Joe Camporeale-USA TODAY Sports

The majority of the WWE Universe hopes to see Cody Rhodes finish his story at WrestleMania 40. Jonathan Coachman also believes that The American Nightmare is in a must-win situation.

Last year, The American Nightmare won the Royal Rumble match by entering at number 30. But he failed to defeat Roman Reigns at WrestleMania 39. This year, Cody Rhodes entered at number 15 and managed to win the Rumble yet again. Now, Rhodes will be yet again challenging The Tribal Chief at the grandest stage of them all.

During a recent episode of the Busted Open Radio podcast, Jonathan Coachman shared that Rhodes must dethrone Reigns and it should be done at WrestleMania 40.

“I say yes, he has to,” Coachman said. “There’s a lot of people that say ‘Wins and losses don’t matter.’ I’ve said at times ‘It’s all about the stories. Wins and losses don’t matter.’ For this story, and the fact that he came back in a redemption story, and you lead up for two full years? That’s a long time when you’re doing TV every single week. People talk about Hulkster back in the day and all those guys, they weren’t on TV every single week. So to me, at some point, you’ve got to pay it off. And you pay it off at a big win.

“If you don’t do that, and he does it at, say, SummerSlam?” Coachman said. “To me, it’s kind of ‘whah whah whah’ moment, because everything leads up to WrestleMania. So my answer, to you, would be yes, he needs to [win].” [H/T Wrestling Inc.]

Will Cody Rhodes be able to finally ‘Finish his Story’?

More must-reads:

TODAY'S BEST
Nuggets teach Timberwolves it's never easy to knock out the champion
Panthers come from behind to take Game 4 vs. Bruins
Hawks win 2024 NBA Draft Lottery
Watch: Padres star passes father on all-time home runs list
Terrion Arnold honors his mother in a unique way
Brad Keselowski breaks 110-race winless streak at Darlington
Watch: Manchester United ties record, highlighting club's ineptitude
Celtics' Jrue Holiday praises overlooked aspect of Jayson Tatum's game
Arturs Silovs' 42 saves lead Canucks past Oilers in Game 3
Braves star leaves game early due to left side soreness
Pacers blow out Knicks on Mother’s Day, even series at 2-2
Hawks GM 'shocked' that his team won the NBA Draft Lottery
Prolific former Brewers, A's slugger announces retirement
Saints to sign veteran offensive lineman
Smother's Day: Pacers shut down Knicks in first half of Game 4
Flyers goaltender suspended from international play for three years
Pistons make wrong kind of history at NBA Draft Lottery
Watch: Pacers C Myles Turner makes absurd three-pointer in first quarter vs. Knicks
Giants place key outfielder on injured list
Broncos release former Super Bowl champion WR

Want more Wrestling news?

Join the hundreds of thousands of fans who start their day with Yardbarker's Morning Bark, the best newsletter in sports.