North Carolina Tar Heels head coach Hubert Davis. Bob Donnan-USA TODAY Sports

Preseason No. 1 North Carolina likely out of NCAA Tournament after Thursday's loss

That sound you heard Thursday night was every sportswriter simultaneously firing off the same tweet.

North Carolina's bubble burst on Thursday.

It's a shocking outcome for a program that reached the finals last year and retained the core that led it there.

The Tar Heels lost to the Kansas Jayhawks 72-69 in the NCAA championship game a season ago after blowing a 40-25 halftime lead, but still built up enough goodwill to score the Associated Press preseason No. 1 rank heading into this season.

That's historically been a harbinger of at the very least reaching the NCAA Tournament since the field expanded to 64 teams. North Carolina is poised to buck trends with its 68-59 loss to Virginia.

Entering Thursday's game, the Tar Heels ranked 90th in offensive rating (108.1) and 128th in defensive rating (100.1). They didn't excel on either end of the floor and paired with an inconsistent regular season, North Carolina likely won't have a strong enough resume to have a chance to reach the Final Four for a second consecutive year.

Key contributors to last year's tournament darlings including Caleb Love, Armando Bacot, RJ Davis, Leaky Black and Puff Johnson returned but couldn't bottle the magic that led them from a No. 8 seed to nearly cutting down the nets in New Orleans.

People were quick to point out the epic flameout this season, with USA Today national sportswriter Dan Wolken particularly critical of head coach Hubert Davis for the team's 2022-23 faceplant. 

The Ringer's Rodger Sherman took a different approach, pointing out the troll job the Tar Heels perfected by essentially having the same team that sent Duke's Mike Krzyzewski into retirement fail to make the big dance the following season. 

That wasn't the intention when North Carolina set out to avenge its championship game loss, but it's one of the few things the Tar Heels can hang their hat on after a season unlike any other.

More must-reads:

TODAY'S BEST
Dolphins' Tua Tagovailoa reportedly makes physical change amid contract talks
Do Oilers need more from Connor McDavid to get to Stanley Cup Final?
All-Rookie teams show gems available all over draft
The NBA has not witnessed this much parity in 50 years
Knicks expected to be 'aggressive' in upgrading their roster
Drew Bledsoe offers advice for Patriots rookie QB Drake Maye
2024 AFC revenge games: Brothers, 'Stefon Diggs Bowl' to take center stage
2024 NFC revenge games: Which game should Cowboys, others have circled?
How All-Star Race victory could turn Joey Logano's season around
Xander Schauffele's triumph could open the floodgates for his career
Anderson Silva, Chael Sonnen will finish off their trilogy in a boxing ring
Ranking the five best MLB free-agent signings of offseason
Veteran WR, former first-round pick announces NFL retirement
Oilers advance to West Final again after holding off Canucks in Game 7
Bengals star WR not expected to sign franchise tender before OTAs
Red Sox RHP diagnosed with ligament damage in elbow
Watch: Caitlin Clark shows off range with logo three, but Fever fall short
Former Dolphins receiving leader announces his retirement from NFL
Detroit Lions dominate PFF's top-25 players under 25
Hall of Famer, legendary Raiders offensive lineman dead at 86