Kansas City Chiefs free safety Tyrann Mathieu Denny Medley-USA TODAY Sports

When Kansas City Chiefs star safety Tyrann Mathieu exited the AFC divisional round early with a concussion, Josh Allen and the Buffalo Bills offense took full advantage.

Buffalo was able to get the ball down the field en route to dropping 36 points and 422 total yards of offense. While it was not enough for the Bills to come out on top in what was one of the better postseason games in NFL history, Honey Badger’s absence was felt.

Fast forward to Sunday’s AFC Championship Game against the Cincinnati Bengals. Mathieu had been questionable all week as he had failed to clear NFL concussion protocols. As the week progressed, it became apparent that the Pro Bowl safety would in fact be able to suit up. The Chiefs made that official mere hours before kickoff at Arrowhead Stadium.

Impact of Tyrann Mathieu returning in AFC Championship Game

As noted above, the Bills were able to take advantage of Mathieu missing three-plus quarters. That included Gabriel Davis putting up a single-game playoff record four touchdown catches. The likes of Daniel Sorensen and Juan Thornhill struggled in coverage.

If Honey Badger were not able to go Sunday, the Bengals offense might have proven too much for Kansas City’s questionable secondary.

The connection of Joe Burrow and Ja’Marr Chase has been electric all season, including the playoffs. In their two postseason dates leading up to Sunday’s AFC Championship Game, the young tandem connected on 14 receptions for 225 yards.

We’re not saying Mathieu will be able to stop the young duo by himself. But he provides elite-level coverage over the top. The expectation has to be that defensive coordinator Steve Spagnuolo will now look to double-team Chase.

During the regular season, Mathieu yielded an 88.1 QB rating in coverage. It was down from the 60.2 mark he gave up back in 2020.

More must-reads:

TODAY'S BEST
Yankees star Juan Soto has eyebrow-raising comments on upcoming free agency
Draymond Green shares tone-deaf take on fines from NBA
USWNT coach Emma Hayes instilling right mindset ahead of Olympics
Winnipeg Jets officially name head coach
Injury bug bites Orioles again as another starting pitcher lands on IL
Yankees' Hal Steinbrenner under fire over Juan Soto comments
Lonzo Ball shares eye-opening details about his knee injury
Jets QB Aaron Rodgers insists focus has been football, not politics
Hurricanes general manager steps down, leaving front office in flux
Travis Kelce echoes Patrick Mahomes in response to controversial kicker
Cowboys QB Trey Lance details how he has changed since 49ers stint
Historic NCAA settlement reached allowing schools to pay players
Celtics dominate Pacers in Game 2, take 2-0 ECF lead
Cavaliers fire head coach J.B. Bickerstaff
Connor McDavid's 2OT goal gives Oilers win over Stars in Game 1
Rob Manfred hints at big change coming to MLB
Scottie Scheffler arrest case takes another weird turn with new video
QB Russell Wilson believes Steelers can 'do something special'
Pacers star suffers injury in ugly Game 2 loss
Watch: Jaylen Brown's big second quarter lifts Celtics to halftime lead

Want more sports news?

Join the hundreds of thousands of fans who start their day with Yardbarker's Morning Bark, the best newsletter in sports.