May 6, 2025; Cleveland, Ohio, USA; Cleveland Cavaliers guard Ty Jerome (2) defends Indiana Pacers guard Tyrese Haliburton (0) on a follow through for a game-winning three-point basket in the fourth quarter during game two of the second round of the 2025 NBA Playoffs at Rocket Arena. Mandatory Credit: David Richard-Imagn Images David Richard-Imagn Images

Several sections of fans inside Rocket Arena rained down "overrated" chants on Indiana Pacers guard Tyrese Haliburton during his handful of trips to the free throw line in Game 2.

Once Cleveland Cavaliers star Donovan Mitchell heard that hymns echoing through the building, he moved quickly to silence them, motioning to the crowd with both hands to quiet down. Mitchell was right in his attempts to stop them.

As fate would have it, Haliburton wound up punctuating a fierce Pacers comeback with a game-winning three-point shot with only a second to play, making those fans who decided to poke the bear, eat their words as Indiana marched off the floor with a 2-0 series lead.

The shot itself was enough of a statement. After the game, he offered a literal one, too.

"That one was unexpected," the 25-year-old admitted with a laugh. "I didn't know we had beef, but yeah, I guess good for them. That came outta nowhere, but I think now that that label's there, that's what it's gonna be every time we play somewhere. Every time on the road it'll probably follow me until the next poll comes out, and we'll see if I'm No. 1 again. For me I just control what I can, man. Yeah. Overrate that."

The poll he referenced was a recent tally of Haliburton's NBA peers that named him the most overrated player in the league. Prior to the series, Mitchell and other members of the Cavs were quick to refute the poll in an effort to avoid giving the Pacers' star any extra motivation.

It's the same reason Mitchell tried to quiet the chants on Tuesday night. The damage had already been done, though. Haliburton heard them, then promptly silenced them with what is arguably the biggest shot of his career.

Now his Pacers lead the series 2-0, with a chance to sweep the top-seeded Cavaliers in their barn over the weekend. Should the series return to Cleveland, though, it's safe to assume that Cavs fans will keep any "overrated" chants to themselves.

Read More Cleveland Cavaliers Coverage


More must-reads:

TODAY'S BEST
Raiders give former Notre Dame star a shot at NFL comeback
Kyle Larson wins AdventHealth 400 at Kansas, earns third win of 2025 season 
Luis Robert Jr. drawing trade interest from notable contender
Steelers landed one of the NFL Draft’s biggest sleepers
Miami football player injured in car crash that killed two children
Watch: Golden Knights win Game 3 with shocking buzzer-beating goal
Insider reveals real reason why Steelers didn't draft Shedeur Sanders
Saints' QB plan revealed after Derek Carr's retirement
Telling detail emerges about Derek Carr’s relationship with Saints
Report: Kevin Durant has mutual interest with one new team
Padres make history in Coors Field romp over Rockies
Derek Carr retirement accelerates necessary Saints rebuild
Celtics rediscover their groove in Game 3 win over Knicks
Rockies' Kris Bryant gives update on back procedure, what comes next
Jake Garcia edges Corey Heim for Truck Series pole at Kansas
Connor Bedard facing major criticism for refusing to play for Team Canada at World Championship
Bill Belichick still has a chance to walk away from UNC
Jasson Dominguez sets Yankees record in three-homer game against A’s
Steve Kerr hints at ‘new formula’ Warriors will use without Steph Curry
'Unstoppable' Donovan Mitchell goes off, Cavs destroy Pacers in much-needed win

Want more sports news?

Join the hundreds of thousands of fans who start their day with Yardbarker's Morning Bark, the best newsletter in sports.