The New York Yankees are most likely going to find themselves in the playoffs this season. But even if they do, they have some serious potential flaws that are going to limit their ceiling. All of those flaws were on display on Friday night in their return from the All-Star break.
Those flaws not only include pitching depth issues in the starting rotation and bullpen, but also the same sort of fundamental issues that plagued the Yankees throughout the 2024 season and ultimately helped burn them in the World Series.
The Yankees are already dealing with starting pitcher injuries that have taken Gerrit Cole, Luis Gil and Clarke Schmidt out of their rotation, but they have also not had a consistently effective bullpen. Both of those issues met head-on on Friday as they opened the second half with a bullpen game that produced a 7-3 loss to the Atlanta Braves.
They clearly need to add some serious pitching help before the July 31 deadline.
But even that might not be enough if they do not clean up some of the fundamental issues the rest of the roster has.
While those issues are typically related to their play in the field, they surfaced on Friday night on the base paths when third baseman Jorbit Vivas was thrown out at third base on a play that should have easily resulted in him moving up 90 feet.
"That can't happen. Those are little things that cost you a chance to have Aaron Judge hit with 1st and 3rd."
— Awful Announcing (@awfulannouncing) July 19, 2025
"First of all, you're not running hard to third, then you don't slide. As you said, perfect word, inexcusable."
Joe Girardi and MIchael Kay react on YES. https://t.co/gjitqcH5Jw pic.twitter.com/obTQeMiIlY
While that was an insane play from Ronald Acuna Jr., there is still no excuse for Vivas to be thrown out there, and manager Aaron Boone made that very clear after the game.
Boone said he said to Vivas afterwards “can’t happen. You can’t let that happen again.”
— Jomboy (@Jomboy_) July 19, 2025
I agree! 3rd “can’t happen” of the season though.
While that might be one play in a 7-3 loss that would not have changed the outcome, it's still a problem. It's a problem because those mistakes keep happening for the Yankees over and over again.
Those types of mistakes might get overlooked over the course of a 162-game season where the Yankees' talent advantage against most of the league might make up for them. You forget it by Saturday if they win the next game. But when it gets into the playoffs against other top teams, those little plays on the margins can sometimes be the difference between a playoff series win and a playoff series loss.
The Yankees should be in the playoffs. But those pitching issues and fundamental errors are going to seriously limit their ceiling. They need to be busy over the next week-and-a-half to help address all of that.
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!