games. With critical matchups on the horizon, Toronto’s ability to rebound from adversity will be a key to its postseason aspirations.

More must-reads:

TODAY'S BEST
Celtics dominate short-handed Cavaliers in blowout Game 1 win
Rangers special teams, goaltending help them take control against Hurricanes
Knicks share brutal injury news on Mitchell Robinson
Titans put Treylon Burks on notice with latest free-agent addition
Rudy Gobert's Defensive Player of the Year award redeems reputation of darkness retreats
LIV Golf scores major win ahead of PGA Championship
Astros GM makes revealing comments about team's trade-deadline strategy amid poor start
Watch: Overtime goal completes Avalanche's comeback in 4-3 win over Stars
Thunder’s three-point barrage takes down Mavericks in Game 1
Legendary Broncos DC Joe Collier dead at 91
Watch: Phillies' Bryce Harper stays hot with another grand slam
Cardinals' Willson Contreras suffers broken arm after being hit by swing
Nuggets star gets fined, but avoids suspension for ugly Game 2 actions
PSG superstar to potentially depart club with zero UEFA Champions League trophies
NFL has a reported date for the 2024 schedule release
Lions sign veteran defensive tackle
Sharks win 2024 NHL Draft Lottery, get No. 1 pick for first time
John Calipari recruiting another top player from Kentucky
Giants designate right-hander for assignment
Former All-Star shares concerns of potential Knicks burnout

Want more NHL news?

Join the hundreds of thousands of fans who start their day with Yardbarker's Morning Bark, the best newsletter in sports.